From Mental Healing to New Thought: How Thought Became a Promise to Change Reality
How did the belief that thoughts can change lives become part of New Thought? This article traces the path from mental healing to modern promises about the creative power of mind.
A flow of ideas — this symbolic scene shows how mental-healing ideas spread and diversified into different philosophical teachings.
We are often told today that changing our lives begins with changing our thoughts. If we want different relationships, we are advised to change our beliefs about ourselves. If we want success, we are told to develop the mindset of a successful person. And if we want to improve our health, some contemporary teachers recommend eliminating negative inner programs. Such advice brings together different ideas. Some concern psychological processes, such as expectations, suggestion, and behavioral change. Others rest on religious or metaphysical notions of the creative power of mind. Often, these two levels appear together, as though evidence for one automatically confirmed the other.
But the story of thought's creative power did not begin with modern online manifestation programs, the vocabulary of neuroscience, or the book The Secret. An important part of its modern roots reaches back to nineteenth-century America, when various teachings about mental healing were developing. Their advocates asked whether people's beliefs, expectations, and understanding of their own bodies could affect their health. This inquiry gradually gave rise to a much broader question: if an inner state can influence health, could it also affect relationships, success, prosperity, and material circumstances? It is in this transition that we find one of the important historical starting points of the modern law of attraction.
Before New Thought: Mesmerism and the Search for Invisible Influences
In the first half of the nineteenth century, the understanding of disease was substantially different from today's. Although medicine was already developing important investigative and therapeutic methods, many illnesses still lacked satisfactory explanations or effective treatments. In this setting, other approaches also gained followers by promising healing through supposedly special natural or mental forces. One of them was mesmerism, named after the Austrian physician Franz Anton Mesmer (1734–1815).
Mesmer proposed the existence of what was known as animal magnetism: an alleged influence that permeated living beings and whose imbalance was said to cause disease. Suitable procedures were supposedly able to correct that imbalance. Mesmer's supposed universal magnetic force was not established as a distinct physical phenomenon. Yet his historical legacy is not limited to an unsuccessful theory. Mesmerism contributed to broader interest in suggestion, trance, the relationship between healer and patient, and unusual changes in subjective experience.
Historian David Schmit has shown that mesmerism spread widely in the United States beginning in 1836. Its practitioners organized public lectures, carried out experiments, and explored questions that they themselves often regarded as part of the study of the mind or psychology. [1] It is important not to equate these historical investigations with contemporary experimental psychology. Nevertheless, they demonstrate that interest in the power of mental processes was developing before modern psychology became an established scientific discipline. Phineas Parkhurst Quimby was among those active in this environment.
Quimby: From Magnetism to a Theory of Mistaken Beliefs
Phineas Parkhurst Quimby (1802–1866) was an American clockmaker and practitioner of mental healing whose early work was rooted in mesmerism. At first, he used procedures associated with magnetism and altered mental states. Over time, however, he developed a different understanding of illness. The idea that a person's mistaken understanding of their condition could contribute to suffering became increasingly central to his thinking. According to Quimby's teaching, it was important to remove false ideas and fears associated with illness. This marked a shift away from the assumption that healing primarily required a special external magnetic force and toward an explanation that placed greater importance on the individual's inner understanding.
Such a shift is historically significant. Different branches of contemporary psychology and medicine do investigate how expectations, stress, and interpretations of symptoms influence bodily experience. But Quimby's teaching was not equivalent to today's scientific models. His explanations drew on philosophical assumptions, individual observations, and accounts of healing. It did not establish reliable scientific evidence that illness is generally caused by mistaken beliefs.
For this reason, Quimby should not be presented as someone who had already proven all the later teachings about subconscious programs or mental healing. His importance is primarily historical: he contributed to the emergence of a new way of thinking about the relationship among beliefs, illness, and human experience.
Quimby's Manuscripts and the Dispute over Their Meaning
Investigating Quimby's work presents a significant historical challenge. During his lifetime, Quimby did not publish a comprehensive, definitively edited book presenting his teaching. We know his ideas through surviving manuscripts, transcripts, letters, and the testimony of people who knew him. One of the most important publications is The Quimby Manuscripts, a collection edited and published by Horatio W. Dresser in 1921, more than fifty years after Quimby's death. [2] The collection contains valuable historical material, but it must be treated as an editorially mediated source. For any given passage, the wording printed in 1921 is therefore not the only relevant evidence. Its origin, possible earlier copies, editorial decisions, and the circumstances of its later publication are also relevant.
This is not merely a technical issue. Quimby's work became the subject of longstanding disputes over the origins of the teachings from which Christian Science and New Thought developed. Dresser prepared his edition in the context of those controversies as well. In its preface, he expressly discussed the significance of the manuscripts for debates about the relationship between Quimby and Mary Baker Eddy. Later defenders of different interpretations sought either to demonstrate Eddy's substantial dependence on Quimby or to establish that their teachings were fundamentally distinct.
There have also been allegations of problematic editorial alterations to the manuscript edition. Such allegations should be assessed by comparing the specific documents, rather than merely by taking the side of one of the disputing groups. The surviving documentation therefore carries more weight than later declarations that one side has definitively established its priority over the other. This example highlights a wider problem in the history of manifestation teachings: the question of who taught an idea first has often become part of the way later systems establish their legitimacy.
Warren Felt Evans: Mental Healing as Philosophy
Warren Felt Evans (1817–1889) was one of the most important early authors to present mental healing systematically in book form. In 1869, the Boston publisher H. H. & T. W. Carter issued his The Mental Cure, a work examining the mind’s influence on the body in health and disease. [3] Evans was not merely a practitioner recounting individual cases of healing. He sought to develop a broader philosophical system. His thought linked mental healing, religious experience, and philosophical idealism.
It is also important not to treat Evans solely as Quimby's successor. A historical connection exists between them: Evans was familiar with Quimby's work and visited him. Yet Evans had also developed his own religious and philosophical approach, particularly through his engagement with the thought of Emanuel Swedenborg. In a 1979 study of Evans, John F. Teahan emphasized that his work combined Romantic idealism with practical mysticism. [4] Evans's teaching therefore matters as an independent systematization, not merely as a book-length version of Quimby's explanations.
In his work, the relationship between mind and body became part of a broader question about how humanity and the material world are related to a spiritual order. That is a fundamentally different framework from the modern psychological question of whether a particular belief improves confidence or reduces stress. Evans was not developing only a practical method. He was also advancing a philosophical account of reality. This makes him an important transitional figure between early mental healing and later metaphysical teachings about the creative power of mind.
Swedenborg and the Correspondence between the Inner and Outer Worlds
Emanuel Swedenborg (1688–1772) occupies an important place in Evans's philosophy. Swedenborg developed an extensive theological and mystical account of the relationship between the spiritual and natural worlds. One of his central concepts was correspondence: the relationship or affinity between phenomena on different levels of reality. Within Swedenborg's framework, material phenomena can carry a deeper spiritual significance. The outer and inner worlds are not treated as entirely disconnected domains. Evans incorporated such ideas into his thinking about health and humanity's spiritual nature. In doing so, he linked mental healing to the broader idea that an important relationship exists between an individual's inner state and a spiritual order.
Here, however, we must distinguish conceptual resemblance from historical influence. Swedenborg's doctrine of correspondences is not automatically identical to the principle of Correspondence presented in The Kybalion, which appeared in 1908. Nor is it enough for two authors to speak about connections between the inner and outer worlds to demonstrate the direct transmission of a particular teaching. In Evans's case, Swedenborg's influence is historically well documented. When comparing Evans with other, later systems, we must investigate any historical connections separately. This distinction will be particularly important in subsequent articles on Hermeticism and the law of attraction.
Mary Baker Eddy: A Shared Environment, a Different Teaching
Mary Baker Eddy (1821–1910) was another important figure in the American history of mental and spiritual healing. In October 1862, she visited Quimby in Portland, Maine. Their direct contact is historically documented. [5] She later developed the teaching that became known as Christian Science.
In 1875, under the name Mary Baker Glover, which she used at the time, she published the first edition of Science and Health. The addition with Key to the Scriptures, which became part of the work's later familiar title, appeared in subsequent editions; the text itself also underwent substantial changes over the decades. [5] This bibliographic distinction matters. If we simply refer to the 1875 book by its final, modern title, we may create the misleading impression that its content and form were already identical to those of later editions.
Eddy developed a distinctly religious teaching centered on her understanding of God as divine Mind and of spiritual reality. Her understanding of healing was therefore embedded in a comprehensive theological account of humanity and the world. It differed from Quimby's teaching on important points, although both emerged from partly overlapping historical circumstances. The extent of Quimby's influence on Eddy's later work remains a subject of historical research and long-running controversy. Yet the divergence between Christian Science and New Thought should not be reduced to personal rivalry.
It Was Not Simply a Dispute over Priority
In 2011, historian Amy B. Voorhees examined the divergence between Mary Baker Eddy and Ursula N. Gestefeld, who later developed her own organized spiritual work. Her analysis shows that the split cannot be adequately explained as a personal dispute alone. Differences in understandings of Christianity, revelation, Theosophy, religious eclecticism, and the authority of particular spiritual teachings were also significant. [11]
This matters for understanding the entire historical milieu. Christian Science and New Thought were not merely two names for the same method of mental healing. They also differed in their organization, their relationships to other religious influences, and their understandings of the source of spiritual truth. Eddy linked her teaching to a particular Christian understanding of reality. By contrast, many New Thought authors drew more freely on a range of philosophical and religious sources.
Of course, New Thought itself was neither completely uniform nor free of internal differences. But comparing the two movements demonstrates that similar approaches to mental healing can be embedded in different, sometimes mutually incompatible philosophical systems. The same caution applies to contemporary manifestation methods. A similar technique does not necessarily mean an identical teaching.
Emma Curtis Hopkins: How an Organized Movement Emerged
The history of New Thought would be incomplete without Emma Curtis Hopkins (1849–1925). Hopkins was an author, teacher, and important organizer of spiritual education. Her path was connected with Christian Science, but she later began developing independent teachings and educational institutions. During the 1880s, she also served as an editor of The Christian Science Journal. After separating from Eddy's movement, she continued teaching independently in Chicago.
Her contribution extended beyond writing books or conducting individual healing sessions. She had a significant influence on the education and training of people who later helped develop various New Thought communities. In her 2002 monograph Emma Curtis Hopkins: Forgotten Founder of New Thought, Gail M. Harley presented her as one of the movement's central yet long-overlooked architects. [6]
Hopkins's career reveals a change in how these ideas spread. Mental healing was no longer primarily the practice of an individual healer. It was becoming part of organized teaching, lectures, schools, publications, and communities. Its reach changed accordingly. Teachings about inner transformation could now reach a broader public, not merely the patients of an individual practitioner.
Hopkins also emphasized affirmations and the wider possibility of human spiritual transformation. She matters to the history of New Thought precisely because she helped connect teachings about healing with organized practices of spiritual and personal development. Her example also demonstrates the important role women played in shaping a movement that popular historical accounts often associate primarily with male authors.
Unity: From Healing to Everyday Spiritual Practice
One of the most recognizable organized expressions of New Thought is Unity. Charles and Myrtle Fillmore began developing the movement in Kansas City, Missouri, in 1889. [7] The movement was associated with prayer, affirmations, and spiritual explanations of healing. According to Unity's own historical accounts, Myrtle's experience was particularly important; she understood it as a healing brought about through prayer and spiritual orientation. Such testimony matters to the movement's history. It should not, however, automatically be treated as clinical evidence that the practices in question cured a particular disease.
Over time, Unity extended its teachings to various aspects of everyday life. In its contemporary presentation of five spiritual principles, the movement emphasizes, among other things, the creative power of thought, prayer and meditation, and putting spiritual teachings into action. [8] Historical precision matters here. The present five-part formulation of these principles is a later summary of Unity's teachings. It is not a list that the founders established in this form back in 1889.
This, too, is an example of later systematization. Particular teachings emerged and changed during the movement's development, while later generations organized them into a clearer system. We will encounter a similar process in other spiritual and manifestation methods.
William James: New Thought Was Already Recognizable in 1902
William James (1842–1910) provided an important contemporary account of the spread of New Thought. James was a philosopher and psychologist who published The Varieties of Religious Experience in 1902. In his lectures on the religion of healthy-mindedness, he discussed the mental-healing movement and also used the name New Thought. [9] This matters because he was describing a movement already publicly recognizable during his own lifetime. James was not examining a single private method but a broader current involving various authors, publications, and spiritual practices.
He also noted that substantial demand for literature had already developed around the movement. He thus drew early attention to the link between spiritual promises and the market for books and self-help manuals. This is an important historical parallel to the contemporary manifestation industry.
Online courses, videos, and social media naturally have a different reach today from books published at the beginning of the twentieth century. But connecting the promise of personal transformation with the sale of specialized knowledge is much older. It is important, however, to distinguish James's description of the movement from scientific validation of its claims. The fact that he treated New Thought as an important religious phenomenon does not mean he accepted or proved its alleged universal laws.
How Did Healing Become a Promise of Prosperity?
By the beginning of the twentieth century, a significant part of New Thought had already expanded beyond questions of healing. Success, personal power, prosperity, and the possibility of changing one's life circumstances increasingly came to the fore. This development did not happen overnight. In a 2026 historical overview of New Thought, researcher Dawn Hutchinson proposes distinguishing several currents: early mental-healing teachings, approaches that connected healing with prosperity, and later religious variants emphasizing faith, divine promises, and success. [12] This is her analytical model of the movement’s history, not a definitive classification or the only possible one. Its value lies in clearly showing how the scope of the promises expanded.
In early mental healing, the central concern was an individual's health. Later, many authors began applying related ideas to relationships, work, money, and personal goals. If thoughts could supposedly find expression in the body, some reasoned that they might also find expression in other external circumstances.
But this inference raises an important problem. The influence of expectations on the experience of a symptom is not the same as their influence on someone's financial position. A change in confidence is not the same as a change in another person's decision. Inner bodily experience is not the same as the direct creation of an independent event. Historically, we can understand why such analogies arose. That does not mean all those analogies were justified.
What Was Genuinely New about New Thought?
Despite all these historical precursors, it would be mistaken to conclude that New Thought created nothing original. Questions about the relationship between mind, body, and the spiritual world had arisen in different cultures long before the nineteenth century. But New Thought brought them together within a particular American religious and social environment. Its authors combined various forms of Christian spirituality, idealist philosophy, Transcendentalism, mental healing, and, later, selected reinterpretations of other religious traditions. Historian Catherine L. Albanese places this development within the broader history of American metaphysical religion. [10]
Another significant feature of New Thought was its practical orientation. Much of the movement was concerned not only with explaining the world, but also with how individuals might change their lives. That emphasis helped these ideas reach people who were not especially interested in complex theological discussions. For them, more immediate questions concerned how to attain health, greater peace, better relationships, or material security. In this sense, New Thought was an important step toward contemporary personal development culture. Nevertheless, we must distinguish historical innovation, practical usefulness, and the empirical truth of a broader philosophical teaching. A practice may be historically significant even if its accompanying metaphysical explanation remains unconfirmed.
Responsibility and the Danger of Excessive Promises
The history of mental healing also raises an ethical question. If we tell someone that their beliefs can affect their experience and behavior, we may help them recognize an area in which genuine change is possible. But if we tell them that their thoughts are responsible for every illness or failure, the claim becomes much more problematic. People do not choose all the biological, social, and material circumstances of their lives. Nor are they responsible for every decision made by other people.
Contemporary research supports the importance of expectations, suggestion, and psychological context in certain symptoms and bodily responses. But that does not mean mental techniques can replace appropriate medical treatment, or that illness is evidence of an incorrect inner orientation. This distinction will be essential when we examine modern methods of subconscious reprogramming, affirmations, and alleged changes to the body through belief. It will also matter when assessing their effects on people who do not achieve the promised results. The effectiveness of a particular method needs to be tested, rather than automatically attributing failure to the individual.
Several Parallel Paths, Not One Line of Descent
Following this overview, it becomes easier to understand why New Thought did not have one single, undisputed founder. Quimby played an important role in the development of mental healing and in the move away from explanations centered on magnetism. Evans helped construct a broader philosophical system of mental healing. Mary Baker Eddy developed an independent religious teaching in a related environment; its relationship to Quimby's work became the subject of historical controversy. Emma Curtis Hopkins contributed significantly to organized teaching and the spread of different currents. Unity demonstrated how teachings about inner transformation could develop into a lasting spiritual community. William James recognized the spread of this way of thinking as early as 1902.
These connections do not form a single, unbroken chain. Rather, they make up a network of historical influences, similarities, disagreements, and independent innovations. For this reason, New Thought cannot be adequately explained as a secret teaching passed from one founder to every later teacher. It is better understood as a milieu in which different views of mind, healing, and spiritual reality met and were transformed. Ever broader promises concerning the creative power of thought gradually emerged from this environment.
The Transition to the Law of Attraction
We can now identify an important historical transition more clearly. The initial question was whether a person's inner state could influence illness and health. Over time, the question became broader: could an inner state influence how someone lives, their success, their relationships, and their prosperity? Some authors focused on changing beliefs and behavior. Others developed metaphysical theories in which thought possesses a special creative power over the external world. In this setting, teachings began to emerge that spoke not only of mental healing but also of thought forces, vibrations, and attraction. Historical development, however, must not be confused with scientific proof. Explaining how an idea originated is not the same as showing that it is true.
In the next article, we will therefore examine Prentice Mulford, William Walker Atkinson, and Wallace D. Wattles in greater detail. With these authors, the shift from inner transformation to broader promises will become even more apparent. We will encounter thoughts conceived as forces, the law of mental attraction, the language of vibration, and theories of material prosperity. It is here that we will be able to investigate more precisely how much of the modern law of attraction is genuinely new and how much represents a reformulation of much older teachings.
Throughout, however, we will need to maintain the distinction among three things: the historical origin of an idea, the practical value of a method, and the evidence for its claimed mechanism. Without that distinction, we might confuse the history of a teaching with proof that it is true—or mistakenly take the philosophical strangeness of its explanation as proof that none of its practices can have beneficial effects. Both oversimplifications would lead us away from the question that prompted this investigation in the first place.
Sources and further reading
- Schmit, D. (2005). Re-visioning antebellum American psychology: The dissemination of mesmerism, 1836–1854. History of Psychology, 8(4), 403–434. source Source
- Quimby, P. P. (1921). The Quimby Manuscripts (H. W. Dresser, Ed.). Thomas Y. Crowell Company. source Source
- Evans, W. F. (1869). The Mental Cure: Illustrating the Influence of the Mind on the Body. H. H. & T. W. Carter. Digitized copy held by the Library of Congress. source Source
- Teahan, J. F. (1979). Warren Felt Evans and mental healing: Romantic idealism and practical mysticism in nineteenth-century America. Church History, 48(1), 63–80. source Source
- Mary Baker Eddy Library. (2022, November 20). What are considered the major editions of Science and Health? source Source
- Harley, G. M. (2002). Emma Curtis Hopkins: Forgotten Founder of New Thought. Syracuse University Press. source Source
- Unity. (n.d.). About Us. source Source
- Unity. (n.d.). Five Spiritual Principles Taught by Unity. source Source
- James, W. (1902). The Varieties of Religious Experience: A Study in Human Nature. Longmans, Green, and Co. Lectures IV–V, The Religion of Healthy-Mindedness. source Source
- Albanese, C. L. (2007). A Republic of Mind and Spirit: A Cultural History of American Metaphysical Religion. Yale University Press. source Source
- Voorhees, A. B. (2011). Understanding the religious gulf between Mary Baker Eddy, Ursula N. Gestefeld, and their churches. Church History, 80(4), 798–831. source Source
- Hutchinson, D. (2026, August 3). New Thought. Center for the Study of World Religions, Harvard Divinity School. source Source