SeriesThe Art of Living Part 22 / 62

Why Were Girls and Boys Raised Differently in Some Traditions?

What was useful about traditional ways of dividing up work—and when did they shut people out for no good reason?

What was useful about traditional ways of dividing up work—and when did they shut people out for no good reason?

“Tjaša, help get dinner ready. Luka, go and help Dad in the garage.”

That might sound perfectly ordinary in your home. Perhaps Tjaša really likes cooking and Luka enjoys fixing things. But what if Tjaša wants to learn to replace a bicycle inner tube and Luka would rather make dinner? Would the same division still make sense? And why might someone respond, “That's not girls' work,” or “A real boy doesn't do that”?

Not every family came to think this way for the same reasons. People once lived and worked in very different circumstances. Some skills were passed down mainly to girls, others mainly to boys. Dividing up tasks could make work easier to organise. But sometimes that division also determined who was allowed to learn, try something new or make decisions about their own future.

The short answer: respect the knowledge and good intentions that earlier generations tried to pass on. But when deciding who should do a job today, don't ask only whether women or men used to do it. Ask who can do it safely, who has time, who wants to learn and whether the responsibilities are being shared fairly. If you want to try something, show that you are genuinely interested and willing to work at it—not merely that you object to an old custom.

You can do this without making fun of your parents or grandparents. And without anyone having to prove their worth by how closely they fit someone else's idea of a “real” boy or a “proper” girl.

Why Did Dividing the Work Once Make Sense?

A farming family, a household in town and a craftsperson's workshop did not all need exactly the same skills. Someone had to look after food, livestock, clothing, tools, and children. Others had to sell produce, transport goods or repair buildings. Much of the work was learned by watching and doing it repeatedly: children usually saw the tasks performed by the people they spent the most time with.

If a mother often sewed, her daughter might learn by watching her. If a father made or repaired tools, his son might spend more time alongside him. In one particular family, that arrangement could be practical. It does not follow that a boy was incapable of sewing or a girl unable to understand tools. What was customary is not the same as everything that was possible.

Even the word tradition can hide important differences. One family's tradition was not necessarily its neighbours' tradition; the customs of a wealthier urban household did not always match those of a small farm. Sometimes there was a considerable gap between the ideal people were told to follow and what they actually did.

In her research into the life stories of Carinthian Slovenes from the first half of the twentieth century, ethnologist Mojca Ramšak described a gender-based division of labour, but also the many tasks women performed in barns, fields, meadows, and forests. These were far more than minor extras alongside housework. On smaller farms, or when workers were scarce, people had to do whatever survival required. The study concerns a particular region and a collection of testimonies, not every Slovenian family. Yet it challenges the simplistic picture of women always staying inside and men doing all their work outdoors. [1]

Those same accounts tell us something else that gets lost when we talk only about skills. On the Carinthian farms examined, sons and other male workers were generally subordinate to the farm's male head, while daughters and female servants were subordinate to its female head. Women worked hard, but work tied to the household and its surroundings often restricted their movement and opportunities beyond the home. So the division shaped not just what a person had to do, but also whom they answered to and how much room they had to make their own decisions. This describes a particular social system; it does not justify it. [1]

That is why it is worth asking an older person something more revealing than “Was everything strictly divided in your family?” Try: “Who did the work when someone was ill? Who taught you to cook or make repairs? Were you allowed to learn things people didn't usually expect of you?” The answer may tell you more about daily life than a sweeping claim that everything was better—or everything was worse—in the past.

When School Decided What You Could Learn

These differences were not confined to advice given at home. In certain periods, they were also written into school rules and curricula.

In its presentation of historical handicraft lessons, the Slovenian School Museum describes girls learning to sew, mend, embroider, knit and crochet, while boys learnt skills such as weaving baskets from willow strips. Today, lessons of this kind also allow museum visitors to see the practical value of basic sewing skills. This is a museum reconstruction of past educational practices, not proof that every school taught exactly the same things in every year. [2]

What was the loss here? Not the sewing or the basket weaving. Both call for precision and patience. The loss comes when someone is denied the chance to learn a different skill simply because of their sex. Being able to sew on a button is useful when you live independently; so is knowing how to use and maintain simple tools.

Physical education offers an even clearer example. An exhibition at the same museum explains that certain school exercises were reserved for boys. In 1883, girls' gymnastics was removed from the curricula under discussion; in 1901 it was once again permitted on a voluntary basis, provided enough girls enrolled. This tells us about the rules of a particular school system, not about every girl's abilities or about sport outside school. [3]

Imagine being interested in a sport today but not even being allowed to try it because the same activity was once reserved for the other sex. How would you ever find out whether you enjoyed it or had the ability to do it? Of course, sport and physical work involve real differences in fitness, health, safety, and necessary training. But a fair test is whether the activity is suitable for you and whether you can do it safely—not merely what label appeared on an old timetable.

When the Stakes Were Your Future, Not Just Household Chores

A family can often adjust who does the sewing or repairs through a sensible agreement. Historically, differences in schooling could have far greater consequences.

The Slovenian School Museum notes that in the grammar-school system it discusses, girls were granted the opportunity to sit the school-leaving examination known as the matura in 1896. In 1900, Medea Norsa passed that examination at the grammar school in Koper. This does not mean that girls had received no education before then: other educational routes existed, including teacher-training schools for girls and, later, girls' lyceums. It does mean that access to a particular examination, and to the opportunities that could follow it, did not develop equally for everyone. [4]

Here an important distinction matters: being allowed to sit the matura did not automatically mean that its certificate opened the doors of university to a girl. At the University of Vienna, courses of study became available to women gradually—the Faculty of Philosophy from 1897 and the Faculty of Medicine from 1900—and the conditions were not the same for every type of study. Some women had to pass further examinations in addition to their previous schooling. A historical step forward can therefore be both genuine and valuable without removing every unjust restriction at once. [8]

The people who sought ways forward are part of this story too. After moving to Ljubljana, Emilija Fon attended a girls' lyceum and, while still at school, expressed a wish to study pharmacy. She later became a pharmacist and opened her own pharmacy. Her biography is not proof that every young woman had the same opportunities. It shows something else: even when restrictions existed, some girls, families, teachers, and institutions were searching for broader educational possibilities. [5]

Why does this matter today? Because the words “That's not for you” can take root more deeply than people realize. They do not merely rule out one task in the present. They may take away your confidence to try a school subject, career, or skill at which you could excel.

There is another side to the story as well. At Ljubljana's Krek Domestic Science School, girls learnt cooking, table service, sewing, gardening and other household skills. In 1930, the school also introduced shorter agricultural and domestic-science courses for girls from farms in the surrounding area. Those were useful skills, but tuition fees affected who could afford to attend. [6]

There is no need to mock someone who takes pride in running a household well. The mistake would be to conclude that only one sex should look after the home, or that domestic work is worth less than paid employment. Anyone who hopes to live independently one day needs both: the ability to earn and manage money, and the ability to handle everyday life.

Tjaša and Luka: Who Will Wash the Dishes, and Who Gets to Learn in the Garage?

The following scene is fictional.

For the third evening in a row, seventeen-year-old Tjaša is helping clear up the kitchen after dinner. Meanwhile, her younger brother Luka is in the garage with their father, assembling a bicycle rack. Tjaša would like to join them because she wants to learn how to maintain her own bike.

“I'd like to go into the garage today,” she tells her mother. “Luka could clean up the kitchen for a change.”

“Garage work is really men's work,” her father remarks from the doorway. “And you're better at cleaning the kitchen.”

“Maybe I am, because I do it every evening,” Tjaša replies. “But Luka can learn too. And I've never had the chance to work on a bike.”

Luka speaks up. “But I want to finish the rack. I've only just learned how to put it together.”

No one person is entirely to blame. Tjaša has good reason to want a different skill and a fairer share of the chores. Luka is not wrong to enjoy working in the garage; that work can be useful too. Their parents may be thinking about who is already better at each job, and they want the kitchen cleared on time. The problem begins when a temporary, practical arrangement turns into a permanent rule that prevents one child from ever trying something else.

Tjaša could suggest a specific agreement: “Today Luka can help Mum clean up, and I can take a look at my bike with Dad. Tomorrow we can switch. If we don't know how to do something, we can learn.” Their father can decide which jobs in the garage need supervision. Working safely matters more than trying to prove how brave you are. The parents can also look at the actual time involved. Is one job harder, more time-consuming or more frequent?

Perhaps Luka really cannot stop halfway through assembling the rack that evening. In that case, the fair thing is to agree on another definite time. “We'll swap tomorrow after school” is a different kind of promise from a vague “some other time” that gets postponed every week.

Fair sharing does not mean everyone must do exactly the same tasks every evening. It means being fair when discussing the workload, opportunities to learn and time off. If the children really do take turns with household jobs, they both have something to gain: Tjaša learns practical bicycle maintenance, while Luka learns to manage the kitchen without constant instructions.

What If a Custom Makes You Feel Inferior?

There is a big difference between “Help me prepare lunch today” and “You're no good for anything else anyway.” The first may reflect an ordinary family need. The second puts a person down and assumes they are less capable before they have even had a chance.

The same applies to a boy who wants to work with children, cook, dance, or care for an ill relative. Imagine he enjoys working with children in a kindergarten and hopes to become an early-years educator, but at home all he hears is, “That's not a job for a boy.” It would be more helpful to ask whether he understands the responsibility involved, what training is needed and how he could gain experience. The label “for girls” tells him nothing about whether he would be a good educator. Equally, a girl might be interested in electrical engineering, carpentry, or outdoor work without rejecting her family or everything she has learned from older people.

That does not mean every individual wish is automatically wise, or that anyone should be allowed to undertake dangerous work without knowing how. If you want to operate machinery, you need appropriate training. If you want to care for a small child, you must be dependable and understand that child's needs. What matters is that people consider your readiness, abilities and whether you can learn safely—not just what they expect of someone of your sex.

If someone says no, first try to find out why. “Do you think this isn't for me because I don't know how to do it yet, or only because I'm a girl or a boy?” That is not a disrespectful question. Sometimes you will discover a serious reason, such as a risk or a lack of time to teach you. At other times, you may discover nothing more than a habit. Then you can make a fair suggestion: “Could you show me the first step and see how I do?”

Nejc and the Courage It Took to Speak Up

The following scene is fictional.

Sixteen-year-old Nejc is becoming increasingly anxious before an important sporting event. He is not sleeping well and is considering telling his coach how worried he feels. But at home he hears, “You're a boy. Grit your teeth. Don't let anyone see you're scared.”

Those words may come from a desire for him to be strong and not give up at the first difficulty. Perseverance matters. But Nejc is no less courageous for admitting that he is struggling. Sometimes it takes more courage to speak openly than to pretend that everything is fine.

Nejc could say, “I don't want to quit just because I'm afraid. I want to prepare better. I need to talk to someone about it.” If his family listens, they can work out together whether this is ordinary nervousness before a competition or something that calls for a different approach or professional help. If they ridicule him, he can seek out a trusted coach, teacher, or another safe adult.

A teenager who can say how they feel is no less able to take responsibility. Nor should a girl have to stay silent when she sees something unfair just to seem nice. Courage and caring are not opposing virtues, and neither belongs to one sex alone.

Does That Mean We Should Throw Away Every Old Custom?

No. Even when you disagree with a tradition, it makes sense to distinguish the purpose behind it from its rigid form.

Imagine a grandmother who believes everyone should be able to make at least a few hot meals. Perhaps she once taught that skill mainly to her daughters. You can thank her for what she knows and suggest that she teach her grandson as well. That way you preserve the ability to care for a family without preserving an unnecessary restriction.

A grandfather might insist that people should learn to repair something simple before throwing it away. That is useful advice too. It loses none of its value when a granddaughter learns it. And even if he is mistaken about who is capable of the work, you can still respect his skill.

Some differences in tasks make sense because of real circumstances: age, physical fitness, health, pregnancy, particular protective needs, experience, schedules, or the simple fact that someone is better at a certain job. What is unfair is turning a real circumstance into a fixed judgement about every girl or every boy. Those are two different judgments.

It also helps to distinguish a respectful conversation from humiliating your ancestors. You do not have to claim that every older person was cruel or ignorant. In the past, many people acted within the opportunities, knowledge, responsibilities, and fears of their time. You can learn diligence from a custom without being obliged to repeat its unjust consequences. Understanding why something happened does not mean approving every restriction.

When “That's How We Do Things in Our Family” Is No Longer Enough

Many family disagreements begin with one person talking about respecting custom and another talking about fairness. Both can matter. But “we've always done it this way” is not, by itself, a good reason to insist on the same rule today.

When you are assigned a chore you dislike, it is only fair to ask yourself first whether you simply do not want to do the work. You cannot reasonably leave the cleaning to your sister on the excuse that traditional roles are outdated. If you want to be trusted with repairs or cooking, you must also accept the learning, mistakes, and responsibility involved. A fair opportunity cannot be separated from a willingness to make an effort.

But if you really have been carrying more of the workload for a long time, you have good reason to talk about it. Concrete details help most: how much time each person spends, what everyone can already do, what each person would like to learn, and when you could exchange tasks. Suggest trying a new arrangement for a week or two instead of demanding that everything change overnight.

Sometimes an adult will say no even after you have explained your reasoning. If no one is being endangered, you can try again another time, find someone else who can help you learn, or start with a similar, safer activity. But if the situation involves humiliation, coercion, threats, or violence, simply insisting on another discussion is not the answer. Reach out to a safe, trusted adult or an appropriate support service. You do not have to confront a violent person alone. In those circumstances, your safety matters more than proving who is right. Article N25 addresses this in greater detail.

There is also a distinction in wider society between something that is morally unfair and something that has been legally established as discrimination. Slovenia provides protection against discrimination on grounds of sex, particularly in areas such as education and employment. That does not mean every disagreement over household chores is a legal case. Begin by describing clearly what is happening and considering what kind of help is needed. [7]

So What Would I Recommend to a Girl—and to a Boy?

If you're a girl and you are interested in something that men usually do in your family, you do not have to reject what the women in your family have taught you. Say what you want to learn, ask for a safe first step, and show that you are willing to practise. If someone says you cannot do the job, ask them to explain what specific knowledge or training you need. You can work towards gaining it. Your future is not determined by who has held the tools in your family until now.

If you're a boy and you are drawn to something that has usually been expected of women in your family, do not turn away from a useful skill because someone makes fun of you. Learn to cook a meal, care for an ill family member, talk about distress, or find a route into a career that genuinely interests you. Ask someone experienced what the work really demands, and give it a responsible try. That is not a loss of independence. The more you can do to care for yourself and others, the less you have to depend on other people's ideas of your role. Take the less enjoyable chores just as seriously.

The same principle applies to both: nobody earns greater dignity by choosing the supposedly “right” jobs for their sex. Good character shows in honesty, skill, reliability, and how you treat people—not in the label attached to a job.

An Opportunity Worth Taking

Next time you hear the familiar division at home—“girl in the kitchen, boy in the garage”—you do not need to start an argument about the whole of history. First do the work that genuinely needs doing and is fair for you to take on. Then suggest one practical change. “I'd like to learn how to make lunch.” “I'd like to know how to fix my bike.” “Could we swap jobs next week and see how it goes?”

At the same time, ask an older person why people once divided the work that way. You may hear about exhausting labour, a shortage of money, the need to care for a family, or a skill passed down through generations. Or the honest answer might simply be, “That's what we were used to.” That answer matters too, because it shows when a custom deserves a fresh look.

Keep the knowledge that helps you live responsibly. Broaden the opportunities to learn wherever tradition has narrowed them unnecessarily. And when you ask to be treated more fairly, be prepared to contribute more fairly yourself.

That kind of change is not a rejection of your family's heritage. It may be the best next chapter in it.


Sources and Further Reading

[1] Mojca Ramšak, Zgodbe z obrobja: Vloge koroških podeželskih žensk v prvi polovici 20. stoletja, Slovenian Ethnographic Museum, Etnolog: https://www.etno-muzej.si/files/etnolog/pdf/0354-0316_11_ramsak_zgodbe.pdf (regional study of selected life stories; no verbatim quotations are used).
[2] Slovenian School Museum (Slovenski šolski muzej), Učne ure — Ročna dela: https://solskimuzej.si/ucne-ure/ (museum presentation of a historical practice).
[3] Slovenian School Museum, Od telovadbe do športa — šolska telovadba na Slovenskem skozi čas: https://solskimuzej.si/razstava/od-telovadbe-do-sporta-solska-telovadba-na-slovenskem-skozi-cas-zdrav-duh-v-zdravem-telesu/ (documented curricular differences in 1883 and 1901).
[4] Slovenian School Museum, Dekletom vse do leta 1896 ni bilo dovoljeno opravljati mature: https://solskimuzej.si/dekletom-vse-do-leta-1896-ni-bilo-dovoljeno-opravljati-mature/ (permission to sit the matura and Medea Norsa in 1900; not equivalent to all educational routes).
[5] Slovenska biografija / ZRC SAZU, Fon, Emilija (1897–1984): https://www.slovenska-biografija.si/oseba/sbi1023830/ (individual biography covering her education and career in pharmacy).
[6] Aleš Šafarič, Krekova gospodinjska šola in grad Jama v Šiški, Zgodovina na dlani: https://zgodovinanadlani.si/krekova-gospodinjska-sola-in-grad-jama-v-siski/ (Ljubljana case study, 1913–1930; access and tuition fees).
[7] GOV.SI, Enake možnosti: https://www.gov.si/podrocja/drzava-in-druzba/clovekove-pravice-in-enake-moznosti/enake-moznosti/ (general framework for equal treatment and protection against discrimination, not individual legal advice).
[8] Alojz Cindrič, Študentke s Kranjske na dunajski univerzi 1897–1918, Zgodovinski časopis 67 (2013), nos. 1–2, pp. 60–85: https://ojs.inz.si/zc/article/download/945/1223/3631 (gradual opening of university faculties, differences in enrolment status, and conditions for university study).