SeriesHidden Power: Dynasties, Secret Societies and the Invisible Mechanisms of Power Part 48 / 55

Does Power Attract People Who Lack Empathy?

Imagine two candidates for a leadership position. The first is cautious, willing to listen to objections, and shares credit for success with the team.

Editorial illustration of empathy and accountability; it does not depict identified individuals or clinical diagnoses.

Imagine two candidates for a leadership position. The first is cautious, willing to listen to objections, and shares credit for success with the team. The second comes across as confident, speaks without hesitation, readily takes credit, and quickly brushes aside other people's doubts. Which of them will make the more convincing impression in an interview or before an audience? And—this is a different question—which will make better decisions later, especially when those decisions affect people who have little influence?

The idea that power attracts people who lack empathy is understandable. History has seen ruthless holders of power, and organizations may reward showmanship, competitiveness, and a willingness to take risks. But an impression is not evidence. We need to examine at least three distinct phenomena: who rises to a position, how that person acts once in office, and whether the position itself changes their behavior. When we combine these phenomena into a single story, we risk overlooking both the actual mechanisms of abuse and the people who exercise their power responsibly.

What Does “Lacking Empathy” Actually Mean?

Empathy is not a single emotion. Researchers commonly distinguish between cognitive empathy—the ability to understand what another person is experiencing or how they see a situation—and affective empathy, the emotional response to another person's distress or joy. Someone may understand human fears very well without being deterred from exploiting them. Someone else may feel deeply for those close to them yet struggle to understand the perspective of people outside their own group. Both are different from making the ethical decision not to disregard other people's needs. [9]

The psychological term Dark Triad describes overlapping but distinct personality traits: narcissism, Machiavellianism, and psychopathic traits. Paulhus and Williams introduced this research framework in 2002. Organizational studies generally examine varying levels of traits measured through questionnaires, not three diagnoses that can be assigned to someone based on a speech or a photograph. Machiavellianism refers chiefly to instrumental and manipulative behavior; narcissism to self-aggrandizement and the need for recognition; and psychopathic traits to a cluster of characteristics that can include callousness, reduced emotional responsiveness, and impulsivity. These descriptions are not interchangeable. [1]

Nor does the ability to understand someone else guarantee compassionate behavior. A person may correctly perceive another's insecurity and exploit it, or instead take it into account when making a fair decision. An article asking about “people without empathy” therefore cannot treat them as one easily recognizable group. It must distinguish a measured trait, a concrete behavior, and moral responsibility.

Rising to a Position Is Not the Same as Leading Well

In a meta-analysis published in the Journal of Applied Psychology in 2019, Karen Landay, P. D. Harms, and Marcus Credé combined data from 92 independent samples to investigate three different questions about psychopathic traits. The association with emerging as a leader (leadership emergence) was weakly positive; the association with leadership effectiveness was weakly negative; and the association with transformational leadership was moderately negative. This is not statistical proof that most leaders are psychopathic, nor does it tell us what percentage of politicians or executives have any particular diagnosis. In their moderator analyses, the authors also described differences between samples of men and women: among men, psychopathic traits were weakly positively associated with leadership emergence and ratings of effectiveness; among women, they were negatively associated with effectiveness and largely unrelated to leadership emergence. These associations within research samples do not establish innate differences between the sexes and cannot justify conclusions about any individual. [2]

The distinction matters. Someone may become visible, gain a position, or win support through decisiveness, personal presentation, networks, and a willingness to engage in conflict. Those mechanisms do not automatically align with the ability to listen to employees, acknowledge mistakes, or sustain trust over time. Rising to a position measures one outcome; performing well in that position measures another. When we equate the two, we confuse the ability to obtain power with the ability to use it well.

A meta-analysis by Emily Grijalva and colleagues on narcissism found a similar distinction. Narcissism was positively associated with leadership emergence, but not with a linear relationship to leadership effectiveness as rated by others. The authors found a more favorable association in leaders' self-ratings, while extraversion could explain some of the association with emergence. They also described the possibility of a curvilinear relationship with effectiveness. This does not mean that there is a universal ideal level of narcissism: the result depends on the measures, raters, tasks, and circumstances involved. [3]

Confidence, too, should be assessed in context. It may help in certain situations, especially when uncertainty makes clear decisions necessary. But when institutions reward only the appearance of decisiveness and ignore the verifiable quality of outcomes, they can encourage poor choices of leaders. Research tells us something about associations between traits and outcomes; how institutions select and oversee individuals is a further, entirely practical question.

What Workplaces Show—and What They Do Not

A 2012 meta-analysis by Ernest H. O'Boyle and colleagues examined the Dark Triad in relation to job performance and counterproductive work behavior. These, again, are different outcomes from appointment to a senior position. Cooperation, rule-breaking, harm to colleagues, and the quality of work performed may follow different patterns. Negative relationships within organizations should therefore be investigated through actions and their consequences, rather than through personality labels alone. [4]

A frequently cited study by Paul Babiak, Craig Neumann, and Robert Hare from 2010 examined 203 corporate professionals selected by their companies for leadership-development programs. This is an interesting and relevant group, but not a random representative sample of all chief executives. Without further sampling, results from this group cannot be translated into a claim that a specific percentage of all leaders have psychopathy. [5]

A 2025 systematic review by Carla Bueno-de la Fuente and colleagues examined 15 empirical studies, all of them cross-sectional. Such studies can identify associations at a particular point in time, but cannot, on their own, reliably establish that a given trait caused someone's promotion or that holding a leadership position produced the trait. This limitation applies even when a review appears in a scholarly journal and follows a systematic study-selection method. The review also noted the relevance of broader personality dimensions, such as extraversion, conscientiousness, and agreeableness. [10]

When we hear stories about “psychopaths at the top,” it is worth asking: which assessment instrument was used, who did the rating, what was the sample, and what exactly does the word leader mean? A company founder, a small-team manager, a minister, and a hereditary monarch are not interchangeable research categories. Nor does a study in one business sector establish the psychological makeup of every political or financial elite.

Understanding Others and Feeling Their Distress

In 2025, Meenakshi Shukla and Niti Upadhyay published a systematic review and meta-analysis of 14 studies involving a total of 5,328 participants. For affective empathy, they found negative average correlations with narcissism (r = −0.134), Machiavellianism (r = −0.291), and psychopathic traits (r = −0.347). The associations for cognitive empathy were different: for example, the average association with narcissism was not statistically convincing. That is the central point: different personality traits do not relate in the same way to different forms of empathy. [9]

But these figures are not percentages of “unfeeling people,” nor are they evidence that people with particular scores ever rose to power. The authors note substantial heterogeneity among the included studies, reliance on self-reporting, and limitations when comparing cultures and sexes. Because the final analysis included cross-sectional studies, it cannot establish a reliable temporal or causal sequence. A correlation describes an average statistical association, not an individual's destiny. [9]

The ability to understand others dispassionately can be useful in negotiations, coordinating interests, or preventing panic; without accountability, however, it may turn into a tool of pressure. Conversely, a strong emotional response does not by itself make a person just. Responsible leadership requires the ability to recognize consequences for other people, a willingness to take those consequences into account, and established mechanisms through which decisions can be scrutinized.

Does Power Change Us?

A second hypothesis suggests that selection is not the whole story: the feeling of power itself may change how a person perceives others. In 2006, Adam Galinsky and colleagues reported experiments in which participants were briefly induced to feel more or less powerful. In some tasks, participants primed to feel powerful were less likely to take another person's perspective—for example, to recognize that the recipient of a message did not have the same knowledge as its sender. This is a laboratory finding from particular tasks, not a long-term study following individuals after they assume public office. [6]

A later test is also important. In the Many Labs 3 project, researchers replicated, among other things, a specific task from the second experiment in the original study, concerning comprehension of a message. In a pooled analysis of 2,969 participants, the expected effect was not confirmed (estimated standardized effect d = 0.03; 95% confidence interval from −0.04 to 0.10). What was replicated was specifically the message-comprehension task, not the exercise involving drawing a letter on the forehead or recognizing emotions. The authors of the original study pointed to possible procedural differences and different outcomes in related studies; this is a relevant counterargument, but it is not independent proof of the original effect. Precisely for that reason, the article must not claim that every form of power necessarily eliminates the capacity to understand another person's perspective. [7]

We must preserve one further distinction: power, status, and responsibility are not the same thing. Someone may make decisions affecting the lives of others without being respected; another person may enjoy prestige yet possess little direct coercive power. A sense of responsibility may change what a person pays attention to, while the risk of being held accountable may change their incentives. These are important possibilities for further research, not proof that we have discovered one universal psychological law of power.

The Toxic Triangle: Individual, Followers, and Environment

If we explained everything through the leader's character, we would overlook why some systems expose abuses while others conceal them for a long time. In 2007, Art Padilla, Robert Hogan, and Robert B. Kaiser proposed the toxic triangle model: destructive leadership emerges through the interplay of leaders' characteristics, followers' responses, and environments that enable such behavior. This is a conceptual model, not evidence that all three elements are demonstrably present in every particular case. [8]

Imagine an institution where subordinates cannot safely object, important decisions are not explained, performance is evaluated only by the immediate superior, and promotion depends on loyalty to a person rather than the quality of work. Such an environment may reward concealing mistakes and punish those who raise concerns, regardless of whether the leader has pronounced dark personality traits. Conversely, a clear division of responsibilities, independent scrutiny, accessible complaint procedures, and protection for those who report wrongdoing are reasonable ways to limit abuse. These are institutional recommendations, not results from a single laboratory experiment.

A 2017 review by Susanne Braun organized research on leader narcissism into relationships between a leader and an individual, team outcomes, and organizational-level effects. Outcomes at these levels may diverge: an institution's business achievements are not automatic proof that it treats employees well, while poor relations in a team do not, by themselves, reveal everything about financial performance. The question of who bears the cost of a decision is therefore not a rhetorical addition, but part of assessing the actual quality of leadership. [11]

The Danger of Quick Diagnoses

When a public figure speaks coldly, acts cruelly, or makes a decision that harms many people, their actions can and should be critically investigated. But diagnosis from a distance is not the same as documenting conduct. If we say that someone lied, we need to show the statement and verifiable information. If we claim that someone abused power, we need the relevant actions and the legal and historical context. If, instead, we apply a clinical label to someone without an individual professional assessment, we replace evidence with a psychological impression.

Such caution does not protect the powerful from criticism. Quite the opposite: it makes stricter and fairer standards possible. A manipulative procedure can be described even when we do not know the perpetrator's personality structure; intentional concealment can be documented without speculating about someone's emotional life. We do not have to prove that a person feels no empathy in order to find that their action was callous. Nor should we assume that everyone with a particular measured trait is destined to behave harmfully.

In this respect, investigating power is more demanding than finding a convenient label. It requires documents, a comparison of decisions made by those responsible, consequences for different groups, and institutions capable of testing an explanation. Rather than asking what hidden diagnosis explains the entirety of history, let us return to what can be verified: who had the authority, what information they possessed, what they did, how they justified it, and who bore the consequences?

What Should Society Demand of People with Power?

Research offers a cautious answer. Some traits that may facilitate rising to a leadership position are not necessarily associated with good and ethical leadership. Average statistical associations exist between dark traits and empathy, but they are not the same for every trait or for both forms of empathy. The effects of feeling powerful are an interesting subject of research, yet at least some well-known laboratory findings have not been successfully replicated. We therefore cannot adequately explain systemic abuses merely by invoking supposedly “corrupt” individuals. [2] [3] [7] [8] [9]

It does not follow that every leader is suspicious or that people who seek influence lack compassion. A more grounded question is how society tests promises, measures consequences, allows dissent, and prevents blind loyalty from becoming more valuable than truth. Accountability does not mean expecting leaders to have flawless personalities; it means that no one receives unlimited permission to harm others simply because they know how to gain support or secure a position.

Here the scientific question touches on a philosophical one. Do we want power guided by a convincing performance, or power that can be questioned, corrected, and, when necessary, limited? Empathy without scrutiny may remain no more than a flattering self-image; oversight without human dignity can become another form of coercion. A person's inner responsibility and public safeguards are not competitors. They work best when they reinforce one another.

Sources and further reading

  1. Paulhus, D. L., and Williams, K. M. (2002). The Dark Triad of personality: Narcissism, Machiavellianism, and psychopathy. Journal of Research in Personality, 36, 556–563. source Source
  2. Landay, K., Harms, P. D., and Credé, M. (2019). Shall We Serve the Dark Lords? A Meta-Analytic Review of Psychopathy and Leadership. Journal of Applied Psychology, 104(1), 183–196. source Source
  3. Grijalva, E., Harms, P. D., Newman, D. A., Gaddis, B. H., and Fraley, R. C. (2015). Narcissism and Leadership: A Meta-Analytic Review of Linear and Nonlinear Relationships. Personnel Psychology. source Source
  4. O'Boyle, E. H., Jr., Forsyth, D. R., Banks, G. C., and McDaniel, M. A. (2012). A Meta-Analysis of the Dark Triad and Work Behavior: A Social Exchange Perspective. Journal of Applied Psychology, 97(3), 557–579. source Source
  5. Babiak, P., Neumann, C. S., and Hare, R. D. (2010). Corporate Psychopathy: Talking the Walk. Behavioral Sciences & the Law. source Source
  6. Galinsky, A. D., Magee, J. C., Inesi, M. E., and Gruenfeld, D. H. (2006). Power and Perspectives Not Taken. Psychological Science, 17(12), 1068–1074. source Source
  7. Ebersole, C. R., et al. (2016). Many Labs 3: Evaluating Participant Pool Quality across the Academic Semester via Replication. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 67, 68–82. source Source
  8. Padilla, A., Hogan, R., and Kaiser, R. B. (2007). The Toxic Triangle: Destructive Leaders, Susceptible Followers, and Conducive Environments. The Leadership Quarterly, 18, 176–194. source Source
  9. Shukla, M., and Upadhyay, N. (2025). Cold Hearts and Dark Minds: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Empathy across Dark Triad Personalities. Frontiers in Psychiatry, 16, 1546917. source Source
  10. Bueno-de la Fuente, C., Núñez-Rodríguez, S., de la Fuente-Anuncibay, R., and González-Bernal, J. J. (2025). Relationship Between Leadership, Personality, and the Dark Triad in Workplace: A Systematic Review. Behavioral Sciences, 15(3), 297. source Source
  11. Braun, S. (2017). Leader Narcissism and Outcomes in Organizations: A Review at Multiple Levels of Analysis and Implications for Future Research. Frontiers in Psychology, 8, 773. source Source