SeriesLaw of Attraction Part 8 / 24

Vibration, Alignment, and Attraction: Atkinson and Abraham-Hicks

From Atkinson's thought waves to Abraham-Hicks's vibrational alignment, this article compares two teachings and asks when 'frequency' is a metaphor or a measurable claim.

A symbolic comparison of two uses of “vibration”: historical analogies with physical forces and a later teaching of emotional alignment. The relief is neither an authentic historical artifact nor a scientific device measuring emotions or thoughts.

If a feeling is a “vibration,” what exactly is vibrating?

“Raise your vibration.” “Align with your desire.” “Stop broadcasting lack.” Such statements are familiar language in contemporary manifestation manuals and online practices. They sound as though they describe a law of nature: a thought has a frequency, a feeling amplifies it, and the universe returns corresponding events. Yet those three steps conceal a considerable leap. Feeling different does not mean that a person has physically measured a signal capable of changing the external world. [9] [10] [13]

The idea did not originate with short videos on social media. As early as 1906, William Walker Atkinson was writing about “thought vibrations” and the law of attraction in the thought world. Almost eighty years later, Esther and Jerry Hicks began communicating the teachings of “Abraham” to the public, with emotion serving as a guide to vibrational alignment. The resemblance in terminology is plain, but we must distinguish historical kinship, direct influence, and a claim about a physical mechanism. [1] [2] [5] [6] [7]

This article therefore asks more than whether an improvement in mood can change someone's life. That question is too general. It asks what the two systems actually claimed, how they were supposed to work, and which parts of their explanations withstand scrutiny outside their own vocabulary.

Atkinson in 1906: the law of attraction before modern marketing

William Walker Atkinson (1862–1932) was one of the more prolific writers associated with the New Thought movement. His Thought Vibration; or, The Law of Attraction in the Thought World was published in Chicago by the New Thought Publishing Company in 1906. This is a verifiable bibliographic fact, not a later attribution made by the modern manifestation movement. [1]

In the opening chapter, Atkinson compares the attraction of thoughts with gravity and magnetism. He describes thought as a force or form of energy supposedly possessing attractive power. That comparison is crucial: for Atkinson, “vibration” was not merely a metaphor for mood, but part of an asserted natural order. He presented his claim in the language of the science of his day, yet the shared words “force,” “energy,” and “attraction” do not establish that he had demonstrated a new physical law. [2]

What matters historically is how early these terms appeared. A modern advertisement claiming to have discovered the secret of “frequency matching” may be selling vocabulary already found in texts more than a century old. That does not, however, make every modern practice identical in substance to every passage Atkinson wrote.

What did Atkinson mean by a “thought wave”?

Atkinson described supposed thought waves as things that spread, influence other people's thoughts, and attract related thoughts and circumstances. In Thought Vibration, he connects human thought with will, desire, emotion, and self-regulation. The very first chapter refers to telepathy and likens the operation of thought to wireless telegraphy; elsewhere, he discusses transforming worry into active interest. This is an account of a historical author's thinking, not a finding of contemporary neurophysics. [2] [3]

A methodological problem follows. An analogy with a magnet does not identify the carrier of the supposed thought wave, explain how the signal travels, tell us how to detect it, or show how to rule out ordinary communication, expectations, or chance. A physical explanation requires these operational steps. Atkinson's book does not supply them in the form of a modern, testable experimental model. [2] [13]

It would nevertheless be unfair to reduce his system to the instruction “think positively.” It also contains the thoroughly down-to-earth idea that desire and interest direct attention toward opportunities, while habits influence behavior. This psychologically recognizable layer does not require an assumed wireless current of thought controlling external circumstances. [3]

Will, habit, and active effort: the Atkinson often overlooked

In his chapter on transforming negative thoughts, Atkinson distinguishes worry from productive interest. He argues that desire encourages the search for ways of attaining a goal. Across the book, he also discusses will, the building of the mind, habits, and emotions. This part of the historical text can be understood as advice about motivation and action; it is not proof that Atkinson had already developed any of the scientific theories of motivation that emerged later. [3]

Yet these recognizable psychological interpretations do not stand apart from his wider doctrine. Atkinson links them to a much broader theory of attraction, to which he assigns cosmic status. Reading him therefore requires three distinctions: advice about behavior, analogy with natural forces, and a claim that thoughts actually affect distant events.

If someone searches for a job more persistently because their goal is clearer and then receives an offer, their actions may explain the outcome. If the same offer arrived without any behavioral, social, or material mediation, a different kind of evidence would be needed. A single outcome cannot, by itself, choose between the two explanations.

Atkinson does not prove that older teachings said the same thing

That same year, Atkinson also published Dynamic Thought; or, The Law of Vibrant Energy (1906). In its preface, he explicitly indicates that he is combining older occult teachings with contemporary scientific ideas. This is valuable evidence of his own project of synthesis, not proof that all ancient teachings shared his model of thought vibrations. [4]

The idea that “everything is vibration” may appear in religious, poetic, and physical language, but the word changes meaning across contexts. We must be particularly careful not to project Atkinson's terminology retrospectively onto ancient texts. The Kybalion (1908), discussed more fully in the article How Old Ideas Become New Secrets: From The Kybalion to The Secret, is itself a modern work with its own historical context; resemblance between a later account and an older tradition is not automatic evidence of ancient continuity. Here the aim is to compare two modern manifestation systems, not to prove that Atkinson's book translated some lost ancient physics.

Abraham-Hicks: from an individual author to an alleged nonphysical consciousness

Abraham-Hicks is not the name of a single historical teacher in the usual sense. It refers to a modern body of teaching presented to the public by Esther Hicks, with her husband Jerry Hicks involved in its development. According to the organization's own account, “Abraham” is a collective nonphysical consciousness, and its official website describes the messages as being expressed through Esther. This is the movement's self-description, not independent confirmation of the messages' alleged source. [5]

In her retrospective account, Esther Hicks identifies an experience in Phoenix in 1985 as the beginning of her encounter with Abraham, while the official presentation of Ask and It Is Given refers to teachings transmitted since 1986. We can thus distinguish the narrative of an initial experience from the subsequent public dissemination of the teachings; the two dates address different questions. [6] [7]

The type of authority also changes when compared with Atkinson. Atkinson made claims in his own name, linking them to the New Thought movement of his time. Abraham-Hicks presents the message as instruction from a wider nonphysical intelligence. Historically, we can document that the movement makes this claim. That does not mean the claimed origin has been verified.

*Ask and It Is Given*: the central guidebook

Esther and Jerry Hicks's Ask and It Is Given: Learning to Manifest Your Desires was published by Hay House in 2004. The official Abraham-Hicks website presents it as an introductory work and lists 22 recommended processes. In that context, the number 22 refers to 22 recommended processes in the book, not the result of an experiment. Separately, the same teaching system also distinguishes 22 ranked emotional groups; the fact that both lists have the same number of entries does not make them the same method. [7] [8] [9]

Its central reversal is straightforward: rather than first obtaining an external goal in order to feel better, a person is supposed to change their inner relationship to the goal and thereby “align” with what they wish to experience. Feelings of relief, gratitude, or optimism are not merely companions of behavior in this teaching; they are taken as signs of alignment with Source Energy. [7] [9]

Here the teaching touches on a very ordinary psychological experience: we sometimes do act more sensibly when we are calmer. Abraham-Hicks, however, takes an additional step by declaring inner alignment a universal condition that supposedly determines how the world responds. That additional step is precisely what requires separate investigation.

Three “laws”: attraction, deliberate creation, and allowing

In an excerpt from The Astonishing Power of Emotions (2007), published on the official website, Abraham-Hicks distinguishes three universal laws: the Law of Attraction, the Law of Deliberate Creation, and the Law of Allowing. The first supposedly operates continuously; the second supposedly enables intentional direction; and the third is meant to help people release resistance and allow what they want. [10]

This is an internally coherent framework within the teaching, but “law” here does not mean what it means in science. The authors articulate rules of a universal metaphysics; they do not provide standardized procedures for independently measuring alignment or separating its effects from other causes. [10] [13] Tellingly, the original excerpt attributes a near-gravitational inevitability to the law of attraction. We saw a similar analogy with gravity in Atkinson. But an analogy is not an experiment: the law of gravity permits quantitative predictions, while “vibrational matching” in these texts lacks a comparably defined physical unit and testing protocol.

Emotions as a compass—and as a frequency scale

One of the best-known features of Abraham-Hicks is the Emotional Guidance Scale. An officially published extract from Ask and It Is Given ranks emotional states from joy, freedom, and love at the top to fear, grief, depression, despair, and powerlessness at the bottom. The scale consists of 22 positions, or groups of emotional terms. [9]

The guidebook itself contains an important nuance: emotions are not simply presented as physical frequencies, but as indicators of vibrational alignment. Within the teaching's own logic, the scale is therefore more like a gauge supposedly registering an unseen relationship to “Source Energy” than an instrument measuring waves in hertz. Yet the underlying hidden quantity cannot be measured independently of the system's terminology either. [9] [13]

As a tool for personal orientation, the question “What am I feeling right now?” may be helpful. As a universal ranking of people and their experiences, however, the scale is much more problematic. Emotions overlap, change with circumstances, and do not provide a one-dimensional measure of someone's worth. Grief can speak of loss; anger can also signal a perceived violation of boundaries; fear may warn of real danger. None of these states is, in itself, a moral or “vibrational” failure.

“Alignment”: a feeling, a behavioral process, or an invisible property of the world?

In everyday language, alignment can mean greater consistency between a person's values, decisions, and actions. Someone who understands why a particular job matters to them may find it easier to set priorities. That explanation belongs to the realm of attention, motivation, and behavior.

In Abraham-Hicks, however, “alignment” has an additional metaphysical meaning: an individual is supposedly aligned with a nonphysical Source and becomes a “vibrational match” for desired circumstances. This is more than a metaphor for feeling well. The authors present it as a description of how the universe objectively works. [5] [9] [10] These levels must remain distinct. Using “alignment” to mean more considered action does not require acceptance of the Abraham-Hicks cosmology. But a claim that a particular emotion directly causes income, another person's decision, or the outcome of an illness carries a burden of proof beyond a self-report of feeling better.

The vortex: a metaphor for a desired world and a question of evidence

In The Vortex: Where the Law of Attraction Assembles All Cooperative Relationships, the authors describe the “vortex” as a realm or state in which what someone wants in relationships is supposedly assembled. The official description promises a shift in understanding relationships and guidance toward a desired experience. This is content within a teaching and commercial system, not a location measurable with an instrument. [11]

The very word “vortex” can evoke physical swirling, but in this teaching it is not a demonstrated vortex in a fluid or field. The same goes for “resonance” unless we identify what is oscillating, at what frequency, under what conditions, and how the change could be measured.

Relationships raise another important question. Our mood and communication can affect other people's responses, but other people retain their own will, history, and boundaries. If someone interpreted this teaching as guaranteeing another person's love or consent through a sufficiently “correct vibration,” that interpretation would outrun the verifiable evidence and disregard the other person's autonomy. This is a criticism of a possible interpretation, not a claim that every follower behaves in that way.

Atkinson and Abraham-Hicks: kinship without a documented direct transmission

Both systems use the language of attraction, thought as a creative factor, correspondence between the inner and outer worlds, and analogies with natural forces. Atkinson's teaching is earlier and demonstrably part of the New Thought tradition; Abraham-Hicks is a later system with its own account of a nonphysical source, emotional guidance, and allowing. [1] [2] [5] [10]

It is therefore reasonable to identify conceptual kinship within the broader history of American metaphysical self-help. Among the sources checked for this article, I found no document demonstrating that Esther or Jerry Hicks derived their doctrine directly from Atkinson's Thought Vibration in particular. Without a documented citation or biographical link, we should not declare such a genealogy a fact. The comparison remains useful because it reveals a shift: Atkinson speaks of thought waves, will, and habit, while Abraham-Hicks places emotional “allowing” at the center of a universal causal model. That difference in emphasis is at least as important as the shared terminology.

Two languages of vibration: historical claims and evidential limits

Aspect Atkinson (1906) Abraham-Hicks (later teaching)
Core expression “Thought vibrations” and attractive thought currents [1][2] Emotional “alignment,” allowing, and the “vortex” [5][7]
Claimed mechanism Thought is likened to a natural force; a physical mechanism is unproven [1][2] Emotional frequency is claimed to affect external results; a physical mechanism is unproven [7][13]
Role of practice Will, effort, habits, and action are part of the historical account [1][2] Emotional guidance and feeling aligned do not establish automatic changes in events [5][7]
What can be studied Behavior, persistence, relationships, and choices, without presuming thought waves Emotion regulation and behavioral consequences, without presuming a “vortex” [14][15]
Historical relation The earlier language of vibration is documented Similar terminology does not establish direct transmission [1][5]
Ethical boundary Inner beliefs are not the sole cause of material conditions Suffering and illness must not be blamed on a “wrong vibration” [16]

This comparison summarizes claims and evidential limits examined in this article. It is not evidence that thoughts physically attract events or that either system has demonstrated clinical efficacy.

What does vibration mean in physics?

In physics, frequency is the number of repetitions of an event per unit of time. If the period of repetition is T, the frequency is f = 1/T; its standard unit is the hertz (Hz). When we speak of vibration, we need to know what is oscillating, relative to which reference, how it is measured, and what dynamics govern the system. The US National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) defines frequency in these terms. [13]

The human body is, of course, a physical system: nerves use electrical signals, the heart produces measurable electrical activity, and the brain can be studied with various instruments. But the existence of measurable bioelectrical activity does not prove that “joy” emits a single cosmic frequency and automatically attracts money. Concepts must be connected through an actual measurement and causal framework, not merely through a superficial resemblance between words.

The Abraham-Hicks emotional scale does not specify frequencies in Hz or a physical measurement of “Source.” Its usefulness may be subjective, symbolic, or motivational; it must not be presented as a table of scientifically calibrated frequencies.

The radio comparison: a compelling metaphor, poor evidence

Many versions of the law of attraction invoke the radio: a transmitter sends out a signal, a receiver tunes in, and a station comes through. The image is easy to understand because it joins repetition, selective attention, and a felt sense of alignment. But an actual radio depends on documented electromagnetic waves, measurable frequencies, an antenna, and a receiver.

To claim that thought works in the same way, we must identify the equivalent of each component. What measurable signal leaves a person? How does it encode a particular wish? Where is the receiver? Why would it respond with an employment contract or a change in another person's behavior? Without answers, the comparison is an explanatory story, not a model with physical predictive power. [2] [13] The metaphor may still have personal value: it can remind someone that repeated attention influences what they notice. But such a psychological explanation must not be mistaken for experimental confirmation of thought waves traveling through space.

Emotion regulation: what science actually studies

Psychology has a substantial research field devoted to emotion regulation. James Gross has, among other things, distinguished changing one's interpretation of a situation from suppressing the outward expression of emotion at a later stage. These are different strategies with different consequences, not an instruction to remain happy at all times. [14]

A meta-analysis by Webb, Miles, and Sheeran (2012) examined 306 experimental comparisons of such strategies. Results varied by strategy: cognitive change had, on average, a small-to-moderate effect on emotional outcomes (d ≈ 0.36), while some approaches involving attention or the suppression of emotional experience worked differently. This supports the reasonable proposition that people can, to some extent, change their emotional experience. It does not support the claim that doing so changes the frequency of the universe. [15]

A study by Lieberman and colleagues (2007) also found that naming emotions in a particular task was associated with different responses in brain regions to negative images. It does not follow that grief is a “lower frequency” causing material deprivation. [16]

Feeling better is not proof that an event was attracted

In practice, a reduction in inner tension may change how someone communicates, how well they rest, their willingness to have a conversation, or their decision to try again. These are recognizable possible mediators between a person's state and an event. None requires a hypothesis about the cosmic exchange of vibrations. [14] [15] [16]

But a correlation between a better mood and subsequent success does not even establish the direction of influence. Perhaps someone felt better because their health improved or they gained greater financial security. Perhaps both are connected to a third factor. There may also be a coincidence in timing without a direct causal relationship. These are not inconvenient details: they are central to an honest investigation of causality. The metaphysical claim remains a separate question. Someone may personally accept it, but establishing it as a general empirical law would require research that adequately rules out alternative explanations.

What does research on belief in manifestation reveal?

Lucas Dixon, Matthew Hornsey, and Nicole Hartley developed a measure of belief in manifestation across three studies involving a total of 1,023 participants. Their article first appeared online in 2023 and was published in a journal issue in January 2025. The authors reported associations between such beliefs, higher subjective ratings of one's own success, stronger expectations of future success, and certain risky financial judgments and experiences. [17]

In the first study, the researchers did not find a significant association between the overall measure of manifestation belief and income or education, although participants who held stronger beliefs rated their own success more highly. That is an intriguing difference between feeling successful and having a verifiable outcome. [17]

Caution runs in both directions, however. The research is largely correlational; it does not prove that believing in manifestation causes bankruptcy or poor investments. Nor does it establish that thought materializes money. It supplies evidence of associations between beliefs, judgments, and behaviors and raises questions for further testing.

Positive expectations are not the same as enjoying an imagined success

In studies by Oettingen and Mayer (2002), positive expectations about an attainable future were associated with greater effort and better outcomes, whereas idealized positive fantasies were linked to weaker effort in the circumstances examined. The pattern appeared across four types of goals; it is not universal proof that every pleasant mental image is harmful. [18]

This finding is particularly relevant to Abraham-Hicks, in which feeling as though the desired reality has already arrived is an important part of the process. Inner relief may help someone, but for some goals it might also replace the perceived need to act. The distinction depends on the exercise, the individual, the goal, and the circumstances—not on a simple division into “high” and “low” vibration.

The practical implication is not a ban on feeling good. It is a reminder that pleasant experiences of an imagined future are not the same as preparing a route toward it. The distinction between “I can do this” and “the external world must adjust to me” becomes especially important.

The ethical edge of the teaching: does a “wrong vibration” cause a person's suffering?

The most sensitive aspect of these systems is how they explain misfortune. If everything a person experiences must necessarily correspond to their inner vibration, an unjust conclusion may follow: illness, loss, violence, or poverty is the result of their poor alignment. An official excerpt from The Astonishing Power of Emotions does indeed include sweeping claims about a “perfect vibrational match” between people and their life circumstances. [10]

This logic can conceal actual causes: genetics, infection, economic inequality, discrimination, other people's actions, injury, war, or chance. It is particularly dangerous when it reinforces guilt in people who need medical care, social support, or protection. We cannot infer from a teacher's text alone that all followers behave in this manner; however, the absolute language in the text provides a reasonable basis for identifying the risk of such an interpretation.

Emotions are not a moral verdict, and nobody has a duty to be cheerful while grieving or calm when facing danger. Responsible self-regulation allows a person to experience an unpleasant emotion while examining real causes and possible actions.

The commercial model: who sells “alignment”?

Alongside books, Abraham-Hicks offers events, recordings, workshops, online broadcasts, and other material. This is visible in the organization's official public presentation, which directs visitors toward ticket sales, programs, and its store. A commercial infrastructure does not, in itself, prove that a teaching is false. It does mean that the teaching is at once an intellectual, spiritual, and market product. [12]

This raises an editorial question that extends well beyond Abraham-Hicks: why are older or metaphorical ideas so frequently repackaged as techniques presented as universal and virtually immune to scientific doubt? When the measure of success becomes an internal feeling and failure can be explained away as “resistance,” the result is an unusually flexible explanatory system in which it is difficult for failure to count as evidence against the promise. We do not have to accuse every seller of intentional deception to recognize the risks of untestable promises.

A forceful critique must also be precise. We can reliably document the existence of a commercial ecosystem and the content of its promises. Claims about particular revenues, deliberate fraud, or manipulation by any specific provider would require further evidence that this article does not present.

Where is the useful part of either system?

Without accepting their cosmic mechanism, we can retain a few questions: Which thoughts keep recurring for me? How do they affect my behavior? Can I acknowledge what I feel? Where can I take one small, concrete step? Do my expectations help me notice an opportunity in the first place? [3] [14] [15] [16]

Instead of saying “the universe will send me a job because I'm on the right frequency,” a person can use a more testable approach: define the work they want, identify the nearest obstacle, improve their résumé, ask for feedback, and submit applications. A better emotional state may help them persist, but the labor market, employers' decisions, and social conditions remain independent factors.

This is more than a verbal distinction. The first formulation promises control over the world; the second separates what an individual can influence from what they cannot guarantee. That distinction makes it possible to examine personal practices respectfully without selling their metaphysical framework as physical science.

What would serious research on vibrational attraction need to show?

A test of direct “vibrational attraction” would first have to define a measurable quantity other than a person's self-reported mood. It would then need to specify predictions in advance: what changes should follow, how quickly, for whom, and after how much practice. It would also need predefined criteria for failure and a way to determine whether an outcome could have arisen from changed behavior or chance.

If adherents explain every unsuccessful outcome after the fact by invoking the “wrong vibration” or hidden resistance, without specifying beforehand what could falsify the hypothesis, the model loses clear empirical testability. If it supposedly works only at an unspecified “right time,” its predictions are insufficiently precise. If, on the other hand, it is intended as a religious or philosophical outlook, it should be assessed in that category rather than being passed off as a frequency measurement. This standard is not hostile to spirituality. It marks the boundary between personal interpretation and a publicly verifiable claim.

Conclusion: shared language is not shared evidence

In the early twentieth century, Atkinson cast thought in the language of supposed waves, energy, and attraction. Abraham-Hicks later developed a more elaborate vocabulary of Source, emotional guidance, allowing, and the “vortex.” Both systems contain practical suggestions about attention and inner states, but both go beyond psychology when they assert universal influence over external circumstances. [2] [3] [4] [5] [9] [10] [11]

Neither a vivid metaphor nor a pleasant personal experience is, by itself, evidence of a physical mechanism. Science has sound tools for investigating emotion regulation, expectations, and decision-making, but those tools do not automatically establish that a desire has a measurable frequency that attracts money, health, or other people's responses. [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18]

The more demanding question here is therefore not “Are you positive enough?” but What actually changes within a person, what behaviors follow, and which external outcomes can fairly be attributed to which kinds of causes? Without those distinctions, vibration remains an appealing word, not an explanation. The later articles Dominant Frequency Projection: A New Discovery or a New Name for Older Processes? and Vibrations, Epigenetics, Quantum Physics, and Claims of Direct Mental Influence return to this distinction.

Sources and further reading

  1. Atkinson, W. W. (1906). Thought Vibration; or, The Law of Attraction in the Thought World. New Thought Publishing Company, Chicago. Bibliographic record for the first edition: WorldCat. source Source
  2. Atkinson, W. W. (1906). Thought Vibration; or, The Law of Attraction in the Thought World, Chapter 1. Primary text (online transcription). source Source
  3. Atkinson, W. W. (1906). Thought Vibration, Chapter 7: “The Transmutation of Negative Thought.” Primary text (online transcription). source Source
  4. Atkinson, W. W. (1906). Dynamic Thought; or, The Law of Vibrant Energy. Segnogram Publishing Company. Project Gutenberg, eBook #41892. source Source
  5. Abraham-Hicks Publications. (n.d.). About Abraham-Hicks: About Abraham. Official self-description of the teaching and the claimed source of its messages. source Source
  6. Hicks, E. (2013). A New Beginning in Phoenix! Abraham-Hicks Publications (the author's retrospective account of 1985). source Source
  7. Abraham-Hicks Publications. (n.d.). Ask and It Is Given. Official presentation of the book and its 22 processes. source Source
  8. Hicks, E., & Hicks, J. (2004). Ask and It Is Given: Learning to Manifest Your Desires. Hay House; publisher's record for the 2004 edition on its accessible UK website. source Source
  9. Abraham-Hicks Publications. (2026, online update February 13; original book excerpt 2004). Emotional Guidance Scale. Excerpt from Ask and It Is Given; primary description of the 22 emotional groups. source Source
  10. Hicks, E., & Hicks, J. (2007). The Astonishing Power of Emotions: Let Your Feelings Be Your Guide. Hay House; officially published excerpt on Abraham-Hicks. source Source
  11. Abraham-Hicks Publications. (n.d.). The Vortex: Where the Law of Attraction Assembles All Cooperative Relationships. Official book description. source Source
  12. Abraham-Hicks Publications. (n.d.). Home. Official website presenting the public offering of workshops, recordings, and programs. source Source
  13. National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST). (n.d.). Time and Frequency from A to Z: Frequency. source Source
  14. Gross, J. J. (2002). Emotion regulation: Affective, cognitive, and social consequences. Psychophysiology, 39(3), 281–291. source Source
  15. Webb, T. L., Miles, E., & Sheeran, P. (2012). Dealing with feeling: A meta-analysis of the effectiveness of strategies derived from the process model of emotion regulation. Psychological Bulletin, 138(4), 775–808. source Source
  16. Lieberman, M. D., Eisenberger, N. I., Crockett, M. J., Tom, S. M., Pfeifer, J. H., & Way, B. M. (2007). Putting feelings into words: Affect labeling disrupts amygdala activity in response to affective stimuli. Psychological Science, 18(5), 421–428. source Source
  17. Dixon, L. J., Hornsey, M. J., & Hartley, N. (2025; first published online July 8, 2023). “The Secret” to Success? The Psychology of Belief in Manifestation. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 51(1), 49–65. source Source
  18. Oettingen, G., & Mayer, D. (2002). The motivating function of thinking about the future: Expectations versus fantasies. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 83(5), 1198–1212. source Source