SeriesHidden Power: Dynasties, Secret Societies and the Invisible Mechanisms of Power Part 4 / 55

The Origins of Theories about a Secret World Power

In 1787, Johann Joachim Christoph Bode travelled to Paris. He was an important member of the Bavarian Illuminati, a society founded in the German lands just over a decade earlier.

AI-generated editorial illustration: an account can grow into a powerful narrative without proving that a single hidden organisation endured throughout history.

In 1787, Johann Joachim Christoph Bode travelled to Paris. He was an important member of the Bavarian Illuminati, a society founded in the German lands just over a decade earlier. According to modern researchers, he recruited only a handful of French Freemasons during his visit. Two years later, the French Revolution broke out. Between that documented visit and the later belief that a small secret group had orchestrated the revolution behind the scenes, a story took shape that outlived the organisation to which it referred. [1]

This is more than the history of unusual books. It raises the question of how we take real events, archival documents and personal connections and weave them into an explanation that promises a single answer to a major political upheaval. Some secret societies genuinely existed; their members had ideas and influence, and the authorities sometimes persecuted them. But can such facts establish the existence of an unbroken global hierarchy supposedly directing states, wars and societies from one century to the next? To understand that distinction, we must first trace the history of the claims and their sources.

The Real Illuminati and Their Afterlife

Adam Weishaupt founded the Order of the Illuminati in Ingolstadt in 1776. Researchers at the University of Erfurt, who study the order's surviving records, can trace its activities up to 1787 on the basis of currently known sources, although older historical accounts often treated its prohibition in 1785 as the end. This was not an imaginary society invented by later novelists. It had members, internal networks, plans and correspondence; the order therefore has a legitimate place in the history of secret societies. [1]

In 1785, the Bavarian authorities banned the order. During searches, they seized some of its secret papers and plans, which were subsequently published. This produced an intriguing paradox: documents through which the authorities sought to expose and restrict clandestine activity also enabled later writers to construct far broader interpretations of the order's power. By examining letters and materials from Bode's estate, researchers in Gotha have shown that the order's history cannot be reduced to its prohibition in Bavaria. They identify Thuringia as an important final centre of activity, where the order continued to operate until the summer of 1787. [1]

Yet the end of the order's documented activity does not mean that every personal connection among its former members disappeared. After an organisation has dissolved, someone may retain acquaintances, convictions or social standing. Equally, individual contacts in later years do not automatically prove that the order survived for another two centuries as a unified command structure. Establishing that would require a continuous chain of evidence concerning membership, leadership, rules, resources and the execution of specific instructions. The sources examined do not establish such a chain. The Illuminati's organisational history will receive closer attention in a separate article in this series; here our concern is how their reputation acquired a new life.

The French Revolution and the Search for a Single Hidden Cause

The French Revolution shook Europe's social and political order. For some opponents of the changes, the idea that such far-reaching consequences arose from numerous social tensions, political decisions and unforeseen events may have seemed less convincing than the explanation of a single overarching plan. If one hidden organisation was responsible, a wide range of circumstances could be assembled into a clear narrative with an identifiable author. The appeal of this explanation is psychologically understandable, but its simplicity is not evidence of its truth.

The historian Albert Soboul pointed out that the conspiracy narrative was not invented by its most famous later advocate, the Jesuit Augustin Barruel. Jacques-François Lefranc had already published the pamphlet Le Voile levé pour les curieux in 1791, followed in 1792 by Conjuration contre la religion catholique et les souverains, works that linked the French Revolution to an alleged Masonic conspiracy. Bibliographic records distinguish the two publications and their dates. Soboul also discussed early opposition to such explanations: Jean-Joseph Mounier challenged them in 1801. The debate thus arose while the consequences of the revolution were still an immediate political issue. [2] [15]

Soboul was not arguing that Freemasons had exerted no social or intellectual influence whatsoever. In his analysis, lodges may have helped spread certain Enlightenment ideas, but their membership and interests were too diverse to justify inferring a single leadership behind the revolution merely from their existence. This distinction matters when weighing both extremes: we need not deny membership or intellectual connections in order to reject an unproven claim about one hidden director. At this stage, we have not conducted a full comparative critical reading of Lefranc's and Mounier's original works; this account draws on Soboul's historical study and additional bibliographic comparison. [2] [15]

Barruel and Robison: When an Explanation Becomes a Book

In 1797–1798, such explanations found expression in two influential books. In his multivolume Mémoires pour servir à l'histoire du jacobinisme, Augustin Barruel brought philosophical circles, Freemasonry and Illuminati networks together into an account of a revolutionary plan. The English edition, Memoirs Illustrating the History of Jacobinism, was published in London in 1798. John Robison, meanwhile, had published Proofs of a Conspiracy against All the Religions and Governments of Europe in Edinburgh in 1797, a title referring to secret meetings of Freemasons, Illuminati and reading societies. Reliable library catalogues establish the existence, authorship and dates of these editions. [3] [4]

Historical lithograph depicting the French Jesuit writer Augustin Barruel in clerical clothing, published in 1825.
Augustin Barruel in a posthumous lithograph by Auguste Pidoux after Desrosiers (1825). Barruel had published his influential interpretations of the French Revolution in 1797–1798. Image: Auguste Pidoux, po Desrosiersu, litografija Augustina Barruela (1825); Wikimedia Commons; javna domena. Public domain (Public Domain Mark – designation, not a license)

The publication of the books was itself a historical event: claims were written down, printed and offered to readers as an explanation of what had happened. Yet this is where a crucial error, often repeated in later accounts, can arise. A book entitled 'Proofs of a Conspiracy' establishes that its author claimed to have evidence; the title does not itself prove the truth of every assertion inside it. We would still need to examine separately each document the author cited, its date, its meaning in its original context and the chain connecting an alleged plan to a particular historical event.

Nor should Barruel's and Robison's arguments automatically be treated as two wholly independent confirmations of the same story. They published around the same time, amid related political disputes, but we have not yet undertaken a parallel critical reading of their complete original works. The historian Michael Taylor examined their influence on British conservative responses between 1797 and 1802; however, we used only the accessible academic abstract of his article. We therefore do not claim either that the two books were identical or that they were entirely independent. Establishing that would require a closer examination of the texts and any material borrowed between them. [5]

Print also changed how the story travelled. It was no longer tied solely to rumours or to the records of the actual order. A reader in another city or country could adopt the whole explanation, bring it into a local political dispute and present it as something already 'proved' in a book. In this way, continuity of narrative could arise without continuity of the organisation the narrative claimed to describe.

Across the Atlantic in 1798: A Sermon and Washington's Letter

In the spring of 1798, similar claims were heard in the United States. On 9 May, the clergyman Jedidiah Morse warned in a sermon of alleged Illuminati influence and referred to Robison's book. An academic discussion of the sermon places it within contemporary American religious and political debates. This establishes that the theory circulated and reached a new audience, not that the Bavarian order actually exercised unified command in America. We have not read the complete original sermon from beginning to end at this stage. [6]

The example of George Washington is particularly instructive. In a letter to George Washington Snyder dated 24 October 1798, he responded to an interpretation of his earlier remarks about the Illuminati. Washington believed that certain teachings associated with the Illuminati, as well as Jacobin principles, had spread to the United States. At the same time, he explicitly explained that he did not believe American Masonic lodges, as organisations, were intentionally spreading such teachings. He allowed for the possibility of influence by individuals, while rejecting a generalisation about all lodges as organisations. The Library of Congress holds the manuscript of the letter; for a closer reading, we also consulted the historical transcription published by Julius Friedrich Sachse in 1915. [7] [8]

That distinction is essential. The letter is primary evidence of Washington's position in 1798. It is not direct evidence that a secret leadership actually operated within American lodges, nor is it a general proof that nobody ever tried to spread particular ideas. His words must be understood as a historical response within a specific correspondence, not as a timeless endorsement of everything now attributed to the Illuminati. We identified the manuscript through the library catalogue but did not produce a fresh palaeographic transcription of every page. [7] [8]

When Political Satire Becomes a Fake 'Secret Document'

About a century after the early disputes over the Illuminati, an even more dangerous form of the same narrative pattern emerged: a text presented not merely as an interpretation, but as the supposed record of a secret plan. The Protocols of the Elders of Zion first appeared in 1903 in the Russian newspaper Znamia. It claimed to reveal a Jewish conspiracy to rule the world. The status of this claim is not an open historical question: the Protocols are a documented antisemitic forgery, not an authentic record of a meeting and not evidence of collective action by Jews. [9]

The United States Holocaust Memorial Museum traces the textual origins of the forgery. Much of its material was drawn from a political satire written by Maurice Joly in 1864, in which Jews were not even the subject. Other motifs can be connected with Hermann Goedsche's novel Biarritz of 1868. In 1921, the journalist Philip Graves published a comparison of passages in the London newspaper The Times, exposing extensive borrowing from Joly's text. The finding that the Protocols are a forgery is therefore not merely a modern moral judgement: it rests on a verifiable history of compilation, false attribution and exposure. We have not independently transcribed and compared all the original editions of the three works; we rely on the comparison documented by the museum. [9] [10]

The consequences of the forgery went far beyond a false attribution of authorship. It was used to spread anti-Jewish prejudice, demonisation and propaganda, including Nazi propaganda. Its exposure did not prevent its further circulation. Here we can see how the appearance of a document, combined with the repetition of an invented claim, can create an illusion of authority even after the text has been shown to be inauthentic. These consequences must be stated plainly, without drawing a false equivalence between the established forgery and the baseless accusation against the people it targeted. [9]

Yet another distinction matters here: criticism of a particular banking transaction, political decision, media organisation or influential individual is not, in itself, the same as an antisemitic conspiracy narrative. Such criticism must be assessed against the facts about specific acts and responsibilities. It crosses into prejudice when verifiable individual responsibility is replaced by an idea of inherited or collective guilt attaching to an entire religious or ethnic community. Research must guard this distinction as carefully as the difference between an authentic document and a forgery.

The Twentieth Century: Old Stories, New Audiences

Narratives about secret societies did not disappear with the nineteenth century. In 1924, Nesta Helen Webster published Secret Societies and Subversive Movements, whose title shows that interest in the supposed political role of secret societies remained alive. The library catalogue confirms the book's publication; it does not, by itself, establish which later writers read it, how they adopted its arguments or which of its conclusions were true. Those are further questions about the reception of the work, not facts that can be inferred from its bibliographic record alone. [11]

In 1964, the historian Richard Hofstadter described a distinctive style of political explanation in The Paranoid Style in American Politics, in which an opponent is portrayed as an extraordinarily powerful, tightly organised and almost omnipresent force. His 'paranoid style' is a concept in historical and rhetorical analysis, not a clinical diagnosis of someone who questions official accounts. Nor should this framework serve as a shortcut: describing a claim as 'paranoid' does not mean that the documents cited in its support have been examined. We must first establish exactly what the claim says and what evidence it rests upon. [12]

In later decades, different motifs could be woven into new narratives: the Illuminati name, images of financial and political power, fears of centralisation, religious expectations concerning the end of history and mistrust of international institutions. In A Culture of Conspiracy, the political scientist Michael Barkun describes contemporary 'New World Order' theories as a convergence of religious and secular currents that developed along different paths before meeting. For this stage of the research, we consulted the abstract of the relevant chapter, not the complete study. His analysis provides a historiographical framework for the emergence of these narratives, not proof that all the groups they describe shared a single origin. [14]

'New World Order': A Public Political Phrase and a Different Theory

On 11 September 1990, President George H. W. Bush used the phrase new world order in an address to the US Congress. The original transcript makes the context clear: Iraq's occupation of Kuwait, cooperation between the United States and the Soviet Union, and a vision of an international order that, after the divisions of the Cold War, would rest on shared rules and cooperation among states. Such a speech is, of course, open to political criticism: we can ask whose interests the proposed arrangement served, what means were used and whether its principles were applied equally to every country. But public use of the phrase is not, by itself, an admission that a secret global command structure exists. [13]

In conspiracy narratives, the same phrase serves a different purpose. It no longer describes a proposed arrangement among states, but supposedly names a hidden structure that already controls, or seeks to control, almost every major institution. If we merge these two uses merely because the words are identical, we mistake a shared expression for evidence that they refer to the same thing. Such a leap would require documents establishing real coordination, actors and powers, not merely a speech containing a memorable phrase. [13] [14]

None of this places international institutions, private interests or concentrations of power beyond critical scrutiny. Quite the reverse: they can and should be investigated through specific questions about decision-making, ownership, financing and accountability. But when we establish a connection between two institutions, we have not thereby established that either is connected to an eighteenth-century Bavarian order. Today's networks of influence require today's evidence, not merely a historical name.

What Really Survived Across the Centuries?

Reading in sequence about the Illuminati, Lefranc's interpretation, Barruel and Robison, American responses in 1798, the antisemitic forgery and modern discussions of a 'New World Order', we can recognise a certain continuity. Across different periods, the same motifs recur: secret meetings, influence over rulers, the transformation of society and a supposed plan said to explain widely different events. We can also document the circulation of texts: a book that someone reads and cites, a speech summarised by another writer, and a forgery that borrows passages from earlier works. That is a real history of the influence of narratives.

It is an entirely different claim, however, to say that all these writers, movements, events and texts were expressions of one unbroken organisation. To reach that conclusion, we would need a chain of verifiable actions, documents, memberships and instructions spanning the decades and institutions involved. The sources examined do not establish such a chain. This is not a declaration that covert networks can never form anywhere. It simply means that we cannot infer their existence from similar symbols, recurring phrases or the fact that an earlier writer already claimed such a network existed.

Historical research must also acknowledge its own limits. At this stage, we have not critically read every original edition by Barruel, Robison, Lefranc, Joly, Goedsche and Webster; nor have we reconstructed the complete historical route by which individual editions were taken up by later authors. We can therefore speak more confidently about the documented existence of texts and some connections between them than about every direction of their influence. We must not treat gaps in the record either as proof of a secret organisation or as proof that particular later connections never existed.

The ability to judge independently is more than a research technique. It also has a moral dimension. If distrust of authority leads us to accept every story about hidden power without criticism, we have not become freer; we have merely exchanged one authority for another. But if harmful forgeries lead us to dismiss every question about influential societies with ridicule, we surrender the possibility of investigating real power. There is a more demanding path between those extremes: asking who is making the claim, what the evidence establishes, and whom a false accusation might harm. Truth requires neither blind trust nor blind suspicion.

This account therefore does not close the investigation into covert connections. It draws a distinction between the path taken by a story and the paths taken by people who may actually have cooperated. In the next group of articles, we will turn from the history of sweeping narratives to a more tangible question: how political, social and material power passes between generations, families and institutions — and what can be documented about that transfer.

Next: When Power Is Inherited (SM-05).

Documentary sources and archive links

These links lead to documents, archival records or photographs hosted by their original source institutions.

Sources and further reading

  1. Forschungszentrum Gotha, Universität Erfurt. Illuminati Research Unit. Research overview of the order's history, the prohibition of 1785, Bode's visit to Paris in 1787 and the surviving archival material. Research institution Source
  2. Albert Soboul (1974). La franc-maçonnerie et la Révolution française. Annales historiques de la Révolution française, 215, 76–88. Historical analysis of Lefranc, Barruel, Mounier and competing interpretations of Freemasonry's political role. Original study Source
  3. John Robison (1797). Proofs of a Conspiracy against All the Religions and Governments of Europe. Edinburgh; the library record establishes the author, title and year. The complete book has not been critically examined. Wellcome Collection Source
  4. Augustin Barruel (1798, English edition). Memoirs Illustrating the History of Jacobinism. London, four volumes, translated by Robert Clifford; the original French edition began appearing earlier. The information was used at the bibliographic level. University of Pennsylvania – Online Books Page Source
  5. Michael Taylor (2014). British Conservatism, the Illuminati, and the Conspiracy Theory of the French Revolution, 1797–1802. Eighteenth-Century Studies, 47(3). The academic abstract was consulted, not the complete article. DOI Source
  6. Jedidiah Morse (9 May 1798), sermon concerning an alleged Illuminati conspiracy; discussed bibliographically and historically in Jonathan M. Yeager (ed.), Early Evangelicalism: A Reader (2013), excerpt A Conspiracy Theorist’s Theory. A summary of the edition was used, not the full sermon. Oxford Academic Source
  7. George Washington (24 October 1798). George Washington to George Washington Snyder. George Washington Papers, Series 4, Library of Congress. The original manuscript was identified; we have not made an independent palaeographic transcription of every page. Library of Congress Source
  8. Julius Friedrich Sachse (ed., 1915). Washington’s Masonic Correspondence. Historical printed transcription of Washington's letter to Snyder, 24 October 1798; it should be read alongside the archival identity of the manuscript. Project Gutenberg Source
  9. United States Holocaust Memorial Museum. An Antisemitic Conspiracy: The Protocols of the Elders of Zion. Documented origins of the forgery, first publication in 1903, textual sources and propagandistic consequences. Holocaust Encyclopedia Source
  10. United States Holocaust Memorial Museum. The Times, August 17, 1921. Archival presentation of Graves's comparison of the forged Protocols with Maurice Joly's satire; we have not independently compared every original edition of the works involved. Archival presentation Source
  11. Nesta Helen Webster (1924). Secret Societies and Subversive Movements. Edition confirmed by a library catalogue; the book's precise contents and influence on particular later writers have not been investigated in full at this stage. University of Pennsylvania – Online Books Page Source
  12. Richard Hofstadter (1964). The Paranoid Style in American Politics. Harper’s Magazine. Original essay used as a framework for interpreting political rhetoric, not as a diagnosis of individuals or proof of any particular conspiracy. Original publication Source
  13. George H. W. Bush (11 September 1990). Address Before a Joint Session of Congress. Original transcript containing the phrase new world order in the context of the Gulf crisis and cooperation among states. The complete accessible transcript was checked at C1. Miller Center, University of Virginia Source
  14. Michael Barkun (2003). New World Order Conspiracies I: The New World Order and the Illuminati. In A Culture of Conspiracy: Apocalyptic Visions in Contemporary America, ch. 3, pp. 39–64. The academic abstract was consulted, not the complete chapter. DOI Source
  15. Charles Porset (1990). Les Francs-maçons et la Révolution (autour de la « Machine » de Cochin). Annales historiques de la Révolution française, 279, pp. 14–31, especially note 4 (Lefranc's distinct publications of 1791 and 1792). Also compared with the Bibliothèque nationale de France catalogue; neither complete work has yet been critically read. Original historiographical study Source