How Do I Know What's Right When Everyone Gives Me Different Advice?
How to weigh conflicting advice without dismissing people who mean well—or letting them make the decision for you.
How to weigh conflicting advice without dismissing people who mean well—or letting them make the decision for you.
The school-project and holiday-job scenarios, including all dialogue, are fictional. The two proverbs are documented in a Slovenian dictionary; their application to the situations in this article is an editorial interpretation, not a historical account.
“Let's just say we all did the same amount of work. We're friends, aren't we?”
You're working on a group project that counts towards your grade. Two students have done most of the work; a third has often been absent. The teacher asks for a short account of what each person contributed. One friend suggests signing a report saying everyone contributed equally, to avoid an argument. Another says that wouldn't be fair. At home, someone tells you, “Tell the truth.” But a person you trust adds, “Don't tell everyone things you don't actually know.”
So who's right? Perhaps each person has noticed something important, yet none of them has given you the whole answer.
Here's my first piece of advice: don't choose between people before you've examined their reasons. Find out what's true, what each person is trying to protect, and how your actions would affect others. If someone is asking you to lie or treat another person unfairly, you don't have to go along with it. But doing the right thing doesn't require you to embarrass someone unnecessarily.
Two People Can Disagree—and Both Want What's Best for You
When your friend urges you to stand by the group, they may not be thinking about cheating. They may be afraid that one school assignment could damage a friendship. Parents who insist on an honest account may see something you haven't considered: once you've signed a statement you know isn't true, it can be harder to expect others to trust your word next time. Your teacher, meanwhile, needs to understand what happened so the work can be assessed fairly.
Those aren't necessarily three opposing camps. They're three ways of looking at the same event.
But there's a distinction worth remembering: understanding someone's reason doesn't mean you have to follow their advice. Wanting peace in the group is understandable. It doesn't make a false report a good idea. And “always tell everyone everything” can be poor advice too, especially if it means publicly revealing a friend's private difficulties when those details aren't needed to explain who did the work.
The same thing happens in families. Your father might advise caution because he remembers the cost of a rushed decision. Your mother might encourage you to seize an opportunity because she sees an ability you haven't yet recognised in yourself. Your grandfather might remind you of a promise you made. A friend may understand how things feel at school better than anyone else. Their experiences differ. That's exactly why it's worth hearing them out—and why no single voice automatically has the complete answer.
Are You Disagreeing About Facts, Priorities, or Right and Wrong?
It's easy to overlook the difference.
Suppose the argument is about whether someone submitted their part of the project on time. That's a question of fact. A vote—or the most confident voice in the room—won't settle it. Check the submitted files, messages and agreed deadlines. If the evidence isn't clear, be honest about what you don't know.
Now imagine you all agree about what happened, but disagree about whether to finish the project immediately or give your classmate one more day. That's a disagreement about priorities and consequences. Both suggestions may have merit. The first protects the deadline and the effort of those who have already worked hard; the second makes room for someone who is struggling. You might be able to speak to the teacher, divide the remaining work differently, or ask for a fair extension—if that's an option.
But if someone wants you to knowingly sign an untrue report, there's also a moral question. You're no longer deciding which option feels easiest. You're deciding whether convenience is worth deceiving someone and overlooking the work others have done.
Sometimes, though, the disagreement isn't moral at all. Your friend likes music you can't stand. Your grandparents find a particular hairstyle unusual. Differences in taste don't prove that one person is better than another. Ask whether the issue is real harm, a promise or agreement, what's suitable for an occasion, or simply a personal choice. If you treat all these things as the same, you can end up arguing needlessly with people who might otherwise have something valuable to teach you.
When a Friend Tells You Something in Confidence
There's more to the school-project story. The classmate who has often been absent speaks to you privately. In the afternoons, they've been looking after a younger brother, which is why they couldn't do as much of the project as everyone else. They ask you not to tell the class.
Now you understand better why your friend asked for some leniency. But you can't turn their difficulties into work they didn't do. And the students who contributed more deserve an honest account of their efforts.
You have several options. You could sign a report saying everyone contributed equally. That might avoid an argument today, but it would mislead the teacher. You could tell the entire class what's happening at home. That might explain the absences, but it would also expose something shared with you in confidence. Or you could try a harder—and usually better—approach: keep the account of the work separate from the private reasons behind it.
You might say: “I won't tell people about your brother. You trusted me with that. But I can't sign something saying we did equal amounts of work. We can write honestly about who did what, and you can speak to the teacher privately about what's been going on. If you'd like, I'll come with you.”
That's a suggestion, not a magic solution. Your friend might be angry. The teacher might not be able to change the grading. Other group members may insist that the tasks should have been agreed earlier. Still, compared with lying or exposing someone's private life in public, this approach does a better job of protecting several important things at once. If your friend doesn't want to explain their home situation, don't force them to. You can still tell the truth about the work you actually saw or did.
This is where simple rules such as “always side with your friends” or “always listen to adults” stop being enough. Good advice takes account of people and circumstances that the first piece of advice may have overlooked.
Why Can a Confident Voice Sound More Convincing Than It Should?
Some people speak with such certainty that you begin to doubt yourself. “Trust me, I know.” “Everyone agrees.” “Nothing bad will happen.” They may sincerely believe what they're saying. But confidence isn't evidence.
Friends and classmates can be especially influential. A research review by Laursen and Veenstra explains how going along with peers can help young people maintain closeness and a sense of belonging. Peer influence can also encourage helpful behaviour, including greater commitment to schoolwork; it isn't always harmful. [1] That's an account of how social influence works, not an excuse for whatever someone chooses to do.
When someone tries to persuade you, pay attention to what they say, not just how confidently they say it. A person who can explain the basis for an opinion—and admit what they're unsure about—may help you more than someone who promises absolute certainty.
It's also worth asking where their knowledge comes from. A classmate may understand the mood in your group but not know how the teacher marks the assignment. A teacher can explain the grading criteria but may know little about each student's situation at home. Parents have experience of promises, disagreements and their consequences, but they may miss something about school life today. It makes sense to ask several people, each about the part they genuinely understand.
And consider who benefits from the advice—and who lives with its consequences. Your friend's suggestion that everyone sign the same report may spare them an awkward conversation. But you'll share the responsibility for putting your name to something untrue. That doesn't make your friend a bad person. It means their wish to avoid conflict isn't the only thing that matters.
What Can Two Old Slovenian Proverbs Teach Us?
Two traditional Slovenian sayings shed light on different sides of this dilemma. The first, “Več glav več ve”—literally, “More heads know more,” close in spirit to the English saying “Two heads are better than one”—is recorded in a Slovenian dictionary of proverbs. Its explanation highlights how working together can help us understand and solve problems. [2] But more people don't necessarily mean more truth. If ten friends repeat the same mistaken assumption, it remains a mistake.
The second, “Čisti računi, dobri prijatelji”, means roughly “Clear accounts make good friends.” It, too, is documented in the Slovenian proverb dictionary. A related saying, “Čisti računi, dolga ljubezen”—“Clear accounts, lasting affection”—emphasises the importance of clear agreements and settled obligations in maintaining good relationships. [3] This isn't only about money. A school project is less likely to strain a friendship when everyone knows who has agreed to do what—and how the group will respond if someone genuinely cannot do their part.
These proverbs aren't proof that an old rule is always right. They do, however, preserve a valuable insight: hear different people out, but be clear about your commitments. A conversation with your parents or grandparents can be more useful if, instead of asking only “What should I do?”, you also ask, “Have you ever had to choose between two pieces of good advice? What surprised you? What would you do differently now?”
The most interesting answer might not be “Do what I did.” They may tell you about a mistake that changed how they think.
What If Both Choices Are Reasonable?
Another fictional scenario. A seventeen-year-old is offered holiday work in a small workshop. He's excited about earning his first money and learning practical skills. The owner encourages him to take the opportunity. His mother supports the idea of becoming more independent but wants to know the working hours and who will be responsible for safety. His grandfather reminds him that he's already promised to help his friends organise an event.
Nobody is asking him to do something obviously wrong. But if he takes the job, he may break his promise. If he turns it down, he may miss a valuable opportunity. If he tries to do everything, he could end up exhausted—or late for every commitment.
The useful question isn't which person he likes most. It's what the actual arrangements would be: which days he'd work, what he'd be paid or what terms he'd agree to, what tasks he'd do, how safety would be handled, exactly what he'd promised his friends, and whether he could honestly rearrange anything. Rules on work by minors need to be checked for the relevant country and type of job; a friendly offer is no reason to skip that step.
Perhaps he finds he can work for only part of the holiday and still keep his promise. Perhaps the arrangements are too vague, and waiting would be wiser. Or perhaps he needs to admit to his friends that he's promised more than he can manage, giving them time to find someone else to help. Each option carries a cost. But now he's comparing real possibilities, not just one person's enthusiasm with another's worries.
In situations like this, there isn't always one answer that's equally good for everyone. One person has more family responsibilities; another has different health needs; someone else has already made a commitment. The moral standards can remain the same—don't deceive people, honour your promises, don't put others at risk—while the wisest choice among acceptable options depends on the circumstances.
When Should You Ask Again—and When Should You Act?
When advice conflicts, there's nothing wrong with saying, “Tell me what worries you, and what your advice is based on.” You're not attacking the person; you're trying to understand their reasoning. You can also ask what might change their mind. A good adviser rarely needs to shut down reasonable questions.
If the disagreement is about information, check the facts. If it's about an agreement, clarify your obligations. If people have different tastes or family customs, look for a respectful way to live with those differences, provided no one is being harmed and no important duty is being neglected. But if someone is asking you to humiliate another person deliberately, cheat, or cause other serious harm, neither their popularity nor their age makes that acceptable.
It isn't always safe to stand up to someone who is threatening, blackmailing or violent. In that situation, don't try to win the argument alone. Your safety and help from a trusted adult or appropriate service come first. That isn't an ordinary disagreement between people who mean well.
And what if you've already made your decision, then learn something important that changes the picture? Reconsider it. Admitting you were wrong isn't a defeat. People who truly care about you may trust you more when they see that the truth matters to you more than looking as though you're never mistaken.
So What Do I Recommend?
When different people give you different advice, first find out whether they're actually talking about the same issue. One may know the facts; another may see the consequences; a third may remember a promise you've made. Listen to older people's experience, but ask for their reasons. Listen to your friends, but don't confuse their approval with proof. Whenever possible, check what people disagree about.
If the issue is a matter of taste, there may be room for several good choices. If you're trying to honour a difficult agreement, look for a solution that treats your commitments and the people involved fairly. But if someone is asking you to lie or act unjustly, my advice is not to go along with it—even if most people agree with them. Find a way to tell the truth without needless humiliation, and try not to cause further harm while doing what's right.
In the school-project case, that means giving an honest account of who did what. You don't need to announce someone's private difficulties to the class. And you can offer to support your friend if they choose to speak to the teacher privately. That way, you don't sacrifice honesty to save a friendship—or mistake friendship for permission to lie.
You don't have to know everything. But it's worth knowing why you trust someone's advice—and what you're willing to do when you discover that someone else has a better reason.
Sources and Further Reading
Laursen, B., and Veenstra, R. (2021). Toward Understanding the Functions of Peer Influence: A Summary and Synthesis of Recent Empirical Research. Journal of Research on Adolescence, 31(4), 889–907. DOI: 10.1111/jora.12606. A review covering both helpful and harmful peer influence and the role of belonging.
ZRC SAZU, Fran, Dictionary of Proverbs and Related Paremiological Expressions (Slovar pregovorov in sorodnih paremioloških izrazov), entry “Več glav več ve”. Documents the Slovenian saying and its meaning in collaboration and understanding.
ZRC SAZU, Fran, Dictionary of Proverbs and Related Paremiological Expressions (Slovar pregovorov in sorodnih paremioloških izrazov), entry “Čisti računi, dolga ljubezen” and the related saying “Čisti računi, dobri prijatelji” recorded alongside it. Meaning: clear arrangements and obligations help support good relationships.