SeriesIsrael and Palestine: Is the Israeli Occupation of Palestine Justified? Part 9 / 12

The Promised Land: Does Judaism Justify the Occupation?

Does a biblical promise of land justify modern territorial claims? We compare Jewish interpretations, religious tradition and international law.

Editorial illustration, not a documentary photograph.

When a Sacred Promise Becomes a Political Claim

“God promised this land to our ancestors.” For a person of faith, these words may express a profound sense of belonging, belief, and historical memory. But what do they mean when the same claim is used to answer whether a family today may remain in its home or cultivate its land? Is an appeal to an ancient covenant enough to justify contemporary forced displacement, military occupation, or violence against civilians?

The question calls for care. Judaism is not a single political party, Jewish sacred texts are not a modern land registry, and today's State of Israel is not identical to the ancient Israel described in the Hebrew Bible. At the same time, it would be just as misleading to ignore the fact that promises concerning the land are a genuine and important part of Jewish religious tradition. An inquiry must consider both: texts that speak of the promise and conquest, and texts that demand justice, protection of the vulnerable, and fair treatment of the stranger.

One further distinction is essential: what a believer understands as God's promise, what a particular Jewish school considers a religious obligation, and what international law permits today. These are not three answers to an identical question, but three different levels of assessment.

What Does “Israel” Mean?

The Hebrew Bible uses the name Israel in several senses: as the name of the patriarch Jacob, as a designation for a people, and, in historical texts, as a name for political communities. The “Land of Israel” has religious and historical meaning in Jewish tradition. The State of Israel, established in 1948, is a modern political and legal entity.

We must likewise distinguish between the names “Judea and Samaria,” referring to ancient historical regions and also used in contemporary Israeli political discourse, and the West Bank, which is treated in international law as part of the occupied Palestinian territory. A place-name does not, by itself, establish sovereignty or ownership of a particular plot of land.

This distinction does not deny the Jewish people's historical and spiritual connection to the land. It does prevent that connection from being turned, without further justification, into a right to exclude others.

The Land Promised to Abraham: Clear Texts, Contested Implications

In Genesis 12:1–3, God tells Abram to leave for a land that will be shown to him. He promises him a great nation and a blessing; the passage also looks outward toward a blessing for other families of the earth. In Genesis 15:18–21, the text describes more specifically the territory associated with the promise to Abraham's descendants. In Genesis 17:7–9, it speaks of an enduring covenant and of the land of Canaan as an inheritance for those descendants, while also commanding them to keep the covenant. [1] [2] [3]

It matters that these passages not be obscured: the texts do contain an actual territorial promise. Many Jews understand it as part of their religious identity, and some also as an obligation to settle in the land. Others attach a different theological or political meaning to it. There is no single self-evident route from the promise to Abraham to every measure undertaken by a modern state.

Even if someone accepts the covenant as an eternal religious truth, another question remains: does it determine the sovereignty of a present-day state, its borders, the status of millions of people living there today, and title to a particular house? Biblical scripture provides no modern cadastral records, court procedures, or rules for protecting civilians. Any conclusion that it therefore permits the forced seizure of land from people living in the twenty-first century requires additional argument—and must withstand both legal and moral scrutiny.

Nor does the promise appear in the narrative entirely without ethical context. Genesis 18:19 links Abraham's calling with doing what is right and just. This does not annul the promise, but it is a significant reminder that covenant and justice are not unrelated in the text. [4]

Difficult Passages: The Torah Also Contains Commands of Conquest

To write fairly about Judaism, we cannot select only those passages that fit a moral conclusion decided in advance. Deuteronomy 20:16–18 contains severe commands concerning warfare and conquest directed at ancient peoples. Later Jewish legal literature treats these texts seriously. In the Mishneh Torah, in the section on kings and wars (5:4), Maimonides reiterates the harsh command to destroy the seven ancient nations, while also stating at the end of the passage that their identity has long since been lost. That historical qualification does not erase the violent content of the command, but it matters when asking to whom it could even apply. [8] [11]

These passages pose a difficult question: how should violent ancient religious narratives and commandments be understood? It would not be credible to pretend they are absent. Yet it is equally unjustified to equate the ancient peoples named in these texts automatically with present-day Palestinians, or to derive a direct permission to attack a civilian today from an ancient religious command about warfare.

To argue that a particular contemporary act of violence is directly religiously motivated, we would need evidence of a specific actor's actual statement, instruction, or conduct. A passage in an ancient book does not, on its own, prove the motives of a particular soldier, settler, or politician.

Justice, the Stranger, and a Land That Is Not Humanity's Absolute Possession

The Hebrew Bible contains another dimension without which the picture would be incomplete. Exodus 23:9 prohibits oppressing the stranger and recalls the experience of being strangers in Egypt. Leviticus 19:33–34 calls for fair treatment and love of the stranger living among the community. Leviticus 25:23 states that the land ultimately belongs to God and that human beings themselves live on it as temporary residents. The prophet Isaiah 1:16–17 demands justice and protection for the vulnerable. [5] [6] [7] [9]

These texts, too, require careful reading. The Hebrew word ger has meanings that vary across ancient and later Jewish legal settings; it is not simply synonymous with the modern category of a Palestinian resident. It would therefore be insufficient to declare a single verse a literal present-day law of citizenship without historical explanation.

A specialist survey of ger shows a shift from a biblical resident of foreign origin toward later rabbinic categories such as ger toshav (resident alien) and ger tzedek (convert to Judaism). Particular rabbinic interpretations use these distinctions differently. An analogy with present-day Palestinians can therefore serve as an ethical interpretation, not a direct translation of an ancient legal category. [17]

Nevertheless, the ethical message matters: in this religious tradition, the memory of one's own vulnerability and exile becomes a reason for care in dealing with vulnerable others. Within that framework, it is reasonable to ask how one could uphold the exceptional value of the land while violating the basic rights of the people who live on it.

Rabbis Have Disagreed About the Path of Return

The Babylonian Talmud, Ketubot 111a, contains a well-known discussion of the “Three Oaths.” Among other matters, it addresses a collective return to the land, relations with the authority of other nations, and an obligation on those nations not to oppress Jews excessively. [10]

The passage describes three oaths: that Jews should not return to the land en masse “as a wall,” that they should not rebel against the nations' rule, and that the other nations should not oppress Jews excessively. It also presents differing rabbinic positions on the significance of return. [10]

Yet this passage does not establish, by itself, that all of Judaism forbids statehood or that all of Judaism favors territorial expansion. We must distinguish an aggadic—that is, narrative and theological—discussion from its normative status in halakha, Jewish law. Rabbi Joel Teitelbaum of the Satmar tradition used the Three Oaths in Va-Yoel Moshe to develop an extensive argument against political Zionism. Religious Zionist authors reject that conclusion; they assign different weight to the commandment of settling the land and to the significance of the modern state. This is an internal Jewish dispute over interpretation, not a universally accepted legal answer. [18] [19]

In the Mishneh Torah, Kings and Wars 5:9–12, Maimonides likewise places great value on living in the Land of Israel. Comparing Maimonides and Nahmanides, Rav Chaim Navon explains that Nahmanides regards conquering and settling the land as an enduring commandment, whereas Maimonides did not include that commandment in the same way in his list of 613 commandments. Rabbinic discussions offer different explanations for this divergence. [21] This shows that the relationship between return, the sanctity of the land, and political power is far more complicated than a single slogan. [11]

We must distinguish between the religious significance of living in the land, support for Jewish statehood, opposition to particular state policies, and support for coercive settlement in occupied territory. A person may support one of these and reject another.

Religious Zionism and Settlement Policy

Zionism also developed as a modern political and national movement; it was never associated exclusively with religious Jews. A particular current, religious Zionism, connected the Jewish historical and religious bond with the land to political restoration and return. Different schools and emphases developed within it.

Rabbi Abraham Isaac Kook and, later, his son Zvi Yehuda Kook played historically important roles. Studies of the religious settlement movement describe how, after the 1967 war, some of their followers interpreted Israel's capture of the West Bank as part of a religiously understood process of redemption. Gush Emunim, which emerged in the 1970s, linked settlement to this view. These are findings from historical scholarship, not proof that every religious Jew or every settler today shares the same theology. [13] [14] [15]

To understand the issue, the inquiry must also present the strongest version of the pro-settlement religious argument. Rabbi Eliezer Melamed argues in his own halakhic exposition that the commandment to settle the land concerns not only individuals living there but also Jewish rule over the land. His exposition specifically places special value on settlement in Judea and Samaria. Rav Chaim Navon likewise documents a serious rabbinic debate about whether and how settlement of the land remains an enduring commandment. These are contemporary religious interpretations by identifiable authors, not the position of all Jews or all religious Zionists. [20] [21]

Supporters of a religiously grounded connection to Judea and Samaria emphasize the continuity of Jewish history, ancient sites, the covenant, and the importance of return. This is a serious religious argument about identity and belonging. It becomes contested when someone treats it as a sufficient reason to deprive other people living there today of their rights. As a matter of research, the bridge between theology and concrete political practice must be documented, not merely assumed.

When writing about violence, evidence must always be examined at the level of specific acts. If a settler attacks someone, destroys olive trees, or unlawfully occupies a home, the investigation must establish who did it, what happened, what evidence exists, and what responsibility the relevant institutions bear. The alleged perpetrator's religious identity is not, by itself, evidence of motive, much less grounds for accusing all Jews. Conversely, documented religious-political advocacy for settlements is a legitimate subject of public inquiry when accurately attributed to the actual speaker or organization.

Jewish Voices Against Oppression

Within the Jewish religious world, there are also organized voices that draw on the same religious and ethical traditions to argue for responsibility toward Palestinians. On its official website, the Israeli organization Rabbis for Human Rights expressly describes its work to protect human rights, including those of Palestinians in the occupied territories. Its activities include assistance to communities and efforts to safeguard their rights. This describes the organization's own mission; it is not automatically independent verification of every individual case it reports. [12]

The formally stated positions of the Union for Reform Judaism demonstrate the wider distinction. The organization maintains its support for the Jewish state and its security while opposing the occupation of the West Bank, settlements, and unilateral annexation. Support for Israel's existence and security and opposition to the occupation can therefore coexist within a single Jewish religious institution's position. [22]

These rabbis are not the only representatives of Judaism, nor do they speak for every Jew. That is precisely the point: the debate is not between “Jews” as one uniform bloc and “Palestinians” as another. Jewish communities contain different responses to the question of how historical belonging, security, justice, and life alongside another people can be brought together in morally defensible policies.

The same principle applies to the other side: Palestinian communities are not a single political or religious entity. Opposition to occupation does not justify attacks on Israeli civilians, hostage-taking, or attributing collective responsibility to Jewish communities.

A Biblical Promise Is Not a Court Ruling on Today's Home

A religious promise and a legal title are different kinds of claims. A believer may hold that their people have a special covenant with the land. A state, however, must comply with its existing legal obligations, human rights, and the prohibition on acquiring territory by force in its treatment of people living there today.

In its advisory opinion of 19 July 2024, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) found that Israel's continued presence in the occupied Palestinian territory was unlawful. Its reasoning rested, among other things, on the prohibition on acquiring territory by force and the Palestinian people's right to self-determination. The Court expressly considered the Palestinian territory occupied in 1967 as a whole. In the operative part of the opinion, it also stated that Israel was obliged to cease all new settlement activities immediately and evacuate settlers from the occupied Palestinian territory. This is an advisory opinion, not in itself a binding judgment in a contentious case between states, although it explains legal obligations that may be binding independently of the opinion. It is not a criminal conviction of any individual believer or a ruling on which religion is true. In the operative part, the finding on the unlawfulness of Israel's continued presence passed by 11 votes to 4; the finding on stopping new settlement activity and evacuating settlers passed by 14 votes to 1. [23] [16]

This legal assessment does not deny the Jewish historical or religious connection to the land, nor the right of Israeli residents to life and security. It means, however, that in the ICJ's assessment, historical ties and invocations of security do not create a right to acquire occupied territory permanently or to restrict the self-determination of its inhabitants. Two other articles in this series, PL-03 and PL-05, examine the legal analysis in greater detail and document specific cases of property dispossession.

Moral Assessment: Can a Promise Become Permission for Injustice?

At the religious level, the answer depends on how a person understands the covenant, sacred scripture, and its authority. Yet even someone who unreservedly believes in the promise to Abraham cannot infer that every action taken in its name is morally permissible. The tradition also contains justice, protection of the vulnerable, accountability before God, and limitations on human power.

The author's moral assessment is therefore this: it is not just to use one people's historical suffering and religious attachment as permission to strip another people of their dignity, security, homes, or rights. This principle applies equally to Palestinian and Israeli civilians. Attacks on civilians, abductions, deliberate humiliation, forced displacement, and collective punishment do not become acceptable simply because someone commits them in the name of faith, national liberation, or security.

The article does not conclude that Judaism as a whole supports the occupation, or that Judaism as a whole unequivocally rejects it. The more accurate conclusion is twofold. First, Jewish tradition does contain significant territorial promises and historical commands of conquest; it also contains a strong ethical demand for justice. Second, no religious interpretation can, by itself, nullify the rights of people living today or replace the legal assessment of specific acts.

The question of whether Judaism justifies contemporary occupation, forced seizures of land, and attacks on Palestinians therefore requires a precise answer: individual advocates may attempt to ground such positions in religious texts, but this does not turn them into a universal Jewish commandment, still less an independent legal justification for those acts. The final article, PL-12, will assess what might constitute a just solution for both peoples once the historical, legal, and factual findings across the series have been brought together.

Sources and further reading

  1. 01:** Genesis 12:1–3 Source
  2. 02:** Genesis 15:18–21 Source
  3. 03:** Genesis 17:7–9 Source
  4. 04:** Genesis 18:19 Source
  5. 05:** Exodus 23:9 Source
  6. 06:** Leviticus 19:33–34 Source
  7. 07:** Leviticus 25:23 Source
  8. 08:** Deuteronomy 20:16–18 Source
  9. 09:** Isaiah 1:16–17 Source
  10. 10:** Babylonian Talmud, Ketubot 111a, Three Oaths Source
  11. 11:** Maimonides, Mishneh Torah, Kings and Wars 5 Source
  12. 12:** Rabbis for Human Rights, About Source
  13. 13:** Amir Reicher (2025), Detachment from the Metaphysical and the Turn to the Concrete Source
  14. 14:** Robert Eisen (2023), War in Religious Zionism Source
  15. 15:** Hellinger, Hershkowitz, and Susser (2018), Religious Zionism and the Settlement Project Source
  16. 16:** ICJ, Advisory Opinion of 19 July 2024, Case No. 186 Source
  17. 17:** St Andrews Encyclopaedia of Theology, Stranger – Ger Source
  18. 18:** YIVO Encyclopedia, Satmar Hasidic Dynasty Source
  19. 19:** The Scourge of Jewish Nationalism: Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum’s Anti-Zionist Thought Source
  20. 20:** Rabbi Eliezer Melamed, The Commandment to Settle the Land of Israel Source
  21. 21:** Rav Chaim Navon, Is There a Mitzva to Settle the Land of Israel? (2016) Source
  22. 22:** Union for Reform Judaism, Longstanding Positions on Israel and the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict Source
  23. 23:** UN, Explanation of the Legal Nature of ICJ Advisory Opinions (updated 2026) Source

The following references provide a basis for checking claims. Biblical and rabbinic sources establish what particular texts say, not a single opinion held by all Jews. Institutional positions are attributed to their respective authors.