SeriesIsrael and Palestine: Is the Israeli Occupation of Palestine Justified? Part 2 / 12

Who Owned the Land Before the Establishment of Israel?

Who owned and used land in Palestine before 1948? An examination of Ottoman land law, the British Mandate and patterns of ownership.

Symbolic artistic illustration of land, land use and farming before 1948. It does not depict an identified parcel or an original land deed.

Who held the land before the State of Israel was established?

When Palestine before 1948 is discussed, an apparently simple question often arises: was the land Arab, Jewish, or state-owned? The answer matters, but this division can be misleading unless we explain what it means to “hold land.” Registered ownership, cultivation rights, inherited use rights, tenancy, communal village use, public land, and political authority are not the same thing. Someone could cultivate land and hold legally protected interests even if those rights had not been recorded in a modern land register. Conversely, someone could have a registered title while tenants lived or worked on the property.

This is the starting point of the article. We are not looking for a map that awards the entire country to a single community. We examine the rights that existed before 1948, the grounds on which people asserted them, and how war, displacement, and new legislation changed both possession in practice and legal standing. The historical question of how two national communities justified their claims to self-determination is addressed in the preceding article, “Who Does Palestine Belong To?” Here our focus is land, homes, documents, and legal categories.

The land had owners and users long before the British Mandate

Before British rule, the territory had been part of the Ottoman Empire for centuries. The Ottoman Land Code of 1858 recognised several categories of land. They cannot be reduced to a simple distinction between “private” and “state” without losing important meaning.

Mulk generally denoted a form of private ownership. For miri land, the state retained the ultimate title, while individuals or families could acquire extensive rights of use that were often transferable and inheritable. Waqf concerned endowed property, generally dedicated to religious or charitable purposes. Matruka referred to land intended for public or communal use, such as roads and certain grazing areas. Mawat denoted a particular legal category of uncultivated or remote land, but it cannot simply be equated with “land without rights.” Under the village arrangement known as musha'a, village households could hold shared or apportioned rights; this was a pattern of possession and cultivation, not an independent sixth land category equivalent to those laid down in the code. [1] [2] [3]

In practice, formal rules interacted with local customs. Families might have used land for decades while official entries remained incomplete; elsewhere, the registered holders of large estates were urban landowners. Historian Ruth Kark describes how Ottoman land reforms and registration contributed to the emergence of large estates and changes in peasants' rights. This is not the story of a single community: transactions involved local owners, Arab large landowners, foreign investors, church institutions, and Jewish individuals and organisations. [1] [2]

The key implication is this: the classification of land as miri under Ottoman law does not mean that the people who cultivated or inherited rights in it had no rights. Equally, the existence of communal village use does not prove each villager's exclusive personal ownership of a specific parcel.

What did British officials actually measure?

After the First World War, Palestine came under a British Mandate. The authorities kept land registers, tax lists, settlement records, and different procedures for establishing legal titles. Registration, however, was not completed to the same degree throughout the territory.

The original British publication Village Statistics, April 1945 states that it describes conditions as of 1 April 1945. Its figures on land area and ownership were compiled from land-tax distribution lists, urban property valuation records, and special tax records for the Beersheba subdistrict. It classified land as “Arabs,” “Jews,” “Public,” and “Others,” applying specific rules to municipal and local council holdings within the public category. These were administrative and fiscal data, not a set of final court rulings establishing the title to every parcel. [4]

The distinction also matters for the unit dunum: in Mandate Palestine it represented an area of approximately 1,000 square metres, so one million dunums amounted to approximately one thousand square kilometres. But the numbers mean little until we specify the date, territory, and classification they describe.

The original British publication is primary evidence of how officials recorded the figures at the time. A later reconstruction by Sami Hadawi in 1970, Village Statistics 1945: A Classification of Land and Area Ownership in Palestine, uses those figures to present an explained aggregate classification. It is a valuable but subsequent statistical and editorial treatment, which must be attributed accordingly. Its reclassifications must not be passed off as an unchanged original British table. [4] [5] [6]

How was the territory classified in 1945?

For 1945, there is a crucial evidentiary distinction: the original British statistical classification, also reproduced in an annex to a 1947 United Nations report, differs from Hadawi's later analytical classification of 1970. Both start from the same total land area but group and reassign categories differently. [4] [5] [6] [15] [16]

United Nations General Assembly document A/AC.14/32/Add.1 of 11 November 1947, “Appendix 6: Extracts from Village Statistics – 1945,” reproduces the original aggregate table for 1 April 1945:

Original aggregate category Dunums
Arabs 12,574,774
Jews 1,491,699
Public (as recorded in the aggregate table) 11,950,658
Others 142,050
Roads, Railways, Rivers & Lakes 163,842
Total land area in the statistical aggregate used 26,323,023

A caution about “Public”: a direct visual examination of the final row of the original UN annex A/AC.14/32/Add.1 (11 November 1947, page 4 of the scanned document, “Grand Total” table) confirmed all the figures above. The original Public category includes, among other things, 10,573,110 dunums of uncultivable land in the Beersheba subdistrict, which Hadawi subsequently treated separately as land whose ownership had not been conclusively determined. The original 11,950,658 dunums recorded as Public must therefore not be portrayed as 11.95 million dunums of legally undisputed state property. The 163,842 dunums of transport infrastructure and water areas are shown separately in the original table. [15] [16] [5]

Subtracting the 10,573,110 dunums of Beersheba land with unresolved status from the original Public category leaves 1,377,548 dunums. Adding the separately recorded area of roads, railways, rivers, and lakes produces 1,541,390 dunums. This last figure is thus an analytical subtotal combining two original categories after the exclusion of Beersheba, not an independent category labelled “Public” in the original table. This corrects the earlier C1/v1 draft precisely. [16]

In his 1970 study, Sami Hadawi reworked the table. In his classification, he included the 142,050 dunums labelled “Others” in the Arab category and transferred another 49,700 dunums from the public category to the Arab category because of ownership of plantations and cultivators' hereditary rights. He removed Beersheba from the public group, producing a different, explicitly interpretive breakdown: [5] [6]

Hadawi's analytical classification (1970; 1945 data base) Dunums Share of total land area
Arabs 12,766,524 48.50%
Jews 1,491,699 5.67%
Public (after reclassification, including transport and water areas) 1,491,690 5.67%
Beersheba — “uncultivable,” land with unsettled title 10,573,110 40.16%
Total 26,323,023 100%

The arithmetic is transparent: 12,574,774 + 142,050 + 49,700 = 12,766,524 (Hadawi's Arab category); 1,377,548 + 163,842 − 49,700 = 1,491,690 (his Public category). This does not represent a physical transfer of ownership between 1945 and 1970. It is a reclassification of the same historical data. Nor should “Others” be equated with a single ethnic identity without explanation: Hadawi himself recognised the possible diversity within that category. [5] [6] [16]

This article does not claim that every area attributed to “Arabs” had been definitively registered as the private property of a particular Palestinian individual. Nor does it claim that all land in the “Public” category was held under an exclusive, undisputed state title. This was an administrative and statistical description, based in part on tax records, not a collection of judicial decisions on each parcel. [4]

Beersheba is the most important methodological qualification. In Hadawi's later analysis its 10,573,110 dunums were treated separately because their legal title was not conclusively settled. This does not prove that the land was empty or “belonged to no one”; nor does it establish the private ownership of every parcel by a particular tribe. Identifying specific Bedouin land rights would require further documents and legal examination. [5] [7] [16]

Used carefully, these sources allow us to reject the claim that, by April 1945, Jewish buyers had already been registered as owners of most of Mandate Palestine. Yet the share of landownership is not, by itself, a measure of state sovereignty, nor does it settle the two national communities' rights to self-determination. That is the subject of PL-01.

The difference between 1945 and 1946

A supplement to the British Survey of Palestine estimates that the area of Jewish-owned land on 31 December 1946 was 1,624,000 dunums. It expressly notes that this figure excludes land used by Jews as lawful tenants or in other capacities when the ownership was not registered in their names. [8]

This figure does not contradict the April 1945 statistics merely because it is larger: both the date and the method of compilation differ. On the same page, the supplement also records 11,506 dunums purchased from Arab and other non-Jewish sellers during 1945 and 35,331 dunums during 1946. These are different and narrower measures than the full difference between the two aggregate estimates (132,301 dunums). Consequently, the 132,301-dunum difference must not be described as an exact measure of land purchases without reconciling the records and methods underlying the two estimates. [8]

Evidentiary limitation in C2/v2: The figures for 31 December 1946 were checked against a publicly accessible transcription of page 30 of the 1947 *Supplement to A Survey of Palestine*, which refers readers to pages 243–245 of the main *A Survey of Palestine*. This does not mean that scanned page 244 of the original main publication was examined directly. The 1,624,000-dunum estimate also appears in a later BADIL overview (2006–2007), but that secondary source does not replace direct examination of the British facsimile. The limitation remains explicitly acknowledged. [8] [18]

Land purchases were real — but they were not purchases of an entire country

Jewish communities lived in Palestine before modern Zionist migration. During the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, Jewish immigrants, private investors, and institutions purchased land for settlement. Such transactions are historically documented; it would be unfair to claim that every acquisition of land involved violence or was unlawful. [1] [2] [8]

At the same time, a legally valid sale between a seller and a buyer does not tell us everything about the people who cultivated the land. Some parcels formed part of larger estates belonging to urban or absentee landowners; other interests might arise from tenancy, village arrangements, or long-established cultivation. The validity of the seller's legal title, the protection of tenants, and the consequences of displacement are distinct questions. [2] [3]

We therefore need to reject two equally oversimplified narratives: that Jews as a community “simply bought” the land, and that Jewish buyers could never acquire any legitimate land rights. What matters is which land, from whom, when, under which legal arrangements, and with what consequences for the people already living there.

In 1947, borders were proposed — not a sale of individual plots

On 29 November 1947, the UN General Assembly adopted resolution 181 (II), recommending the partition of Palestine into a Jewish state and an Arab state with an economic union and a special regime for Jerusalem. This was a political and territorial plan, not a collection of land title entries. More importantly, the plan itself included restrictions on expropriation in its provisions protecting minority rights. Chapter 2, paragraph 8 provided that land owned by an Arab in the Jewish state or by a Jew in the Arab state could only be expropriated for a public purpose, with full compensation paid before dispossession. [9]

This directly demonstrates that the proposed state border did not imply an automatic transfer of all private parcels to members of the majority nation. Even the partition plan distinguished state authority from individual property ownership. The plan was not implemented as envisaged; war followed. But what it actually prescribed remains important for understanding the legal principle proposed at the time.

What did the 1948 war change?

The war of 1947–1949 caused large-scale Palestinian displacement, including flight from fighting, forced expulsions, fear, and other circumstances that varied from place to place. Some refugees ended up outside the borders of the newly established State of Israel; others remained within it but could not regain access to their former homes or land. Neither the reasons for departure nor their legal consequences should be generalised across all villages or families.

For property rights, the key distinction is between the loss of actual possession and the examination of an earlier legal title. Homes and fields did not cease to raise questions of property rights simply because their inhabitants lost access to them.

On 11 December 1948, paragraph 11 of UN General Assembly resolution 194 (III) supported the return, at the earliest practicable date, of refugees wishing to return to their homes and live at peace with their neighbours, and envisaged compensation for those choosing not to return or for loss of or damage to property under specified conditions. A General Assembly resolution must not be presented as an already executed judicial determination of every individual claim. It does, however, unequivocally show that restitution and compensation were recognised as international concerns by 1948. [10]

How did new legislation affect the land?

Following the establishment of Israel, specific legal mechanisms were developed that affected real estate and the property of displaced persons.

The Absentees' Property Law of 1950 defined an “absentee” broadly in section 1 by reference to a particular period, location, and other circumstances. Under section 4, rights in “absentees' property” vested in the Custodian of Absentees' Property. The rule did not depend solely on whether a person had personally signed away ownership. The law also provided procedures for certifying that a person was not an “absentee” in certain cases and for releasing property; it would therefore be inaccurate to say that the law allowed no exceptions. Nevertheless, its application could also affect people who remained in the new state after the war but were no longer living in their former homes. [11]

The Development Authority (Transfer of Property) Law of 1950 created a body empowered to acquire, administer, and dispose of property. Its provisions can now be checked more directly: UN document A/AC.25/W/58 (9 February 1951) includes an English translation which, according to the document, was forwarded by Israel's Ministry of Finance on 16 October 1950. Section 2 established the Development Authority; section 3 empowered it, among other things, to acquire, sell, or otherwise transfer property; and section 6 governed transfers to it by persons and institutions authorised to do so. [12] [17]

The rules for subsequent sales were not unrestricted. Under section 3(4)(a), land designated for transfer to public ownership could be sold to a limited class of recipients: the state, the Jewish National Fund, a duly approved institution for the settlement of landless Arabs, or a local authority. For another category of real property, section 3(4)(b) generally required a prior offer to the Jewish National Fund. For transfers of real property, section 3(4)(d) required a government decision in each case. The law thus established a specific framework for disposing of property; it does not automatically prove that every subsequent sale or acquisition followed the same procedure. [17]

The Land Acquisition (Validation of Acts and Compensation) Law of 1953, in section 2, established a mechanism for acquiring land for development, settlement, or security where specified conditions were met. These included that the land was not in its owner's possession on 1 April 1952, had been used or designated for the stated purposes during a defined period, and was still required for those purposes. Section 3 provided for monetary compensation and, subject to certain conditions, an offer of substitute land to an owner whose main livelihood had depended on cultivating the land. The existence of a statutory right to compensation does not, in itself, establish that an individual claimant actually received compensation or that the compensation was adequate. The sequence matters: loss of possession could become the factual situation upon which a later legal transfer of ownership was based. Whether such an arrangement was fair, or complied with other legal obligations in every case, requires separate assessment. [13]

This is an account of Israeli domestic law, not an automatic ruling on the international-law legality of every expropriation. Nor does this article conflate these post-war property transfers with the different legal position of land Israel occupied in 1967: the next article, on the law of occupation, addresses that subject.

Why do documents relating to individual parcels matter?

Aggregate figures are valuable for understanding the proportions of different land categories. They cannot tell us who owned a particular house or grazing area.

The United Nations Conciliation Commission for Palestine (UNCCP) began a programme in 1952 to identify and value property belonging to Arab refugees. In its 1961 report it referred to approximately 450,000 forms covering immovable property owned by Arab individuals. This is not equivalent to 450,000 distinct owners, 450,000 households, or 450,000 judicially upheld claims. The forms reflect extensive documentation of individual property units, which must be distinguished from later decisions on return and compensation. [14]

An account of a particular home therefore requires the parcel designation, a chronology of possession, land registration or tax records, contracts, any administrative or judicial decisions, and evidence of displacement or transfer of ownership. Cases such as Iqrit, Kafr Bir'im, and disputes in East Jerusalem have different histories and legal proceedings. They cannot responsibly be resolved by pointing to a single map from 1945. Detailed documentation of such cases belongs in the article on Palestinian homes (PL-05).

Which arguments withstand scrutiny?

The argument of Jewish land purchasers: There were documented lawful land transactions, registered titles, and historical examples of Jewish cultivation. These rights are no less valid because the claimant belongs to the Jewish community. But the purchase of a particular parcel does not establish ownership of neighbouring villages' properties or of most of the country. [1] [2] [8]

The argument of Palestinian owners and users: Before Israel's establishment, Palestine had Arab private landowners, tenants, cultivators, and communities with rights in land. Some rights were recorded in registers; others arose under more complex systems of possession and use. War and subsequent legislation affected the ability of many people to use or recover their homes and land. Yet it would also be wrong to declare every piece of land lacking completed registration to have been conclusively established as the private property of a specific individual. [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [11] [14]

The argument of state administration and security: States may adopt domestic rules on public property, expropriation, and emergency needs. Domestic legislation alone, however, cannot determine whether a particular measure complies with every right of the people affected and with international obligations. In particular, calling land “state-owned” is not enough without establishing the rights of use, inheritance, or compensation that may attach to it.

Understanding the land question calls for equal respect for evidence, not an identical outcome in every dispute. Where a document supports a specific legal title, that title must be acknowledged. Where evidence is limited, the limitation must be stated. Where a government or political movement turns the property of a number of individuals into an exclusive claim over an entire country, the distinction must be made clear.

Conclusion: so who owned the land?

Before Israel's establishment, land did not belong to a single, homogeneous group. There were Arab and Jewish private owners, various religious and other institutions, state and municipal land, village and communal use rights, and large areas where titles had not been conclusively settled. British figures for 1945 and subsequent analyses offer an approximate overview of the proportions involved, but they do not resolve ownership of every parcel.

The historical record shows that the area registered or statistically attributed to Jewish owners was far less than half of Mandate Palestine. Nor does it justify automatically treating all remaining land as the private property of a particular population. The vast areas of Beersheba with uncertain legal classifications show why that simplification fails.

The central lesson is both legal and human: a change of state borders or government does not, by itself, extinguish the land rights of people who live there, have a home there, or cultivate the land. Whether a specific transfer was lawful, whether rights were protected, and whether effective compensation was provided require scrutiny of the evidence and the applicable law—not the claim that one people's historical rights erase the rights of another.

Documentary sources and archive links

These links lead to documents, archival records or photographs hosted by their original source institutions.

Sources and further reading

  1. Ruth Kark and Nadav Solomonovich, Land Privatization in Nineteenth-century Ottoman Palestine, Islamic Law and Society 22(3), 2015, pp. 221–252. Academic record and abstract. Source
  2. Ruth Kark, Consequences of the Ottoman Land Law: Agrarian and Privatization Processes in Palestine, 1858–1918, 2017. Academic record. Source
  3. The Archaeology of Land Law: Excavating Law in the West Bank, a legal-historical examination of land categories. Cambridge. Secondary scholarly source. Source
  4. Government of Palestine, Village Statistics, April 1945, original scanned publication, introductory section “B. Areas and ownership.” Digitisation. Checked using accessible extracted text; the large file did not permit an independent visual examination of every page. Source
  5. Sami Hadawi, Village Statistics 1945: A Classification of Land and Area Ownership in Palestine, 1970, p. 19. Sabil, page 19. Subsequent statistical reworking, not an original 1945 table. Source
  6. Hadawi, ibid., pp. 20 and 39: methodology, table and notes. Records the reclassification of “Others” and the definition of “Public.” Source 1 Source 2
  7. Hadawi, ibid., p. 35: Beersheba. Later interpretation subject to the limitations of the underlying figures. Source
  8. Government of Palestine, Supplement to A Survey of Palestine (1947), page 30 of the supplement, referring to pages 243–245 of the main publication for the landownership figures. Public transcription of page 30. The 31 December 1946 estimate and 1945/1946 purchases were checked against this transcription, not by direct visual inspection of the corresponding original facsimile. Source
  9. UN General Assembly resolution 181 (II), 29 November 1947, Plan of Partition with Economic Union, Part I, Declaration of Rights, Chapter 2, paragraph 8. Yale Avalon transcription; official UN Digital Library record. Source 1 Source 2
  10. UN General Assembly resolution 194 (III), 11 December 1948, paragraph 11. Official UN record; UNCCP historical discussion. Source 1 Source 2
  11. Israel, Absentees' Property Law, 1950, sections 1, 4, 27, and 28. UN text archive; unofficial English transcription. In the event of legal disagreement, the authoritative Hebrew text should be consulted. Source 1 Source 2
  12. Israel, Development Authority (Transfer of Property) Law, 1950, sections 2, 3(4), and 6; see the officially transmitted translation at [S17].
  13. Israel, Land Acquisition (Validation of Acts and Compensation) Law, 1953, sections 2 and 3. Unofficial English translation with caveat; Hebrew text under “חוק רכישת מקרקעין (אישור פעולות ופיצויים)” on Wikisource. For a definitive legal reading, consult the official Hebrew law. Source
  14. UNCCP, Palestine Refugees; Repatriation and Resettlement, 1961, paragraphs 75–76 (approximately 450,000 forms). UN archive. Source
  15. UN General Assembly, A/AC.14/32, 11 November 1947, printed p. 44, paragraph 68. Facsimile; figures 12,574,774 / 1,491,699 visually checked against the original. Source
  16. UN General Assembly, A/AC.14/32/Add.1, 11 November 1947, Appendix 6: Extracts from Village Statistics 1945, “GRAND TOTAL” row (scan p. 4, last two rows). Official PDF in the UN Documents System. C2/v2: visually checked against the original; every aggregate figure cited agrees with the table. Source
  17. UN, UNCCP, A/AC.25/W/58, 9 February 1951, Development Authority Law (Transfer of Property), 5710–1950, Annex I, containing the English translation forwarded by the Israeli Ministry of Finance on 16 October 1950, especially sections 2, 3(4), and 6. Original UN copy. The first two pages were also checked visually. Source
  18. BADIL Resource Center, Survey of Palestinian Refugees and Internally Displaced Persons, 2006–2007, historical overview of landownership under the British Mandate; cites the end-1946 estimate of 1,624,000 dunums. Digitised report (PDF). This is a later secondary source, not the original British facsimile. Source