From Thought Attraction to Wealth: Mulford, Atkinson, and Wattles
Mulford, Atkinson, and Wattles linked thought to attraction, vibration, and wealth in different ways. This article compares their original teachings and the limits of their promises.
Attraction as a historical metaphor — the magnet and coin represent comparisons and promises in early New Thought writing, not a proven mechanism by which thoughts draw money.
Imagine three books standing on the same shelf. The first tells us that thoughts are not merely private events inside the mind but something like currents connecting people with influences of a similar kind. The second explains that thoughts emit vibrations and that a law of attraction, comparable to natural laws, supposedly operates in the world of thought. The third promises that a person can become wealthy by thinking and acting in the right way.
The books might appear to be three versions of the same modern guide to manifestation. Yet they were written before social media, online courses, and the successful film The Secret.
In the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, Prentice Mulford, William Walker Atkinson, and Wallace D. Wattles developed different answers to a question emerging from the New Thought movement: if an inner belief can influence a person, how far might that influence extend into the external world?
Their answers were not identical. Mulford spoke of thought currents. Atkinson used the language of vibration and attraction. Wattles formulated a system linking thought and action to the promise of material prosperity.
Their writings matter historically, but we need to distinguish what these authors actually claimed, what can be understood as practical psychological advice, and what would require independent evidence. The history of an idea does not, by itself, establish the reality of its proposed mechanism.
When a Thought Becomes More Than a Thought
In the previous article, we traced the development of mental healing and New Thought. An important shift occurred when discussions of the relationship between mind and body were no longer confined to health.
If someone believes that an erroneous belief can affect illness, another question readily follows: might a similar belief also affect success, relationships, chance encounters, and money?
This extension was not automatic. Influencing our own behavior is not the same as directly influencing circumstances beyond our control. Yet some New Thought writers began to describe thought as an active force supposedly connecting the individual to the surrounding world.
A new vocabulary emerged: thought currents, thought vibrations, mental attraction, and eventually the law of attraction. These terms did not always mean precisely the same thing. Sometimes they referred to the effects of belief on a person's attitude and behavior; at other times, they referred to the alleged direct operation of thoughts across space.
The conflation of these two levels would become one of the most persistent features of modern manifestation literature.
Prentice Mulford: Thoughts as Currents
Prentice Mulford (1834–1891) was an American writer and an early figure who became important to the later New Thought movement. His writings appeared as individual pieces and in collections under the title Your Forces and How to Use Them.
Bibliographic records identify a first volume published by F. J. Needham in 1887 and a second volume in 1888. Because later reprints and reorganized collections often combined different texts, we should not automatically assign the date on an arbitrary later edition's title page to every passage it contains. [1][2]
Mulford's central idea was that a thought is not an insignificant inner representation. In the essay Thought Currents, he compares currents of thought to currents of air and water. The essay appears in the London collection Thoughts Are Things, published by George Bell and Sons in 1908, which brings together older essays from the White Cross Library. The date 1908 therefore identifies this edition of the collection, not necessarily the essay's first publication. Mulford argues that, through their habitual thinking, people attract corresponding mental influences from others. [3]
This is not merely the ordinary advice to be careful about what we say. Mulford describes supposedly real but invisible currents capable of affecting a person's mental and physical condition.
Here we find an early formulation of the later rule that like attracts like. Cheerful and courageous people would, on this account, connect with similar thought currents, while anger and despair would expose a person to corresponding negative influences.
Such an explanation goes beyond the psychological observation that we tend to associate with people who share our interests. It presupposes a special transmission of thought between people, which Mulford did not establish by measuring the currents he proposed.
An Intriguing Mixture of Observation and Metaphysics
Part of Mulford's account can also be understood without invoking invisible thought currents.
If someone regularly talks to people who expect failure, those people's attitudes may affect that person's attention, mood, and decisions. If they spend time with people who encourage one another to learn and create, they may find more support and new opportunities.
Such influence can operate through conversation, group norms, imitation, and behavior. There is no need to assume a special vibration passing from one person to another.
But Mulford did not restrict his account to these ordinary pathways. He treated thought as something that actively helps shape a person's life, including bodily condition and external opportunities. [2][3]
This raises an important methodological question. If similar moods really do contribute to similar social connections, we have observed an effect that can be studied. We have not, however, established Mulford's explanation in terms of invisible currents.
The distinction resembles one we encountered in mental healing: a genuine effect of expectation does not confirm every metaphysical explanation offered for that effect.
Did Mulford Invent the Law of Attraction?
Popular historical surveys sometimes claim that Mulford invented the law of attraction.
His writings certainly matter for the development of the idea that thoughts attract corresponding influences. But this does not establish that he was the first person to use the expression law of attraction, or that every later version derived directly from his work.
The language of attraction appeared in a variety of religious, philosophical, and Spiritualist contexts during the nineteenth century. Moreover, Mulford's writings circulated through several publications and later collections whose dates must be kept distinct. [1][2]
A more defensible historical claim is narrower: Mulford was one of the important early writers who helped formulate a teaching about mental attraction within the milieu from which modern New Thought developed. His historical significance does not depend on assigning him absolute priority.
More important is the image he presented of a person's inner world as an active force supposedly connecting that person with other people and circumstances. Later writers would give this picture a more systematic form.
William Walker Atkinson: The Law in the Title
William Walker Atkinson (1862–1932) was an extraordinarily prolific American writer associated with New Thought, personal power, mental techniques, and occult teachings.
In 1906, the New Thought Publishing Company published his book Thought Vibration: Or, the Law of Attraction in the Thought World. Contemporary bibliographic evidence confirms the original year and publisher. [4]
This distinction matters because editions dated 1908 also exist. Their existence does not prove that the book first appeared in that year. A later edition and an original publication are separate bibliographic facts.
Atkinson's title itself clearly combines two ideas: thoughts supposedly vibrate, and these vibrations supposedly account for a law of attraction in the world of thought.
In the opening chapter, he compares this law to gravity and the attraction between material bodies. He tells readers that nature also contains a special form of attraction operating between thoughts. [5]
This marks an important shift within the texts under discussion. What Mulford presented as thought currents is described by Atkinson in the more systematic language of a universal law. That does not mean Atkinson was the first person ever to use the term.
Thought Vibrations: Physical Fact or Metaphor?
Atkinson builds his account through analogies with natural phenomena. He discusses waves, different frequencies, magnetism, and the possibility of detecting invisible phenomena once suitable instruments have been developed.
He also advances the notion that the brain is a kind of receiver for thought waves. In doing so, he draws on the contemporary excitement surrounding wireless communication and claims about telepathy. [5]
But the word vibration does not itself establish the existence of a particular physical mechanism. Atkinson uses it as more than a poetic metaphor: he attempts to explain what he regards as an actual transmission of mental influences.
With sound, we can describe oscillations in a medium. With electromagnetic waves, we can measure relevant physical quantities. For a supposed thought vibration that attracts external events, we would first need to specify what is vibrating, how the influence travels, how it can be measured, and what observations would count against the claim.
The fact that brain activity is associated with measurable electrical and other physiological processes does not, by itself, confirm Atkinson's law of attraction.
A similarity of vocabulary is not an identity of phenomena.
Atkinson offered his analogy to natural laws as an explanation of how thoughts actually work, not merely as a literary comparison. For that very reason, his claim raises questions about evidence.
Atkinson's Affirmations: Two Explanations of One Practice
Atkinson's book contains another feature that is particularly relevant to our investigation.
When explaining affirmations and autosuggestion—that is, deliberate attempts to influence one's own thinking by repeating statements—he identifies two effects. The first is a change in mental attitude and character. The second is supposed attunement to positive thought waves coming from other people. [6]
These two explanations are not equivalent.
The first can be investigated using psychological methods. We can ask whether a particular practice changes a person's expectations, feelings, conduct, or perseverance. In doing so, we must allow for the possibility that the same affirmation will not work equally well for everyone.
The second explanation claims an additional transmission of thought waves. Accepting it would require evidence of that transmission, not merely an observation that someone felt better after an exercise.
This helps explain why some older practices may remain interesting today even if their original explanations are unsupported.
If an exercise helps a person prepare for a difficult conversation, that is worth investigating. But success in the conversation would not, by itself, mean that the person had tuned into the vibrations of the universe.
Atkinson's book is therefore a revealing example of how practical work on habits and a broader metaphysical teaching were already intertwined in the same self-help text more than a century ago.
From Attracting Thoughts to Attracting Results
A further change in scale is important when considering Atkinson.
Claiming that someone attracts similar thoughts does not necessarily mean that they will attract a particular amount of money, a particular person, or an exact event.
Yet when thoughts are understood as a general creative force, the extension to such outcomes becomes almost inevitable.
In some strands of New Thought, questions about a person's mental state therefore became increasingly linked to enterprise, social standing, and material prosperity.
We should not forget that a genuine change in attitude can influence external outcomes through entirely ordinary pathways. A more confident person may apply for a job they previously avoided. A more persistent entrepreneur may take more of the necessary steps. Someone who manages fear more effectively may communicate more clearly.
But inner attitude is not the only factor shaping success in the external world. Health, available resources, education, economic conditions, social relationships, and other people's decisions also matter.
When an author moves from the possibility of psychological influence to the certainty of a material outcome, an important boundary has been crossed.
This shift becomes especially pronounced in Wallace D. Wattles's writing.
Wallace D. Wattles: The Right to Be Rich
Wallace Delois Wattles (1860–1911) published The Science of Getting Rich in 1910 through the publisher Elizabeth Towne. A digitized copy of the original edition survives. [7]
The opening chapter already reveals his starting point. Wattles does not portray wealth as a morally suspect goal but as a prerequisite for fully developing one's physical, mental, and spiritual capacities.
In his view, people need material goods to develop their abilities, educate themselves, rest, and care for those they love. This is why he writes about a right to be rich. [8]
This part of his teaching has an understandable human core: poverty can indeed restrict opportunities for development and free choice.
But Wattles moves from this point to a much stronger claim: there is supposedly an exact method by which anyone who follows it properly can become wealthy.
His book thus offers more than an encouraging perspective on financial security. It promises a universally reliable procedure for obtaining riches.
The difference between these two claims is essential.
Thinking Substance and the Creation of the Material World
Wattles's philosophy rests on the assumption that there is a primordial Thinking Substance, also called Formless Substance.
According to his account, all material forms arise from this substance. Human thoughts can supposedly be impressed upon it and help bring corresponding things into existence in the external world. [9]
This is not simply advice to imagine a goal before taking steps to achieve it.
In ordinary creation, a plan affects a finished product through action: an architect draws up plans, and builders construct a house. Wattles claims something further: by influencing a universal substance, thought can participate in the emergence of desired circumstances.
He presents these claims as foundational principles of a science of getting rich. But the word science in the title is not evidence that the method has been scientifically validated.
A scientific account would need to identify a measurable mechanism, allow predictions to be tested, and distinguish the effect of the proposed method from other causes.
Wattles's Thinking Substance is a philosophical or metaphysical premise of his system. We cannot verify it merely because someone obtains a better-paying job after reading his book.
That outcome could have many different causes.
Wattles Did Not Teach Visualization Alone
One of the most common simplifications of older manifestation teachings is the idea that a person need only think about what they want and wait for the universe to deliver it.
Wattles's text contradicts that notion more directly than we might expect.
In chapter eleven, Acting in the Certain Way, he explicitly warns that thinking without personal action is not enough. He emphasizes the need to act in one's present environment, complete today's work, and use the concrete opportunities immediately available. [10]
In Wattles's account, someone seeking a different job should not merely imagine a future position. They should also act where they are currently employed and prepare the way for change.
This part of the teaching can make practical sense without accepting the existence of Thinking Substance. A goal may influence behavior, and activity may affect the likelihood of an outcome.
But Wattles's insistence on action does not remove his metaphysical promise. He also believes that correct thinking initiates the creative activity of a universal force.
It would therefore be just as inaccurate to say that Wattles taught nothing but passive daydreaming as it would be to present him simply as an early advocate of modern goal-setting.
His system includes both active conduct and a supposed universal mechanism of creation.
Creation Instead of Competition
Wattles devotes considerable attention to the difference between a creative and a competitive way of thinking.
In his view, people should not start from the assumption that the supply of good things is limited or that the only way to advance is to take something from others. Wealth is supposed to come from creating new opportunities and greater value. [11]
This sounds appealing and contains an important ethical possibility: work that genuinely benefits others is different from success achieved through exploitation.
Yet Wattles adds a much broader claim about the unlimited availability of material wealth. In chapter three, he explicitly argues that capital and economic monopolies do not inevitably keep workers in poverty and that anyone who acts in a "Certain Way" can find another opportunity. In chapters five and sixteen, he argues even more strongly for an unlimited supply of wealth, asserting that neither government nor the capitalist system can prevent someone who acts in the prescribed way from becoming rich. [11][13]
Taken literally, such a promise is problematic.
An individual's opportunities are not wholly independent of ownership, wages, access to land, education, law, and unequal economic power. Encouraging productive work may be helpful, but it does not eliminate every external constraint.
We therefore find in the same book a useful call to create value and an unsupported assurance that any individual can overcome all economic barriers through the proper form of thought.
Whose Will May We Change?
Wattles also sets out an important ethical limit that is often overlooked.
In chapter nine, How to Use the Will, he argues against using one's will to coerce other people. He says a person has no right to use mental power to bring another under their control, even when they believe doing so would be in that person's best interests. [12]
This point deserves attention because manifestation is sometimes presented in modern online communities as a way to obtain a specific person regardless of that person's own decision.
Wattles's ethical boundary shows that historical teachings about the creative power of thought should not all be treated as unrestricted endorsements of control over others. Yet in the same chapter, he allows that his proposed mental process may unconsciously influence the conduct of other people. The tension between rejecting coercion and asserting an indirect influence remains unresolved. [12]
His teaching still presupposes that an inner state can affect external circumstances through a special metaphysical pathway.
The ethical position and the claim about causation must therefore be evaluated separately.
We can agree that people should not be coerced without accepting the assumption that external circumstances respond to our thoughts.
When Success Is Guaranteed and Failure Always Explainable
The most difficult feature of Wattles's system is its certainty.
In chapter sixteen, he claims that no combination of circumstances can prevent a person who thinks and acts correctly from becoming wealthy; he even compares the certainty of success to the result of a simple arithmetic calculation. If someone does not receive an expected opportunity, however, Wattles calls it an "apparent failure" that is supposedly destined to lead to something better later on. The explicit guarantee of success and the advance explanation of failure belong to the same system. [13]
This creates the danger of an explanation that is difficult to disprove.
If someone becomes rich, their success can be cited as proof of the method. If they do not, their failure can be attributed to a departure from the prescribed way of thinking or acting; if the desired result has still not appeared, the explanation can shift to a supposedly better outcome in the future. In this form, the claim evades testing.
But if an additional explanation is always available for why failure does not count, it becomes almost impossible to determine whether the method works as promised.
An assessment would also have to consider people who followed the method without obtaining the promised result. We would need to compare them with people pursuing similar opportunities without the proposed metaphysical technique.
We would also have to define what counts as correct application before observing the outcome, rather than only after the result is known.
Without such distinctions, a promise of universal success can become impossible to test.
Three Different Conceptions of the Same Power
We can now compare Mulford, Atkinson, and Wattles more precisely.
For Mulford, the central image is thought as a current supposedly linking an individual with similar mental influences. His account extends to character, experience, health, and wider opportunities in life.
For Atkinson, the idea of a law of attraction in the world of thought is more fully developed. He draws on physical analogies, particularly vibration and magnetism, and also includes practical techniques for self-direction.
For Wattles, the primary objective becomes material prosperity. His system combines a clearly envisioned goal, faith, gratitude, action in the present, and a supposed Thinking Substance through which the desired outcome can be brought about.
All three belong to the history of New Thought, but they cannot simply be merged into a single doctrine.
What they share is the broad conviction that a person's inner state plays a more significant role in shaping life than a purely passive understanding of thoughts would suggest.
They differ in the way they explain the proposed connection and in what they primarily promise.
What Remains if We Remove the Unproven Mechanism?
This may be the most important question for a present-day reader.
If we remove the proposed invisible currents from Mulford's teaching, we are left with the question of how environment, conversations, and expectations affect people.
If we remove the special thought vibrations from Atkinson's teaching, questions remain about habits, attention, autosuggestion, and behavior.
If we remove Thinking Substance from Wattles's teaching, we are left with clarity of purpose, consistency, the creation of value, and concrete action.
But translating these ideas into psychological and behavioral language must not create the impression that the original teachings have thereby been proved.
In fact, we have changed them.
The claim that better organization of one's work can improve the chances of success is not the same as the claim that the universe responds to a thought by creating the desired event.
The first has an identifiable possible causal pathway. The second requires additional evidence.
We can therefore recognize these authors' historical importance, investigate the usefulness of particular exercises, and remain skeptical of their universal promises at the same time.
Why Has This Idea Endured?
Mental attraction offers an appealing combination of hope and personal responsibility.
It tells people that they are not entirely powerless in the face of circumstances. It encourages them to notice recurring patterns of thought, reconsider their goals, and begin to act differently.
But the same promise can turn into the belief that a person is responsible for almost everything that happens to them.
If someone becomes ill, loses a job, or lives in poverty, it may be both unfair and inaccurate to conclude that the condition was attracted by the person's wrong thoughts.
Historical writings about like attracting like, creative primordial substance, and inevitable success are not neutral pieces of advice. They also make claims about how reality is structured and who bears responsibility for life's outcomes.
That is precisely why we need to read them in full: not just select their most encouraging sentences, but also examine their assumptions and consequences.
From Old Books to Modern Manifestation
When we encounter claims today that thoughts emit vibrations, that like attracts like, or that vividly imagined wealth can become material reality, we are hearing a vocabulary that had already taken important shape long before contemporary online culture.
Mulford helped popularize the image of thoughts as active currents. In 1906, Atkinson put the law of attraction in the thought world into a book title. In 1910, Wattles offered a detailed system of becoming wealthy that combined metaphysical assumptions with an insistence on concrete action.
We do not need to declare any of these men the sole inventor of the law of attraction to understand their importance.
Their writings show how a question about the effect of one's inner state grew into a far broader promise: that through the right thoughts, will, and conduct, people might direct not only themselves but also the circumstances around them.
The decisive question remains: how much of this actually occurs through changes in perception, behavior, and relationships, and how much would require an additional mechanism that has not been independently demonstrated?
That distinction will also help us examine later teachers and methods of manifestation. We will be able to compare them in terms of their proposed mechanisms rather than merely the appealing words they use.
Sources and further reading
- Mulford, P. (1887). Your Forces and How to Use Them (Vol. 1). F. J. Needham. Historic edition digitized from the New York Public Library. source Source
- Mulford, P. (1888). Your Forces and How to Use Them (Vol. 2). F. J. Needham. Historic edition digitized from the New York Public Library. source Source
- Mulford, P. (1908). Thought Currents. In Thoughts Are Things: Essays Selected from the White Cross Library (p. 32 onward). George Bell and Sons, London. This year identifies the collected edition, not necessarily the essay's first appearance. Title page: source ; text: source Source 1 Source 2
- Atkinson, W. W. (1906). Thought Vibration: Or, the Law of Attraction in the Thought World. New Thought Publishing Company. Original bibliographic record. source Source
- Atkinson, W. W. (1906). Thought Vibration, Chapter I, The Law of Attraction in the Thought World. Digital transcription of historical text. source Source
- Atkinson, W. W. (1906). Thought Vibration, discussion of affirmations, mental attitude, and thought waves, p. 17. Digital transcription. source Source
- Wattles, W. D. (1910). The Science of Getting Rich. Elizabeth Towne. Digitized original edition and transcription. source Source
- Wattles, W. D. (1910). The Science of Getting Rich, Chapter I, The Right to Be Rich. source Source
- Wattles, W. D. (1910). The Science of Getting Rich, Chapter IV, The First Principle in the Science of Getting Rich. source Source
- Wattles, W. D. (1910). The Science of Getting Rich, Chapter XI, Acting in the Certain Way. source Source
- Wattles, W. D. (1910). The Science of Getting Rich, Chapters III and V, on opportunity, economic structures, and creation rather than competition. source ; source Source 1 Source 2
- Wattles, W. D. (1910). The Science of Getting Rich, Chapter IX, How to Use the Will. source Source
- Wattles, W. D. (1910). The Science of Getting Rich, Chapter XVI, Some Cautions, and Concluding Observations. source Source