SeriesThe Art of Living Part 19 / 62

Why Do We Have Rules, and When Is It Right to Challenge Them?

How to tell the difference between a boundary that protects you, a custom that can change, and a demand no one has the right to make.

How to tell the difference between a boundary that protects you, a custom that can change, and a demand no one has the right to make.

“No phones after ten. Not even on Fridays.”

“But we won't know the arrangements for tomorrow's trip until ten-thirty!”

“A rule is a rule.”

Perhaps you've heard an answer like that. Sometimes you feel as though the adults around you aren't listening at all. At other times, you only understand later what they were trying to protect you from. And perhaps you've experienced the opposite, too: someone demanded something that struck you as unfair, and you weren't sure you even had the right to object.

Here's the short answer: a reasonable rule is worth respecting even when you don't like it. But an adult isn't right simply because they're an adult, and questioning a rule isn't automatically disrespectful. First, try to understand what the rule protects and who it affects. If it fails to serve its purpose or is unnecessarily unfair, explain why and offer a better way. But if someone expects you to endure violence, danger, or humiliation, that isn't an ordinary disagreement about rules—and you don't have to face it alone.

That may sound straightforward. The harder part is working out what kind of rule you're dealing with in the first place.

Who Is a Rule Really Protecting?

“Let me know when you arrive.” “Clear up after yourself when you've finished eating.” “Stand up and greet a visitor when they come in.” At home, all three instructions might be given in an equally firm voice, even though each serves a different purpose.

Letting someone know you've arrived may be about safety. Clearing up is also a matter of fairness: if one person always cleans up after everyone else, you aren't sharing the work as a household; you're letting that one person carry everyone else's burden. Greeting a visitor may be a family tradition, a way of showing that the visitor is welcome. Not every rule has to prevent an accident to have a worthwhile purpose. But it's equally unfair to present every old custom as though it were an essential safety requirement.

Think about a bicycle that several people share. If you return it filthy, damaged, and no longer ready for the next person to use, they haven't been left the same opportunity you had. It's easier to see why shared things need looking after when you're not the only person who uses them. The same is true of noise late at night, the kitchen, or the division of household chores. A good reason for a rule isn't simply “because I have the power to insist.” It's “because this protects something or makes something possible for someone.”

But a worthwhile purpose and a sensible way of achieving it are not the same thing. If everyone at home needs a good night's sleep, limiting late-night phone use may help. Must that limit apply without exception when someone is waiting for an important message about transport? If everyone is expected to help around the house, why does one person always have three chores and another none? The real question is not just whether the rule has a good intention. It's whether this particular requirement actually helps, imposes a reasonable burden, and achieves something that couldn't be achieved better another way.

That may sound like a small distinction. But one day, when you're helping decide how people live together, it will matter a great deal.

Old Mountain Pastures: Why Make Rules When Land Is Shared?

An unexpected place to learn why rules matter is high in Slovenia's mountains, far from phones and school corridors.

On an Alpine pasture used by livestock belonging to several farmers, no one can simply announce, “My cows will graze here because that's what suits me.” People have to agree on who may use the pasture, how the work will be shared, and who will maintain the paths, fences, and other facilities everyone relies on. That is why grazing regulations, known in Slovenian as pašni redi, developed in the country's mountain-pasture communities. They set out grazing rights and duties connected with the work. Slovenia's official Rural Development Programme 2004–2006 explicitly describes them. [1]

Velika planina gives us an even more concrete example. In its presentation of the area's heritage, Slovenia's National and University Library describes a herders' community with a chairperson responsible for keeping order, recording livestock, and organizing shared maintenance work. Modern grazing communities also set out their members' mutual rights, obligations, and responsibilities in agreements. [2][3]

Imagine someone bringing their animals onto the mountain, using the common pasture, and always leaving everyone else to repair the fence. The problem wouldn't be that they had broken some quaint local custom. They would be benefiting from a shared resource while refusing their share of the responsibility. An agreement, then, need not take freedom away. It can stop the strongest person from claiming the shared resource at everyone else's expense.

Of course, these sources don't tell us whether every historical grazing regulation treated everyone fairly. Who was allowed to make decisions, who received more rights, and who carried the heavier workload could vary. To claim that a particular historical injustice occurred, we would need evidence for that specific claim. So the lesson from history isn't that you must obey everything old without question. It is that good rules need to connect rights with responsibilities.

At home, you share a kitchen, time, space, and often money rather than a mountain pasture. On a school project, you share the work. On a trip, you have to coordinate transport and plans. Whenever several people use something together, the value of a fair arrangement becomes obvious surprisingly quickly.

When a Rule Outlives the World That Gave Rise to It

“In our family, we always stand up when an older guest arrives,” your grandmother might say. Perhaps your father insists that nobody looks at a phone during family lunch. One rule may be rooted in hospitality, the other in the wish to spend at least some time truly together. Yet customs can also carry an assumption that the youngest person should always have the least say.

Before you dismiss a tradition, ask your grandmother, “What mattered most in your family when guests came over?” Perhaps she'll tell you about visitors who were offered the best chair and a good meal even when the household had little to spare. That tells you much more than a curt “because it's proper.” Hospitality can be preserved without repeating every detail of an old seating order.

That is the difference between respecting tradition and copying it blindly. Respect means listening to people's experience and trying to understand what a practice was for. But reason still has work to do if that same practice unfairly excludes, humiliates, or overburdens someone. This doesn't mean all older people followed the same customs, or that every family rule today arose for the same reason.

Adults often know consequences that a young person hasn't experienced yet: the missed bus, the cost of a repair, exhaustion after work, or the anxiety of waiting for someone who hasn't come home. It's worth listening to what their experience has taught them. But older people can be mistaken, too. Sometimes the most respectful conversation is one in which you ask them seriously what they are trying to preserve—and whether it could be preserved in another, fairer way.

When an Exception Makes More Sense Than a Ban

Fictional scene. Every evening, fifteen-year-old Tia puts her phone away at ten. Often the rule helps her: she doesn't keep conversations going late into the night, and getting up in the morning is easier. But this Friday, she and her friends are waiting to find out who will drive them on a trip the following morning. The driver won't be able to confirm the arrangements until ten-thirty.

Tia could secretly take the phone from the shelf. If she got away with it, she would have the information, but she wouldn't have given her mother any more reason to trust her. On the other hand, simply shouting “Why am I the only one who can't use my phone?” would miss what her mother was actually worried about.

“I know the rule is there so I get enough sleep,” Tia says earlier, when they're both calm. “But I need one message about tomorrow's transport. Could I check it at ten-thirty in the living room and then put the phone away? If the ride isn't confirmed, I won't go.”

Her mother has good reason to be cautious. More than once, “just one message” has turned into a long conversation. So she asks, “How will I know it's really only one message?”

“I can read it here with you. Or we could ask the driver to send you the confirmation instead, if you'd prefer.”

Perhaps her mother agrees to a brief exception. Perhaps she suggests sorting out the transport that afternoon instead. If neither is possible, Tia may also have to consider missing the trip. The wisest option isn't always the one that gives you most of what you wanted. It's the one that meets a real need without defeating the reason the rule exists.

Tia isn't asking for the household cutoff time to be abolished forever. She explains why this evening is different, offers a limited solution, and accepts that going on the trip isn't guaranteed. If late-night messaging has genuinely been leaving her tired, that still matters even if she persuades her mother this time.

A conversation about a rule hasn't failed simply because you didn't get a “yes.” What matters is whether you've found a fair way to preserve what made the rule worthwhile.

You Can Disagree Without Turning It into a Fight

There's a difference between “Your rule is stupid” and “I don't think this restriction solves the problem. Could I suggest another way?” The first dismisses the person; the second challenges the rule itself. But even the second doesn't guarantee a pleasant conversation. Adults can make mistakes, be tired, or struggle with the fact that their child is growing up.

If you want a later curfew, saying that your friends' parents allow it isn't enough. Explain how you'll get home, who you'll be with, what you'll do if your transport falls through, and when you'll contact your family. If the distribution of household chores seems unfair, show what each person actually does and suggest a change. If a rule hasn't been reconsidered for years, explain what you can do now that you couldn't do when you were younger.

Sometimes, though, “no” is a well-founded answer. Even a persuasive argument won't make an unsafe journey safe. Parents and guardians have responsibilities both to safeguard a child's health and wellbeing and to prepare that child for independent life. Both duties are reflected in Slovenia's Family Code. [4] That means care should have a reason behind it and that a young person's room for independence should sensibly expand with experience and reliability—not merely with the number of arguments they've had.

If a rule isn't harmful in itself and a decision has to be made straight away, it is often better to follow it for the moment and return to the question of changing it later. That is particularly important with safety instructions while travelling, working, or in class. If a restriction is unnecessarily rigid, a trial arrangement may help: “Let's try this for two weeks, and then see together what worked.”

But a fair agreement has to work both ways. If an adult promises to reconsider a restriction after a month, they should keep that promise. If you've spoken insultingly, it's right to apologize for the insult. It's just as right to expect that you won't be insulted in return. And if someone repeatedly calls your calm questions disrespectful, that doesn't automatically make the questions wrong.

Remember: you can have a good reason for disagreeing and still struggle to express it well the first time. It's often better to come back when everyone has cooled down than to try to prove everything in the middle of an argument.

A Punishment That Only Hurts—or a Consequence You Can Learn From?

Suppose you borrow the family bicycle and damage it. The first question is one we often skip: what actually happened? An accident despite careful use is not the same as deliberate damage, or carelessness you've already been warned about. A fair consequence should take that difference into account, not just the damage left behind.

If you were careless, it makes sense to help with repairs, contribute an appropriate share of the cost if you're able, or agree on safer use next time. This isn't just about money. Someone else can't use the bicycle now, and it's right that you notice that.

It's another matter altogether if you're insulted in front of relatives over the same damage, or forbidden from doing anything for an indefinite period without being told what you can do to put things right. Reacting strongly isn't the same as helping someone learn from what happened. Professional guidance for parents also emphasizes clear expectations, consistency, and discussing consequences. [9]

Sometimes a temporary restriction is entirely reasonable. If you repeatedly come home much later than agreed and don't answer messages, adults may temporarily set an earlier curfew. But even then, a helpful question is, “What would I need to show you for us to review this arrangement?” When there's no way to put things right, a punishment begins to lose its purpose as a way of teaching.

Someone who can admit a mistake is not demanding a life without consequences. They can, however, ask that those consequences relate to the action, be explained, and be proportionate. That's a far stronger argument than simply saying “It's not fair.”

“Why Does My Brother Have a Different Rule?”

Fairness doesn't mean a nine-year-old girl and a fifteen-year-old boy must have the same curfew or the same chores. One person knows a route well; another needs help. One can do a demanding task safely; another might get hurt trying. The same restriction for everyone can have very unequal effects.

But when a brother and sister of the same age are always held to different expectations, it's understandable to ask why. Perhaps the reasons genuinely are different experience and reliability. Or perhaps the adults are repeating an assumption that something is unsuitable for a girl but perfectly ordinary for a boy—or the other way around. Such family expectations have a history worth listening to. Yet gender alone doesn't tell you who can get home safely, keep an agreement, or clean up the kitchen.

A more useful conversation begins with: “What's the specific difference between our situations? What would I need to demonstrate for a different rule to apply to me?” If there's a good reason, you may be able to accept it even when it's inconvenient. If nobody can explain the difference, you have good reason to suggest another look at the rule.

The same goes for chores. It's useful for young people to learn to cook, keep things clean, help an older relative, and contribute to shared life according to their abilities. It isn't right, though, for one child to be routinely left carrying so much of the adults' work that there is no room left for school, sleep, and health. A responsibility that helps someone grow is not the same as a burden that wears them down.

A School Rule Is Not the Same as an Arbitrary Ban

It's understandable that a teacher doesn't want half the class watching videos on their phones during a lesson. But what if a pupil needs an electronic device for a medical reason?

Second fictional scene. At the start of a lesson, Mark is told to put his electronic device in a designated place. But he needs it to receive a health-related alert. He calmly tells the teacher that he uses it for a medical purpose and asks for help arranging an exception. His parents or guardian and appropriate school staff can also be involved, so that its use is safe and Mark doesn't have to explain every private medical detail in front of the class.

The medical exception is real; it hasn't been invented for this story. In Slovenian primary schools, Section 60.l of the Primary School Act allows a pupil to use an electronic device for health reasons. Section 60.e of the same Act provides for teachers and other relevant school professionals, pupils, and parents to take part in drawing up the school's rules of conduct. [5] Participation doesn't mean any pupil may reject any instruction a teacher gives. It means school rules are not merely the personal whim of whoever has the loudest voice in the room.

An ordinary disagreement can often begin with a conversation with the teacher, class teacher, or school counselling service. Some decisions, however, also have formal procedures. If a primary-school pupil receives a formal educational warning (vzgojni opomin), Section 60.g allows the pupil and their parents to file a reasoned written objection with the headteacher within eight days of receiving notice of the warning. [5] That deadline applies to this specific situation; it isn't a general rule for every disagreement at school. Before acting, check what kind of decision has been made and which procedure applies. The rules for secondary schools are not automatically identical.

Both scenes—Tia at home and Mark at school—make the same distinction: you don't have to destroy a sensible rule in order to correct an unreasonable application of it in particular circumstances.

When “Obey” Becomes a Dangerous Demand

So far we've been discussing rules that people can disagree about without being afraid. But some instructions are different. “Never tell anyone that we hit you at home.” “If you respect me, you'll hide what I've done.” “As punishment, you're not allowed to speak to anyone outside the family.” In situations like these, the problem isn't that a young person hasn't found a polite enough way to object.

Parental or any other authority is not permission to use violence, abuse, or humiliation. The UN Convention on the Rights of the Child protects children's ability to express their views and requires protection from physical and mental violence. [6]

If someone threatens you, pressures you to conceal abuse, or prevents you from asking for help, you don't have to negotiate with that person first. Reach out to a safe adult, a school counsellor, or another trustworthy professional. In Slovenia, the police emergency number is 113; for emergency services, call 112. Young people can also talk to someone through the free TOM helpline on 116 111. [7][8] If the person threatening you monitors your phone or messages, choose a way of reaching help that is safe for you. Don't try to face danger alone merely to prove that you're brave.

The boundary between a rule you dislike and a dangerous demand isn't always obvious. If you're unsure, it's entirely reasonable to talk about it with an adult you trust. You don't have to know the exact name for everything that's happening before you ask for help.

So When Should You Follow a Rule—and When Should You Challenge It?

If someone asks you to clean up after dinner, don't respond only by demanding to know why you have to do yet another thing. Look at whether the work is actually shared fairly. If you're asked to come home on time, think about what is genuinely safe given your age and the transport available. If your grandmother reminds you to greet a visitor, ask what kind of respect she wants you to show. In each of these situations, understanding the reason may give you a better answer than simply counting restrictions.

As a rule, respect rules that are reasonable, safe, and fair—even if you don't especially like them. Challenge unnecessarily rigid or unfair rules with good reasons and a workable alternative. But don't respond to dangerous demands, abuse, or humiliation by trying to earn the right to be safe—seek help.

Perhaps Tia will be allowed to check that one message. Perhaps she'll have to organize the trip earlier. Either answer can be reasonable if it's grounded in the actual circumstances and an honest conversation. A bad rule needs correcting; a good rule sometimes needs someone who understands why it is good.


Sources and Further Reading

[1] Republic of Slovenia, Rural Development Programme for the Republic of Slovenia 2004–2006: a historical account of mountain grazing and grazing regulations governing rights and duties relating to grazing and work. This is an institutional secondary account, not a transcription of an individual historical grazing code.
[2] National and University Library of Slovenia, Velika planina, Google Arts & Culture: an account of the herders' community, livestock records, and shared maintenance work.
[3] Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Food, Agrarian and Grazing Communities (updated 4 June 2026): regulation of modern grazing communities and their members' rights, duties, and responsibilities.
[4] Slovenian Family Code (Družinski zakonik), especially Articles 136 and 137: protecting, raising, and supervising children and preparing them for independent life. This legal framework does not supply an automatic answer to every disagreement at home.
[5] Slovenian Primary School Act (Zakon o osnovni šoli), especially Sections 60.e, 60.g, and 60.l: school rules of conduct, objections to formal educational warnings, and health-related reasons for using a pupil's electronic device. Applies to primary schools; the Slovene source statements were checked on 26 October 2026.
[6] UNICEF, Convention on the Rights of the Child, especially Articles 5, 12, 16, and 19: age-appropriate guidance, children's views, privacy, and protection from violence.
[7] GOV.SI, Emergency Calls (Klici v sili): 112, 113, and TOM 116 111.
[8] GOV.SI, Help for Victims of Violence (Pomoč žrtvi v primeru nasilja): avenues of support in situations involving violence.
[9] US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), Parental Monitoring: clear expectations, contact with adolescents, and consistent responses; this guidance does not establish that every parenting measure works equally well.