The Nine Stages of Settling the Mind: Elephant, Monkey, and the Path to Shamatha

The classical Buddhist map of nine mental abidings leads from wandering attention to effortless stability and śamatha while distinguishing the older textual system from the later elephant, monkey, and rabbit iconography.

One of the most recognizable Tibetan images of meditation shows a monk climbing a winding path behind a dark elephant and a restless monkey. Later a rabbit appears. The elephant gradually turns white, the monkey loses influence, the flames along the path diminish, and the scene eventually becomes still. Today this motif is often described as the “nine stages of taming the mind.”

That label is useful but not quite precise. The classical framework concerns the nine stages of mental abiding or settling the mind — Sanskrit navākārā cittasthiti, Tibetan sems gnas dgu. “Taming” (damana) is actually stage five of the sequence rather than the formal name of the entire system. [1][2]

The nine stages are not nine levels of enlightenment and they are not nine different meditations. They describe the gradual training of one basic ability: remaining with a chosen meditation object with progressively less distraction, dullness and forced effort. Their goal is shamatha (śamatha) — a calm, stable and clear abiding of mind that many Buddhist systems treat as a foundation for deeper insight or vipaśyanā. [3][4]

Shamatha Is Not Merely “Relaxation”

Śamatha is often translated as calm abiding, peaceful dwelling or tranquillity. The Tibetan term is zhi gnas: zhi indicates peace or calming and gnas means to remain or abide. [3]

Classical shamatha, however, is not simply a pleasant relaxed feeling. The tradition demands both stability and clarity. The mind should not continually run after other content, but neither should it sink into a comfortable fog, drowsiness or inert stillness.

The nine-stage map therefore continually balances two opposite dangers:

  • excitation, distraction and wandering attention;
  • dullness, sinking and loss of vividness.

A calm mind without clarity is not the goal. Clear attention that remains tense and agitated is not the goal either.

Where Did the Nine-Stage System Come From?

Modern scholarship identifies the Śrāvakabhūmi, a section of the large Yogācārabhūmi, as the earliest extant systematic source for the nine modes of mental abiding. This Indian meditation framework later influenced Yogācāra literature, accounts of shamatha in the Madhyāntavibhāgabhāṣya, and Kamalaśīla’s Bhāvanākrama, or Stages of Meditation. [1][5]

Important historical evidence also comes from Dunhuang. The Old Tibetan manuscript IOL Tib J 648, probably copied before 814, preserves a version of Kamalaśīla’s first Bhāvanākrama together with the nine stages of mental abiding. The framework was therefore present in the early Tibetan translation environment. [6]

It later became a central part of Tibetan presentations of shamatha, including Tsongkhapa’s Lam rim chen mo. [1][7]

The nine stages are thus not a modern meditation invention. Their doctrinal skeleton is an old Indian Buddhist system that later acquired an extraordinarily memorable visual form in Tibet.

For direct reading, the relevant Śrāvakabhūmi passage on the nine mental abidings — together with the Sanskrit text, six powers, four modes of mental engagement, and the THY-REALITY translation — is also available in Primary Texts.

The Elephant Path Is Younger Than the Doctrine It Illustrates

The textual teaching and the famous visual diagram must be distinguished.

The nine stages can be documented in early Indian and Tibetan texts. The history of the image known as zhi gnas dpe ris, however, is much less certain. Sangyeob Cha notes that surprisingly little is known about its origins despite its widespread modern familiarity. Comparative research has even proposed that Chinese ox-herding imagery may have influenced its visual form, although this is not the same as claiming that the doctrine of nine stages itself originated in those pictures. [1][2]

The Tibetan image therefore combines an older Indian meditation framework with an effective visual teaching device.

The important boundary is:

the nine stages ≠ necessarily the original elephant-and-monkey picture.

What Do the Elephant, Monkey, Rabbit and Monk Mean?

Versions of the diagram differ in detail, but the main symbolism is fairly stable.

The monk represents the practitioner.

The elephant represents the mind — powerful, heavy and initially difficult to guide. As its dark colouring fades, the image indicates a reduction in obstacles to concentration.

The monkey represents distraction and restless movement of attention. Early on it leads or pulls the mind; later it loses its influence. [1][2]

The rabbit, appearing only in the middle stages, represents subtle dullness: the danger that meditation becomes very calm while losing vividness and alertness. [8]

In many versions the rope represents mindful retention of the object, or smṛti, while the hook represents alert monitoring, or saṃprajanya. Flames indicate the amount of effort required: large at the beginning, diminishing later. [8][9]

The map therefore teaches more than “concentrate harder.” Attention must become stable, vivid and correctly balanced in intensity.

Mural of the nine stages of meditation with a monk, elephant, and monkey on a winding path.
Nine stages of meditation — mural at Buddha Park in Ravangla, Sikkim. Elephant, monkey, rabbit, rope, hook and flames function as mnemonic symbols for mind, distraction, subtle dullness, retention of the object, alert monitoring and changing effort. [1][8] Image: Prof Ranga Sai / Wikimedia Commons CC0 1.0

The First Four Stages: Learning to Return

The classical names of the first four stages are:

  1. placement of the mind (cittasthāpana);
  2. continuous placement (saṃsthāpana);
  3. replacement or resetting (avasthāpana);
  4. close placement (upasthāpana). [4][10]

At the first stage we can place attention on an object — the breath, for example — but it is almost immediately carried elsewhere. Beginners often feel that meditation has produced more thoughts. The classical explanation reverses the interpretation: for the first time we are clearly noticing how much mental traffic was already present. [10]

At the second stage, brief periods of continuity emerge.

At the third, a new skill becomes central: we notice more quickly that the object has been lost and return.

At the fourth, the object generally no longer disappears completely from awareness, although subtle distraction and dullness remain serious dangers. [10]

This changes the meaning of early success. Success is not “never wandering.” It is recognizing wandering sooner and restoring attention with increasing stability.

Stages Five to Seven: “Taming” Begins Only Here

The fifth stage is taming (damana). This is the term often used today for the whole map.

By this point the mind is stable enough for a new problem to appear: the practitioner can over-tighten control or relax into subtle dullness. The task is no longer merely to retrieve wandering attention but to regulate the quality of concentration precisely. [10]

Stage six is stilling or pacifying (śamana). Having corrected subtle dullness, the attempt to brighten the mind can create very subtle excitation. Now the practitioner learns to loosen the hold just enough for attention to remain vivid without becoming tense.

Stage seven is complete stilling (vyupaśamana). Dullness and excitation may still arise, but they are weak and can be dealt with quickly. [10]

The middle of the path therefore resembles tuning an instrument more than violently controlling the mind: a string too loose will not sound, and one pulled too tight will break.

Stages Eight and Nine: From Continuity to Spontaneity

Stage eight is single-pointedness (ekotīkaraṇa). A small intention or effort is still required at the beginning of a session, after which attention can remain continuously on the object without major dullness or excitation. [4][10]

Stage nine is balanced or absorbed placement (samādhāna). Stability is now maintained without deliberate strain. Familiarity has made what was previously difficult spontaneous. [10]

This is one of the most striking features of the classical model. Progress is not described as endlessly increasing effort. It moves in the opposite direction:

the beginning requires great effort; mastery requires less and less effort.

Once a skill is internalized, excessive control itself becomes an obstacle.

Stage Nine Is Still Not Quite Shamatha

Popular diagrams sometimes give the impression that the ninth stage is simply the final goal and that shamatha is already complete.

The classical Tibetan presentation is more precise.

At stage nine, very stable and effortless concentration or samādhi has been achieved, but it is still described as an approximation to shamatha. Full shamatha arises when that stability is accompanied by a distinctive mental and physical pliancy (praśrabdhi) that makes the mind reliably serviceable and free from resistance when applied to a constructive object. [10][11]

B. Alan Wallace therefore follows the nine stages in his modern presentation with a “tenth” chapter on achieving shamatha — not as a tenth classical mental abiding, but as the result reached after the ninth stage. [11]

So:

the nine stages lead to shamatha; they are not nine synonyms for it.

The Six Powers: What Actually Moves the Practitioner Forward?

The nine stages are embedded in another classical scheme, the six powers:

  1. the power of hearing or learning the instructions;
  2. the power of reflection;
  3. the power of mindfulness or retention;
  4. the power of alert monitoring;
  5. the power of perseverance;
  6. the power of complete familiarity. [10]

Their distribution is elegant.

The first stage relies on understanding instructions. The second develops through reflection. Stages three and four depend on retaining the object. Stages five and six depend on alert recognition of defects. Stages seven and eight rely on perseverance. Stage nine rests on familiarity, through which the skill becomes spontaneous. [10]

It resembles a general model of learning complex skills: understand, practise, detect errors, persist, and eventually automate some of the process.

That resemblance does not turn the Buddhist scheme into a modern cognitive theory. It remains a traditional contemplative model with its own philosophical and soteriological purposes.

Four Modes of Attention: Why Effort Eventually Disappears

The nine stages are also coordinated with four modes of applying attention.

During the first two stages, attention is effortful: the object must repeatedly be taken up by deliberate force.

From stages three through seven, it is restorative: attention is repaired whenever distraction or dullness appears.

At stage eight it becomes uninterrupted.

At stage nine it is spontaneous or effortless. [10]

The diminishing flames in the visual map are therefore not decorative. They represent a transformation in the way training is applied.

Mastery does not mean pressing the mind harder and harder. It means learning when effort is required and when effort itself should be released.

Five Faults and Eight Antidotes

The traditional system is even more detailed. Five major faults in the cultivation of concentration are:

  • laziness or resistance to practice;
  • forgetting the object or instructions;
  • dullness and excitation;
  • failing to apply an antidote when needed;
  • continuing to apply an antidote when it is no longer needed. [10]

The last point is especially subtle. The tradition explicitly warns that over-correction can disturb otherwise good concentration.

The five faults are opposed by eight factors: confidence in the value of the practice, intention, perseverance, pliancy, mindful retention, alertness, application of an antidote, and stopping the antidote when its job is complete. [10]

The map is therefore not a story about “defeating thoughts.” It is a system of attention regulation in which the correct degree of intervention matters as much as strength.

Lachen Gomchen Rinpoche seated in meditation before a stone house in the Himalayas around 1915.
Lachen Gomchen Rinpoche in meditation, c. 1915. The historical photograph does not depict one specific stage; it provides a broader Himalayan contemplative context in which maps of concentration such as the nine stages were transmitted as part of meditation training. Image: Alexandra David-Néel collection / Wikimedia Commons Public domain (US)

What Can Modern Attention Science Add?

Modern science can investigate some components of meditation training, but it cannot simply validate the entire traditional map.

Contemplative researchers often distinguish focused-attention meditation, in which attention is voluntarily directed to a chosen object, from open-monitoring meditation, in which the flow of experience is monitored without selecting a single object. The first category has obvious functional similarities with early and middle shamatha training. [12]

Neuroscientific reviews report changes in systems involved in attentional control, self-regulation and monitoring, while also emphasizing serious methodological limitations in meditation research. [13]

A 2023 meta-analysis of 111 randomized controlled trials found small-to-moderate improvements in several cognitive domains, including executive and sustained attention. [14] An earlier meta-analysis of controlled studies, however, found a non-significant average effect on attention and substantial heterogeneity across studies. [15]

The most defensible conclusion is therefore:

meditation training can affect some components of attention; science has not established that all human brains progress through exactly nine classical stages.

Buddhist Mindfulness Is Not Identical to Every Modern “Mindfulness” Definition

Translation requires one further caution.

Sanskrit smṛti and Tibetan dran pa, often translated here as mindfulness, primarily involve not losing the meditation object — retaining or remembering it. Alongside this operates saṃprajanya or Tibetan shes bzhin: alert monitoring of whether the quality of attention has deteriorated. [10]

This is not identical to every modern clinical definition of mindfulness, where emphasis may be placed on non-judgmental awareness of present-moment experience.

The overlap is real, but the terms should not be mechanically equated.

In classical shamatha the questions are concrete:

Have I lost the object? Has attention become dull? Has it become too excited? Do I need to correct it — or do I need to stop correcting it?

Why Is the Map Still Useful?

Because it normalizes something that often surprises beginners: instability of attention is not evidence that meditation has failed. It is what practice begins to reveal more clearly.

The map also shows that problems change. Early on, distraction dominates. When thought quiets, subtle dullness may appear. When dullness is corrected, excessive tension can emerge. Later the new task is to release unnecessary effort.

This is much more sophisticated than the common instruction to “empty the mind.”

The traditional map says almost the opposite:

the aim is not to have no thoughts; the aim is to recognize the condition of attention and regulate it with increasing precision.

What Do the Nine Stages Actually Show?

First, the historical core:

The nine stages of mental abiding are an old Indian Buddhist model for the development of shamatha. Their earliest systematic formulation is preserved in the Śrāvakabhūmi, and the scheme later appears in Kamalaśīla and Tibetan traditions. [1][5][6]

Second, the visual tradition:

the elephant path is a later pictorial teaching device, whose precise historical origins are less certain. Elephant, monkey, rabbit, rope, hook and flames turn problems of dullness, distraction, monitoring and effort into a memorable visual sequence. [1][2]

Third, the practical correction:

“taming” is not the whole path but stage five. The nine stages begin with barely successful placement of attention and end with effortless stability. [10]

And finally, the scientific boundary:

modern research supports the trainability of aspects of attention, not the nine-stage system as a universal neurological law. [12][13][14][15]

In this sense the old image remains remarkably effective. At first the monk runs after the mind. Later he walks beside it. Then he leads it. In the end it no longer needs to be pulled.

Perhaps the deepest lesson of the map is not that the mind must be defeated, but that it must be understood so well that force eventually becomes unnecessary.

Sources and further reading

  1. Academic study of the nine mental abidings and the history of the Tibetan śamatha illustration. Source
  2. Study of the relation between zhi gnas dpe ris, lamrim, and possible comparative iconography.
  3. Traditional terminological overview of śamatha / zhi gnas. Source
  4. Terminological overview of the nine stages of mental abiding and their Sanskrit/Tibetan names. Source
  5. Primary early Yogācāra textual framework for the nine modes of mental abiding. Source
  6. Manuscript study of an early Tibetan witness to Kamalaśīla's meditation tradition from Dunhuang.
  7. Classical Tibetan lamrim presentation of the development of śamatha and pliancy.
  8. Modern traditional explanation of elephant, monkey and rabbit iconography and subtle dullness. Source
  9. Academic context for distinguishing traditional meanings of mindfulness and meta-awareness. Source
  10. Detailed traditional explanation of the nine stages, six powers, four attentions, five faults and eight antidotes. Source
  11. Modern Tibetan Buddhist synthesis clearly distinguishing stage nine from full śamatha.
  12. Influential scientific framework for focused attention and open monitoring in meditation research. Source
  13. Review of meditation neuroscience and methodological limitations of the field. Source
  14. Meta-analysis of 111 randomized trials of cognitive effects of mindfulness interventions. Source
  15. Meta-analysis of controlled studies with a more cautious result for attention and substantial heterogeneity. Source