SeriesThe Art of Living Part 5 / 62

Do I Always Have to Tell the Truth?

How to be honest without betraying someone's trust, causing needless hurt, or helping someone do harm.

How to be honest without betraying someone's trust, causing needless hurt, or helping someone do harm.

“Nika, is the hall definitely booked for Saturday?” asks a friend who's organising the sound equipment for their music night. “If it is, I'll call the technician today.”

Nika sent a booking request several days ago, but she hasn't had a reply. She promised to arrange the venue, and now she's embarrassed to admit she hasn't actually secured it.

“Well, I did write to them,” she says.

“Great. Then I can confirm the sound equipment,” her friend replies. Nika could still stop him, but she says nothing. She hasn't said the hall is booked. Even so, she knows perfectly well what her friend has understood.

Here's the short answer: as a rule, tell the truth—especially when other people will rely on what you say to make a decision. That doesn't mean you have to tell everyone everything. You can reasonably choose not to discuss private matters—your own or someone else's. You can tell an uncomfortable truth with kindness. And when someone is in danger, protecting them comes first. What matters, too, is whether your words—or your deliberate silence—leave someone with an impression you know is false.

The scenes and conversations in this article are fictional. They do not describe real people or events.

Can You Mislead Someone Without Saying Anything False?

Nika really did send the request. But her friend didn't ask whether she'd written to the venue. He asked whether the booking had been confirmed. He needs that answer to decide whether to hire the sound equipment and tell the others the event is going ahead. If Nika deliberately lets him draw the wrong conclusion, she can't fairly defend herself by pointing out that every word she said was technically true.

A much more useful answer would be: “I've sent the request, but I haven't had confirmation yet. I'm sorry I didn't tell you sooner. I'll call them today, and we should check another hall just in case.” Her friend might be disappointed. But at least he can adjust the plan in time. A more reassuring version of events that exists only in his mind won't help him.

It helps to distinguish three situations. You might make an honest mistake: you misread a message and genuinely believed the booking was confirmed. You might simply not know: the request has been sent, and you're still waiting for a reply. Or you might know there is no confirmation and deliberately create the opposite impression. The consequences can be similar, but the moral meaning of your actions isn't quite the same. When you discover a mistake, correct it. When you don't know, don't pretend to be certain. When you've misled someone, acknowledge that as well.

So the question isn't only whether Nika's words were literally true. It also matters whether she deliberately left her friend believing something false. Discussions of lying and deception don't always draw these distinctions in the same way. But in Nika's case, the consequence is clear: her friend could book sound equipment for a hall that hasn't been confirmed. [1]

Some of the most useful things you can learn to say are also the hardest when you're embarrassed: “I don't know yet.” “That was only my assumption.” “What I told you earlier wasn't right. Let me correct it.” Saying these things doesn't automatically destroy trust. It lets the other person judge how much they can safely rely on the information.

Can You Keep Something Private Without Lying?

Of course. Suppose a friend tells you that her parents have been struggling to communicate with each other. There is no violence or other danger involved; it's simply a sensitive family matter. The next day someone asks, “Why has she been so quiet lately? What's going on at home?”

You don't owe someone who is simply curious your friend's story. You can say, “That's private. If she wants you to know, she'll tell you herself.” You don't need to invent an excuse about her being tired—or hint that you're keeping a particularly fascinating secret. Someone else's trust isn't something you trade for attention. Even when private information is true, that doesn't automatically make it yours to share. Before speaking about someone else, consider not only whether the information is true, but whether you have good reason to tell this person.

Now notice the difference. Nika can't use privacy in the same way when her friend asks about a booking she promised to arrange. The status of the hall matters to a shared responsibility. Her feelings, private worries, and every detail of her day, however, don't automatically belong to the other members of the group.

When a question catches you off guard, it may help to consider why it's being asked. Is the person merely curious, or do they need the answer to make a decision? Are you talking about something personal, something another person told you in confidence, or an agreement you've taken responsibility for? Those distinctions won't settle every situation neatly. But they can help you avoid two opposite mistakes: revealing far too much, or using “privacy” to hide something another person reasonably needs to know.

The UN Convention on the Rights of the Child also recognises children's right to privacy. That doesn't mean young people should hide everything, or that other people are entitled to demand every intimate detail from them. Privacy deserves serious respect, alongside genuine responsibilities and the need for safety. [2]

How Can You Tell the Truth Without Being Cruel?

A friend shows you a small wooden box he's made as a birthday present. The lid sticks a little, and you don't particularly like the colour. He's proud of his work. “Do you think it's good enough to give as a present?” he asks.

You could smile awkwardly and say, “It's perfect!” You might make him happy for a moment, but you could also take away his chance to fix the lid before he gives the box away. Or you could snap, “It's awful.” That would hurt him without explaining what's actually wrong. The colour is largely a matter of taste; the sticking lid is a practical problem you can check together.

Try something else: “You've done a really nice job on the details. The lid catches a little—shall we see if we can fix it? As for the colour, that's more a matter of taste. I usually like different shades.” You haven't pretended the box is flawless, and you haven't dismissed the effort he put into it.

Now change the circumstances. If he gives the box to you, receiving it doesn't mean you need to turn into a critic of his workmanship. You can sincerely thank him for the time, thought, or idea behind the gift. If he later specifically asks for your honest opinion of the object, that's a different conversation. Being considerate doesn't necessarily mean hiding facts. Often it means understanding what someone is actually asking you—and why.

Sometimes people say something untrue because they don't want to hurt someone else's feelings. Researchers sometimes call this a polite lie. Studies involving children and parents examine how people judge such statements: what matters may include the intention, what was said, and who said it. But good intentions alone don't mean that saying something untrue is the best way to help. [3][4]

My advice is to look for a third option before choosing between a comforting lie and harsh criticism: an answer that's truthful, specific, and respectful. If someone needs your judgement about safety, health, money, or an important decision, accuracy matters especially. When the question is mainly one of taste, don't present your preference as the one correct verdict.

What Did Older Generations Mean by “A Lie Has Short Legs”?

A Slovenian proverb says, “Laž ima kratke noge”—literally, “A lie has short legs.” It is recorded in a dictionary of Slovenian proverbs available through the Fran language portal. The idea is that a lie may soon be exposed. That doesn't mean every lie will inevitably come to light, and the dictionary entry doesn't establish exactly when the saying first arose. [5]

Why do people still pass on this advice? An untruth can begin with something quite ordinary. You don't want to disappoint a friend. You're afraid of anger at home. Or you're ashamed to admit that you haven't done what you promised. That's Nika's situation. Her fear matters, but it still leaves her friend without information he needs. Understanding why you avoided the truth isn't the same as excusing the consequences.

If you then need another invented explanation, you have to remember what you told each person. Yet the real problem isn't just the risk of getting caught. Other people are making decisions based on a picture you know is wrong. The longer you put off correcting it, the harder it can become to speak openly. Often, it's wiser to admit an uncomfortable fact early than to wait for a moment when admitting it will feel completely easy.

Could you ask a parent, grandparent, or another experienced adult whether they ever put off telling an uncomfortable truth? You might hear a story from work, family life, or friendship that no textbook could give you. But listen thoughtfully: adults can make mistakes too, and they may sometimes demand more disclosure from a young person than is reasonable. Experience can inform your judgement; it doesn't give anyone permission to humiliate or control you.

What If Being Honest at Home Means a Difficult Conversation?

Seventeen-year-old Sara agreed to be home by nine. She stayed out later and didn't send a message. When she returns, her father is both worried and angry. “Why didn't you let me know?” he asks. Sara could say her phone had run out of battery. It hadn't. In truth, she simply hadn't wanted to interrupt her time with friends.

I'd advise her not to reach for an excuse that merely postpones the problem. She could say: “We agreed on nine, but I came home late and didn't message you. I understand you were worried. That was my mistake. I want to tell you what happened, but it's hard to talk when we're both shouting. Could we carry on in a few minutes?”

She isn't asking her father to forget their agreement. She's acknowledging something that affected him too and suggesting a better way to discuss it. Her father has a chance to explain his worry and talk reasonably about what should happen next. If they can keep the conversation respectful, both may learn something: Sara, how important it is to communicate a change of plans; her father, what makes it easier for her to tell the truth next time.

But one honest conversation won't automatically rebuild broken trust. Sara is more likely to regain it by communicating changes in good time, keeping reasonable agreements, and telling the truth even when it's uncomfortable. Her father, for his part, should distinguish fair consequences for a particular mistake from responding to honesty with fresh humiliation or excessive control. Trust has to be built in both directions.

A US interview study explored, among other things, how voluntary disclosure and perceived parental responses were associated with what young people said they had learned from disclosing information or lying. It involved a limited interview sample, so it can't establish one method that works for every family. It does offer a reason to think carefully about how we respond when someone trusts us with an uncomfortable truth. [6]

For parents, then, I'd recommend encouraging honesty through the way you listen as well as through what you say. Humiliation and ridicule do little to build trust, even when consequences for a broken agreement are justified. And for young people, honesty shouldn't be treated as a guarantee that there will be no consequences. An uncomfortable truth may be the beginning of a responsible conversation, not a magic way of erasing a mistake.

If there are threats of violence, intimidation, or other serious danger at home, this isn't an ordinary disagreement about a curfew. A young person shouldn't be expected to confront that danger alone. Help from a safe adult or an appropriate support service matters more.

When Shouldn't You Keep a Secret at Any Cost?

A friend tells you that someone has been threatening or hurting them. Then comes the plea: “Promise you won't tell anyone. If they find out, it'll get worse.” You may be afraid of betraying your friend's trust. But keeping a secret that leaves someone alone in danger isn't the same as protecting their privacy.

First, listen. Don't make your friend repeat everything in front of other people, don't spread the story on social media, and don't go off to confront the person causing harm yourself. You could say: “Thank you for trusting me. I'm not going to tell everyone. But we shouldn't have to deal with this on our own. Let's find someone who can help us safely.”

If the adult you'd normally turn to is part of the danger, find another trustworthy adult, a school counsellor, or appropriate professional support. Share what is needed for protection—not every detail other people might be curious about. If you're unsure what to do, you can first seek guidance from a specialist service. In Slovenia, 112 is available for emergency assistance and 113 for urgent police intervention. Children and young people can also call the TOM helpline on 116 111 for support and advice. [2][7]

There is also the opposite situation: someone threatens you and demands to know where a person at risk is hiding. Honesty doesn't require you to hand dangerous people information they could use to hurt someone. Getting to safety and protecting the person at risk come first. This isn't an excuse for everyday lying to avoid inconvenience. It's the difference between an ordinary conversation and a situation of immediate danger.

The responsibility for violence belongs to the person causing it, not the victim. No one should be pressured into a dangerous confrontation to prove their courage or honesty.

If You've Left the Wrong Impression, Correct It While It Can Still Help

Let's return to Nika. When her friend says he'll confirm the sound equipment, the best thing would be to stop him right then. If she doesn't, the next best step is to correct the impression as soon as possible: “I should have stopped you. I've only sent the request—we don't actually have the hall yet. I'm sorry I let you think we did. I'll check today, and if the venue isn't available, there's still time to make another plan.”

She can't insist that everyone immediately forget the embarrassment or trust her again straight away. But she can still prevent other people from wasting time or money because of her silence. And if she actually told someone, “We've got the hall,” she needs to acknowledge that false statement too, not just call it a misunderstanding. Making up for harm done will be explored more fully in a later article. What matters here is giving people the accurate information they need, while they can still act on it.

What Would I Recommend?

When other people need information about an agreement, money, health, or safety, tell them what you know, what you don't yet know, and what still needs checking. Don't let them plan around your guess when you know they're treating it as a fact. If you discover an error, correct it before the consequences grow.

When someone asks for a personal opinion, don't confuse honesty with putting them down. Explain what's a fact, what's your taste, and what might genuinely help. If someone is trying to draw you into gossip or wants details of another person's private life, you don't have to reveal everything: “I'm not going to talk about that” can be a perfectly honest answer.

If revealing information could put someone at risk, don't give a dangerous person details they can misuse. And if someone is in danger because a secret is being kept, seek help safely rather than putting a promise of silence above their protection.

The next time someone asks you an uncomfortable question, you don't need a perfect speech. Maybe the right answer is, “I don't know yet. I'll check.” Maybe it's, “That's not my story to tell.” In danger, it may be, “I need help.” All three can be honest, even though they reveal very different amounts. You build trust by telling people in time what they can rely on—and by protecting what others have trusted you to keep private.

Sources and Further Reading

[1] Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, The Definition of Lying and Deception (2008; updated 2015). Philosophical overview. Explores definitions; it doesn't supply a single moral answer.
[2] United Nations / UNICEF, Convention on the Rights of the Child, especially Articles 16 and 19. Convention text. Does not automatically settle individual legal situations.
[3] Cui, D., Zhang, X., and Li, Y. (2026). Children's prosocial lying: Polite versus altruistic lies in different social contexts. International Journal of Behavioral Development, 50(1), 83–92; first published online in 2025. DOI: 10.1177/01650254241312140. A study of children, not a rule for all adolescents.
[4] Turchio, V. M., and Evans, A. D. (2024). Moral evaluations of children's truths and lies in a prosocial context: The role of reputation. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 239, 105825; first published online in 2023. DOI: 10.1016/j.jecp.2023.105825. Evaluations of hypothetical situations.
[5] Fran / ZRC SAZU, Slovar pregovorov in sorodnih paremioloških izrazov (Dictionary of Proverbs and Related Paremiological Expressions), “Laž ima kratke nogé.” Slovenian dictionary entry. Documents the saying's meaning, not its exact historical origin.
[6] Smetana, J. G., Li, Y., and Mncwabe, S. (2024). Voluntariness, timing, and consistency in adolescent routine disclosure and lying to parents. Journal of Adolescence, 96(1), 152–166. DOI: 10.1002/jad.12265. US interview research with 131 participants; it does not establish causation.
[7] Government of Slovenia (GOV.SI), Emergency Call. Emergency numbers 112, 113, and TOM 116 111. These Slovenian contacts must be rechecked before the series is published as a whole.