SeriesThe Art of Living Part 56 / 62

How Can I Handle Criticism or Problems With a Teacher?

Unfair grades, harsh criticism or humiliation at school? Understand the difference, check the rules and find a safer response.

You get your written test back. Your grade is lower than you expected, even though you spent several evenings studying. Next to one of your answers, the teacher has written “superficial”—and then says it again in front of the class. Someone laughs. At home, someone asks why you didn't try harder. You want to tell them they have no idea how hard you worked.

Do you have to accept everything a teacher says simply because they're the teacher? Should you challenge them? How can you tell whether a grade was genuinely unfair or whether the teacher's words just felt hurtful?

Don't rush into an argument, but don't accept every comment without question either. First find out what the teacher is criticising and why. If the comment is about your work, ask for an explanation and learn from it if it's fair. If you have doubts about a grade, check your work and the assessment criteria. But if someone repeatedly humiliates you, discriminates against you or puts your safety at risk, seek help from a trusted adult or an appropriate member of school staff. These are not the same problems, and they call for different responses.

When Comments About Your Work Feel Like Comments About You

A grade isn't just a number. It can affect what your parents say, your progress at school and how you feel around your classmates. It hurts especially when you've worked hard and adults speak as if you hadn't tried.

But try to tell the difference between two statements: “Your explanation is missing an important reason” and “You don't understand anything.” The first is about an assignment; the second is a judgment about a person. Your essay may have a weak ending, you may have missed a minus sign in a maths problem, or you may have left out an important fact when answering aloud. Those are mistakes you can examine, understand, and often correct. They say nothing about your worth as a person.

Feeling hurt doesn't prove that the teacher was wrong. Likewise, a teacher's authority doesn't make them infallible. Perhaps the comment was accurate but delivered disrespectfully. Perhaps you didn't understand the criteria. Perhaps there was a marking error. These differences become clearer only when you look at the facts as well as your feelings.

Teachers are human, and they have difficult days too. Remembering that can be helpful. But their tiredness doesn't mean you have to accept insults. Teachers are also responsible for the way they speak to students.

Is Every Unpleasant Criticism Bad?

No. Sometimes an honest comment is exactly what helps you improve. If you hear “Your answer is incomplete,” you may know only that you didn't meet expectations. If the teacher adds, “You listed the causes of the event, but didn't explain how they relate to the consequences,” you know what to improve.

Good feedback helps you understand where you are and what to do next. Research-based guidance for teachers stresses what feedback actually tells a student and whether it helps them improve. Feedback isn't useful simply because it was written down or said aloud. [1]

Even when a comment is fair, you can ask what the teacher means. “Could you show me an example of how I should have explained my answer?” isn't an excuse or an attack. It's a way of learning.

But calling someone “lazy,” “incapable” or “hopeless” is not the same as assessing their work. If a teacher points out that you haven't handed in an assignment, you can discuss that. A poor assignment never justifies treating you as worthless. High expectations and respect can go together.

What Can You Say When a Comment Hurts?

Consider this fictional example about Taja. In history class she receives a lower grade than she expected. Her teacher describes her explanation as superficial in front of the class. Taja wants to shout, “You're picking on me again!” But she still doesn't know whether her answer was missing facts, an explanation or something else.

After class, she asks, “I mentioned the event and its cause in my answer. Could you show me what else was needed for a higher grade?” The teacher explains that she needed to connect the cause with its consequence. Now Taja understands what she left out. That doesn't automatically make the public remark appropriate.

So she could add, “I felt embarrassed when you said that in front of everyone. It would have been easier for me to understand the mistake if we could have talked about it without the class laughing.” Perhaps the teacher listens. Perhaps the teacher says she meant no harm. Taja can calmly say, “I understand you wanted to point out the mistake. I just wanted you to know how it made me feel.”

Taja's aim isn't to win an argument. She wants to understand the assignment and explain how the way the criticism was delivered affected her. She doesn't have to choose between learning from a mistake and keeping her self-respect.

Real conversations are not always this straightforward. If a teacher refuses to talk, interrupts you, or the same thing keeps happening, you can speak to your class teacher or the school counselling service. You don't have to keep knocking on the same door alone.

If you feel safe doing so, try talking after class or at another quiet moment. Say which assignment you're asking about and what you want to understand. “I expected more marks for question three. Could we look at the marking criteria together?” is a more useful opening than “You hate me!” But politeness isn't a magic solution: the other person still has to be willing to have a fair conversation.

And what if you lost your temper yourself? You can apologise for an unkind remark without giving up a legitimate question. “I'm sorry I raised my voice. I'd still like to understand my grade.” Both things can be true at once.

When Is a Grade Worth Checking More Closely?

Spending a lot of time studying doesn't guarantee a particular grade. A teacher assesses what you demonstrated in your work, not simply how hard you prepared. But a teacher might overlook part of an answer, make a mistake when adding up points, or apply a criterion unclearly. That's why it's sensible to check what is written on your work and how it was assessed.

Suppose you were awarded five marks out of ten for a question, even though you think you met all three requirements. First read the instructions and the marking criteria. Which requirements did the teacher mark as incorrect or missing? If the marks don't add up, show how you calculated the total. If the reason isn't clear, ask for an explanation. That way, your question is based on something you can both examine.

Discussing a single grade during the school year is not the same as making a formal objection to a final grade. In Slovenia, the assessment rules for basic schools and secondary schools are different. The basic-school regulations set out a specific procedure for objecting to a final grade. The secondary-school regulations provide for access to marked written work and the right to have a grade explained. [2] [3]

If you're dealing with a final grade, an examination, or another important decision for which a deadline may apply, ask your school promptly which current procedure applies to your programme. Parents or guardians, your class teacher, or the school counselling service can help. Don't rely on deadlines mentioned in old online posts, and don't assume that asking for a review will automatically change the grade.

Perhaps checking will show that the grade was correct. Accepting a well-explained mistake is not humiliating. But if you find a genuine mistake, or an important question remains unanswered, use the appropriate procedure to clarify it. That isn't rebellion; it's a request to be treated fairly.

“Why Is It Allowed for Others but Not for Me?”

Some teachers find it easier to communicate with some students than with others. Perhaps the teacher rarely calls on you even though you raise your hand, or you feel that you're treated more strictly than others when you're late.

Sometimes there are circumstances you don't know about. Another student may have agreed adjustments or accommodations or may already have spoken with the teacher about a difficulty. The fact that a teacher is more relaxed with someone else doesn't, by itself, prove unfair grading. But that doesn't mean you have to ignore obvious differences either.

Focus on specific incidents. Were different criteria used for comparable assignments? Does an insulting comment keep being repeated? Is someone treating you differently because of a personal characteristic or circumstance? Write down what you saw or heard for yourself, and keep that separate from rumours. If a pattern continues, show it to someone you trust and work together to find out how to address it.

You can take a similar approach at home if your parents immediately say, “The teacher must be right.” Instead of a long argument, show them your assignment and say, “I'm not asking you to agree with me automatically. Please help me check what really happened.” If you don't have support at home or don't feel safe there, turn to another trustworthy adult, such as a school counsellor.

What If the Problem Is More Than Criticism?

Nejc is a fictional example. For several weeks, his teacher has been calling him insulting names in front of the class. When he asks for an explanation, the teacher makes fun of him. There are also unexplained differences in his grades. Nejc becomes so anxious before these lessons that he starts trying to avoid them.

Telling Nejc, “Just be even nicer and it'll go away,” isn't helpful. Repeated humiliation is not an ordinary correction of schoolwork. Nor should he have to prove how much humiliation he can endure. Adults responsible for a safe school environment must take such incidents seriously. [4]

If something similar is happening to you, you can, when it's safe, write down the date, what was said or done, any witnesses, and how it affected you. Keep any relevant messages or other material you are entitled to keep. You don't need a complete folder of evidence before you tell someone you need help. Notes may help, but they are not a condition for being heard.

Speak to a trusted adult, a class teacher who isn't involved, the school counselling service or the school's leadership team. If the first person doesn't act, look for another safe route. If there are threats, violence, or sexual harassment, don't try to force a confrontation with someone who puts you at risk. Put your safety first and seek appropriate help; in immediate danger, contact the relevant emergency services. Official protocols vary according to the kind of violence involved, so not every protocol applies in the same way to every disagreement with a teacher. [4]

Anyone who insults or harms someone else is responsible for their own behaviour. If you reacted badly in the heat of the moment, you can put your own part right. But that never means you deserved humiliation or danger.

So What's the Sensible Thing to Do?

A demanding teacher isn't necessarily unfair, just as a friendly teacher isn't necessarily fair. You can learn a great deal from older people—from their experiences, including mistakes they have made. Perhaps your parents or grandparents can tell you how a strict teacher helped them improve or how an adult once knew how to admit a mistake. Listen to them, but don't take those stories as proof that you must endure every injustice today.

Be honest with yourself about whether you did the assignment, kept your agreements, and listened to instructions. If you made a mistake, correct it. If criticism of your work is justified, use it. If it's unclear, ask for an explanation. If you have good reasons to question a grade, check the marked work and find out which procedure applies. If there are insults, discrimination, or danger, seek support and protection—you don't have to confront the person alone first.

The next time a comment hurts, you might say to yourself, “Perhaps there's something I need to learn. But first I need to understand what happened.” That is better than arguing without thinking—or staying silent at any cost.

Criticism can be an opportunity to improve your work. But it is never a measure of your worth as a person.


Sources and Further Reading

  • [1] Education Endowment Foundation (2021), Teacher Feedback to Improve Pupil Learning, https://educationendowmentfoundation.org.uk/education-evidence/guidance-reports/feedback . Research-based guidance about the quality of feedback (ages 5–18). It does not establish that every individual conversation will succeed.
  • [2] Pravilnik o ocenjevanju znanja in napredovanju učencev v osnovni šoli [Regulation on Assessment and Progression in Slovenian Basic Schools], Official Gazette of the Republic of Slovenia 80/2025, especially Articles 3 and 24, https://pisrs.si/Pis.web/pregledPredpisa?id=PRAV15843 . Specifically addresses objections to a final grade; this procedure is not a universal route for every grade received during the year.
  • [3] Pravilnik o ocenjevanju znanja v srednjih šolah [Regulation on Assessment in Slovenian Secondary Schools], Official Gazette of the Republic of Slovenia 30/2018, especially Article 18, https://pisrs.si/Pis.web/pregledPredpisa?id=PRAV13441 . Access to marked written work and the right to an explanation of a grade; particular deadlines and procedures depend on the type of decision and educational programme.
  • [4] Ministry of Education of the Republic of Slovenia, Prepoznavanje in preprečevanje nasilja v šolah [Identifying and Preventing Violence in Schools], https://www.gov.si/teme/prepoznavanje-in-preprecevanje-medvrstniskega-nasilja-v-solah/ . Supports a safe and respectful school environment; the protocols outlined on this page primarily concern specific forms of violence and must not be presented as procedures for every disagreement with a teacher.