Occultism: Knowledge Hidden from the Uninitiated
Who decides which knowledge is available to everyone and which is reserved for a select few? Throughout the history of religion and philosophy, we repeatedly encounter the idea that deeper understanding cannot be reached simply by reading books: a person also needs inner preparation, a teacher, or a particular experience.
Editorial illustration.
Who decides which knowledge is available to everyone and which is reserved for a select few? Throughout the history of religion and philosophy, we repeatedly encounter the idea that deeper understanding cannot be reached simply by reading books: a person also needs inner preparation, a teacher, or a particular experience. This understanding of knowledge appears in various esoteric traditions, from philosophical texts and spiritual teachings to organized brotherhoods and initiatory orders. For an investigation of hidden power, it is important to understand how authority based on the promise of special knowledge can become authority over another person.
What Is Occultism?
The word occult comes from the Latin occultus, meaning hidden. In the history of European thought, it was also used to describe supposed forces and properties of nature considered inaccessible to ordinary perception. In the history of Western esotericism, however, occultism is not simply a name for every secret teaching. Esotericism is a broader scholarly category encompassing different traditions and ways of understanding humanity, nature, and the divine. In its narrower historical sense, occultism refers primarily to currents that took shape in the modern era and acquired a distinctive expression in the nineteenth century. The boundaries between these terms are not entirely fixed, so it matters who uses them and in what historical context. [1][2]
Secrecy can take several forms. A text may be available only to a limited circle, or it may be publicly accessible but written in a symbolic language that its interpreters believe not everyone can understand. In initiatory associations, this may be accompanied by a formal distribution of knowledge according to degrees of initiation. Restricting access, claiming a special understanding of a teaching, and maintaining an organizational hierarchy may overlap, but they are not the same thing.
Hermeticism: Between Inner Knowledge and Silence
Hermetic writings attributed to Hermes Trismegistus form one of the important traditions of Western esotericism. According to the prevailing historical dating, the collection now known as the Corpus Hermeticum belongs to the first centuries of the Common Era and the setting of Roman Egypt. Hermes Trismegistus appears as a mythical authority and transmitter of wisdom. These texts explore the origins of the world, human nature, and humanity’s relationship with the divine. [3]
The first text in the collection, Poimandres, describes a revelation received by the narrator from the divine mind. In the narrative, knowledge is linked to a transformation in how a person understands themselves. At the end, the disciple does not withdraw into a closed circle of initiates but begins to share the message with other people. The thirteenth text, by contrast, depicts a different mode of instruction. Tat asks Hermes for the teaching on spiritual rebirth that the teacher had promised once Tat was inwardly prepared. In the dialogue, Tat is also called upon to remain silent. [3][4]
In this second dialogue, spiritual transformation also involves overcoming inner faults such as greed, envy, anger, and malice. Secrecy is associated with inner readiness, not merely with possessing information. Yet a comparison of these two texts shows that the Hermetic tradition cannot be reduced to a single way of accessing knowledge. The desire to communicate wisdom and the demand for confidentiality concerning a particular teaching both appear within it. [3][4] These are literary and religious-philosophical sources. They testify to how their authors understood spiritual knowledge. By themselves, they do not establish that a single ancient organization controlled the transmission of these teachings or political events across the centuries.
The Renaissance: From Manuscript to Printed Book
In the fifteenth century, the Hermetic tradition acquired a new place in European intellectual history. At the request of Cosimo de’ Medici, Marsilio Ficino translated the fourteen Greek Hermetic texts then available to him into Latin in 1463. His translation was first printed in 1471. The patronage of an influential Florentine made the translation possible, while printing broadened access to these writings beyond readers of Greek. [5][6]
In his preface, Ficino described a tradition of ancient theology believed to begin with Hermes and culminate in Plato. In his account, he portrayed Hermes as a philosopher, priest, and king. A translation of the preface also records his thanks to Cosimo for the books and financial resources that enabled him to study Greek. This is a valuable example of direct testimony concerning the relationship between patronage and the development of knowledge. Yet the imagined succession of sages must be distinguished from a historically documented succession of organizations. [6]
In the early seventeenth century, the French-Swiss philologist Isaac Casaubon questioned the then widespread belief in the exceptional antiquity of the Hermetic writings. In 1614, he published a critique of historical chronology that also addressed the attribution of prophetic knowledge to Hermes. He thereby made an important contribution to changing the historical understanding of these texts. This does not determine their spiritual or philosophical value, nor does it rule out older cultural motifs. It does mean that the presumed antiquity of a teaching should not be confused with the documented age of surviving texts. [3][7]
Agrippa and the Occult Philosophy of Nature
A Renaissance view of the world is also evident in Heinrich Cornelius Agrippa’s De occulta philosophia. In the first chapter of Book One, he presents three levels of what he understands as magic: natural, celestial, and ceremonial. These correspond to his understanding of the elemental, celestial, and intellectual worlds. For Agrippa, the levels of creation are interconnected, and magic was supposed to enable human beings to understand and make use of those connections. [8]
Agrippa’s ideas must be read in a historical context in which the distinctions between natural science, astrology, philosophy, and religion were not the same as they are today. His work allows us to understand his worldview, but it is not experimental proof that the magical procedures he describes are effective. What matters for our investigation is above all the belief that hidden relationships exist in nature and that someone possessing the relevant knowledge can understand them better than others.
Modern Occultism and the Idea of an Original Hidden Doctrine
In the nineteenth century, the French writer Éliphas Lévi, whose real name was Alphonse-Louis Constant, became one of the central figures of modern occultism. In Dogme et rituel de la haute magie, he searched for traces of a common doctrine among different religious images, symbols, alchemical writings, and initiatory customs. In the introduction to the first volume of the second edition, published in 1861, he described it as “une doctrine partout la même et partout soigneusement cachée” — “a doctrine that is everywhere the same and everywhere carefully concealed” (our translation). He also attributed a former dominance in society to occult philosophy, at a time when, according to his account, it was reserved for the education of priests and kings. [9]
This passage is especially important to an investigation of hidden power. The notion of a body of knowledge reserved for a select few and associated with authority does not appear only in later theories about occultism; it is explicitly present in the writings of an influential occultist. Whether similarities between traditions point to a common origin, later mutual influences, or comparable symbolic ideas remains an open question. Lévi’s text establishes what his interpretation was, not that his interpretation was historically true.
The historian of religion Julian Strube emphasizes that the development of Lévi’s ideas should also be understood in the context of nineteenth-century French political, religious, and social debates. Lévi’s earlier participation in the socialist intellectual milieu is important for understanding his later spiritual thought. Such a historical interpretation shows that modern occultism was not merely the passive preservation of older teachings but also their transformation in response to new social questions. [10]
From Tradition to an Actual Organization
One concrete example of the combination of different esoteric traditions is Germany’s Fraternitas Saturni, founded by Eugen Grosche in Berlin on 8 May 1926. The Secret State Archives of Prussian Cultural Heritage in Berlin hold collection I. HA Rep. 239, devoted to this association. The archive’s historical description records a combination of Hermetic, alchemical, Rosicrucian, Kabbalistic, and astrological elements. The collection comprises 135 archival units. [11]
The archival description also identifies a specific internal structure: the lodge was led by a Master of the Chair, assisted by two wardens. A novitiate was followed by three main degrees and then higher degrees of initiation. The system was partly modeled on Freemasonry. Here we encounter a documented example in which esoteric teachings, initiation, and organizational hierarchy were brought together within the same institution. That does not mean its internal hierarchy also amounted to authority beyond the lodge. [11]
Such documentation matters because it allows us to move from general ideas about occult associations to the study of a specific institution. But an archival collection description is not the same as an examination of its individual records. We therefore cannot infer from it that the association directed political decisions or answered to an alleged higher global hierarchy. Such a conclusion would require further evidence concerning membership, authority, instructions, and concrete actions.
When examining similar orders, it is important to distinguish intellectual inheritance, personal connections, and institutional continuity. The first means that later authors or groups adopt earlier teachings. The second means that the same individuals participate in different circles. The third requires evidence of actual organizational succession. None of these three phenomena, on its own, proves the existence of common political leadership.
When Does Hidden Knowledge Become a Means of Power?
A teacher may introduce a particular teaching gradually so that a student can understand it more easily. Confidentiality may protect privacy and allow for the free pursuit of spiritual questions. Yet the relationship between the person who controls access and the person seeking it can also create an imbalance of power. If further knowledge depends on unconditional obedience, if questioning is forbidden, or if leaving a community brings threats, the nature of the relationship changes.
For this reason, when studying initiatory institutions, it is not enough to ask which symbols they use or which secrets they guard. We must also establish who has the right to make decisions, to whom that person is accountable, whether a member can freely refuse a demand, and whether there is independently verifiable evidence of abuse. These are criteria for assessing concrete conduct, not accusations against all esoteric communities.
Likewise, we must distinguish spiritual influence from political power. Belief in invisible masters or a higher order may form an important part of an individual’s or association’s worldview. The historical and social influence of that belief is a legitimate research question; whether the supernatural beings described actually exist and direct events in the world is a separate question that belief alone cannot settle.
Secrecy, then, is not in itself evidence of evil, just as claiming a spiritual mission is no guarantee of moral conduct. What matters is what knowledge does to a person and what that person does to others with it. Does it lead to greater inner freedom, responsibility, and respect for others, or does it become a means of demanding their submission? If the purpose of knowledge is to overcome greed, deception, and cruelty, it makes sense to judge those who transmit it by the same standards in their use of authority.
Next in the Series
The next article examines the Rosicrucians: the enigmatic manifestos, the idea of a hidden spiritual brotherhood, and the question of which historical links between a tradition and actual orders can be documented.
Sources and further reading
- University of Amsterdam. Western esotericism. Introduction to the field of study. Source
- Marco Pasi (2015). Occult/Occultism. Vocabulary for the Study of Religion, 2, 555–561. Academic abstract. Source
- Matthew Andrews (2026). Corpus Hermeticum I. Center for the Study of World Religions, Harvard Divinity School. Introduction and discussion. Source
- Corpus Hermeticum XIII: The Secret Sermon on the Mountain, trans. G. R. S. Mead (1906), §§ 1, 7–10, 22. Accessible English transcription; parallel transcription of the 1906 edition, pp. 219–233; academic edition, trans. Brian P. Copenhaver (1992) (excerpt available). Source 1 Source 2 Source 3
- Maurizio Campanelli (2019). Marsilio Ficino’s portrait of Hermes Trismegistus and its afterlife. Intellectual History Review 29(1), 53–71. Academic abstract; DOI. Source 1 Source 2
- Marsilio Ficino. Preface to Pimander (1463). Ficino’s Hermetic Translations: English Translation of His Latin Pimander, preface, pp. 2–3 (accessible English version; the identity and edition of the translation have not been conclusively verified bibliographically). Source
- Florian Ebeling (2011). Seventeenth Century: High Point and Decline. The Secret History of Hermes Trismegistus, 91–114. Section on Casaubon’s dating. Source
- Heinrich Cornelius Agrippa. Three Books of Occult Philosophy, English edition of 1651, Book I, Chapter 1. Transcription of the translation. Source
- Éliphas Lévi (1861). Dogme et rituel de la haute magie, second expanded edition, I: Dogme, introduction, pp. 63–64. Digital edition, text retrieval; English translation by A. E. Waite, introduction. The French passage was checked against text retrieved from the digitized edition; a page image was not available for inspection. Source 1 Source 2
- Julian Strube (2016). Socialist Religion and the Emergence of Occultism: A Genealogical Approach to Socialism and Secularization in 19th-Century France. Religion 46(3), 359–388. Academic abstract. Source
- Guido Behnke / Geheimes Staatsarchiv Preußischer Kulturbesitz (2019). Einleitung, I. HA Rep. 239 Fraternitas Saturni, §§ 1, 4. Archival collection description. Source