How Can I Break a Harmful Habit and Stick With a Good One?
Why making another promise often isn't enough — and how to change something you keep doing.
Why making another promise often isn't enough — and how to change something you keep doing.
“Tonight I'm really going to bed on time,” you tell yourself over dinner. Later, you check one message, then watch a short video, and before you know it, it's much later than you thought. The next day you're tired and make exactly the same promise. Perhaps your problem has nothing to do with your phone. Perhaps you've wanted for ages to practise an instrument regularly, stop putting things off, put your things away when you should, or stop interrupting people. Things go well for a while, and then the old behaviour returns.
What hurts most may be the thought that follows: “I know what I should do. So why don't I do it?” Someone tells you that you simply need more discipline. Someone else thinks your goals are too ambitious. Both may have a point. But neither tells you what to do differently tomorrow evening.
The short answer: don't try to overcome a habit by making yet another promise. First, find out when you repeat it and what you get out of it at that moment. Take away at least one incentive for the harmful behaviour, and give the good habit a realistic time and place to start. If your plan falls apart, adjust it and carry on. First, though, ask whether the goal is genuinely worthwhile — and whether this is a problem you can safely deal with on your own.
Why Does the Old Habit Return Just When I Don't Want It To?
When you reach for your toothbrush in the morning, you don't think through every movement. You know where it is, and you simply get on with the task. Familiar activities like these make everyday life easier. But something you want to stop doing can become just as familiar: you automatically open an app as soon as you get home, find another task when faced with an unpleasant one, or begin replying before the other person has finished speaking.
Research suggests that repeating an action in similar circumstances can strengthen the link between the situation and the action. A habit, then, isn't necessarily the result of a fresh, deliberate decision every time. Of course, this doesn't explain every human action, much less determine its moral worth. It does suggest something useful: if you want to change something you keep doing, pay attention to the circumstances as well as your willpower. [1][2]
Think back to the most recent time it happened, rather than the worst one. What happened just before it? Where were you? Were you tired, bored, or overwhelmed? What did you get out of doing it at that moment? Perhaps it brought welcome attention from friends, a short break, or the feeling that you'd escaped a task you didn't know how to begin.
That last question matters. If scrolling through your phone is how you unwind, simply taking it away doesn't answer the question of how you'll rest instead. If fear of failure is making you postpone studying, perhaps what you need first isn't extra hours at your desk but help understanding the material you're stuck on. And if you interrupt someone because you're worried you'll forget what you wanted to say, try waiting and, if necessary, jotting down a few words. Sometimes lasting change begins when you discover what you were trying to achieve through the old behaviour.
Who Says It's a Bad Habit?
Before you set about changing something, ask another question: Who is this habit harming, and how? One person likes chatting with friends every evening; another enjoys drawing, reading comics, or playing games. An activity isn't harmful simply because it isn't schoolwork or a job. Rest matters, too.
It's different when a repeated activity starts costing you sleep, affecting your health, disrupting agreements, or hurting other people. If you repeatedly borrow things without asking, the problem isn't merely that you're “disorganised”; you're disregarding someone else's rights. If you go to bed too late every night, the important consequence is your tiredness, not simply your parents' dislike of how you relax. When a pattern has consequences like these, there are good reasons to change it.
People at home may see the situation differently. A parent notices a pile of things you haven't put away or a light still on late at night; you see all the responsibilities you've already dealt with that day. Rather than having a general argument about “laziness”, it helps to ask: “What exactly worries you? Which agreement haven't I kept?” Then explain your side. You may discover that something really does need to change. Or you may first need to agree on a more realistic division of tasks or expectations.
Someone else's demand isn't automatically a moral standard. Nor does every disagreement mean the other person fails to understand you. When your reasons for changing are rooted in consequences for health, relationships, trust, and agreements, you have a firmer basis for persistence than merely trying to please or impress somebody.
Vid: What Happens Before “Just One More Video”?
The following story is fictional.
Vid enjoys chatting with friends after dinner. He usually takes his phone to bed. He intends to reply to his messages, but notifications often draw him into something else. In the morning, he struggles to get up. His father is tired of the nightly arguments and says, “You said yourself you'd put it away.”
“I meant to,” Vid replies. “But when someone messages me, I look.”
“Then don't keep it in your room at all.”
“What if a friend really needs me?”
The conversation could have ended in another argument. This time, though, they take a closer look at what's actually happening. Vid realises that he usually isn't deliberately searching for videos: he opens a notification when he's already lying in bed and carries on from there. His father explains that he doesn't object to Vid's friendships; he's worried about how tired Vid is. They agree to try a different routine: Vid will finish his conversations before bedtime, silence non-essential notifications, and put his phone away from the bed, while making sure urgent calls can still get through. He also sets aside something he genuinely enjoys doing to unwind without a screen.
That doesn't guarantee the problem is solved. Vid may discover that worries, schoolwork, or an irregular bedtime are also keeping him awake. If so, they'll have to look at the bigger picture. But he's changed one very specific thing: the moment when the old habit usually begins.
For teenagers aged roughly 13 to 18, professional recommendations generally call for eight to ten hours of sleep in every 24 hours, although individual needs vary. [5] So Vid's experiment has a real purpose. The point isn't to prove that technology is bad, but to protect his rest. N46 will look separately at phones, games, and their effects on everyday life. Here, the phone is simply an example of how changing your surroundings can help you change a habit.
How Do You Make Room for a Good Habit Once the Excitement Wears Off?
Giving up something familiar is one challenge. Starting something worthwhile is another. Sometimes the hardest part is finding room in your life for a new activity when you aren't particularly good at it yet. The idea of learning a language or a musical instrument may be exciting; the first slow practice session may be much less appealing.
“Starting tomorrow, I'm going to work harder on improving myself every day” sounds determined, but it doesn't tell you what you'll do when you come home exhausted. It helps more to link the action to a particular moment: “When I've cleared my plate after lunch, I'll open my music book and practise one chord shape.” Or: “When I put down my schoolbag, I'll get tomorrow's notebook ready first.” Research suggests that such plans, linking a recognisable situation to an action in advance, can help people follow through on their intentions. The effects aren't the same for everyone or every goal. [4]
A good habit doesn't require a fixed, supposedly magical number of minutes. Five minutes of practice might be a sensible beginning, but it isn't a rule for everybody. One person can practise longer; another has to adapt a goal because of school, work, illness, or family responsibilities. There's a big difference between asking “How much could I manage on my best day?” and “What would be worth repeating on an ordinary day?”
Don't overlook another option: if you discover you don't know how to do the task, ask someone to explain it. If you don't have time, take a closer look at your schedule. If you lack the equipment or a quiet space, look for a workable arrangement. More effort can't always make up for missing the conditions you need.
Tara and Her Grandmother: Is Practice Worthwhile Only When It's Perfect?
This story is fictional, too.
Tara receives a guitar from her grandmother. She's wanted to learn for a long time, so on the first evening she practises for almost two hours. Over the next few days, schoolwork, a workshop, and late arrivals home pile up. The guitar stays in its case. Tara begins taking it out only when she knows she'll have plenty of time — and days like that hardly ever come.
When her grandmother asks how it's going, Tara shrugs. “I haven't been practising. And every time I start, my fingers get tangled up.”
“It was slow going for me at first, too,” her grandmother says. “You know I practised a lot.”
“You did. I obviously can't keep it up.”
“I don't expect you to practise on my schedule. Show me where you're getting stuck.”
Tara tries the chord shape she keeps getting stuck on. Her grandmother shows her how to do it more slowly. They also realise that on some days Tara gets home so late that a longer practice session simply wouldn't make sense. They agree that she'll try one short exercise on ordinary days and, when things are quieter, they'll sometimes work on a whole song together. Her grandmother promises that next time she'll ask what Tara has learned, rather than how many days in a row she's practised.
Perhaps Tara will come to love playing. Or she may discover that another way of making music appeals to her more. Persistence doesn't mean being obliged to stick forever with every goal you've ever chosen. It means giving it a fair chance, thinking things through when you meet obstacles, and not giving up just because early progress doesn't look impressive.
Her grandmother's experience is valuable, but not because everyone used to be more disciplined. We often learn skills — from gardening to playing music or repairing things — alongside someone who already knows how. Asking older people how they learned and what helped them can start a much better conversation than competing over which generation worked harder. A good example includes mistakes and corrections, not just the finished result.
Does Missing One Day Wipe Out Your Progress?
When a plan is interrupted, the hardest reaction to deal with may be the thought in your head: “It doesn't matter now. I'm back where I started.” That turns one missed practice session into a reason to give up the whole ambition. But there is no universal deadline by which every habit must become automatic.
You may have heard that it takes 21 days to form a habit, or perhaps 66. The research by Lally and colleagues did not establish either number as a rule for everyone. For the everyday activities they studied, the modelled pace of developing automaticity varied considerably from person to person; missing one opportunity did not substantially alter the observed process. That is a finding about certain everyday behaviours, not evidence that all repeated actions work alike or that addiction treatment can follow the same pattern. [3]
If you miss one session, it's usually more useful to ask why than to punish yourself by trying to make up for it. If you were ill, you may have needed rest. If you keep forgetting, perhaps your plan doesn't have a good reminder. If you always struggle with the same task, it might be too difficult or you may need help. If the goal no longer seems worthwhile, you can reconsider it deliberately. That's different from abandoning it whenever it becomes a little uncomfortable.
Be fair with yourself, but be honest, too. “I didn't have time” may be true, or it may conceal the fact that you gave something less important priority. Even if you were making excuses, though, calling yourself “useless” won't help. It's far more useful to admit: “Today I avoided something I promised to do. Tomorrow I'll start before I do something else.” If you've disappointed someone else, you should say so and put right what you can. Changing a habit doesn't replace taking responsibility; it helps make the same mistake less likely to happen again.
Striving for quality and demanding flawlessness aren't the same thing. If you demand perfection from yourself, fear of making a mistake may stop you before you even begin. [7] The aim is to take a mistake seriously without making it the measure of your worth as a person.
When Is Advice About Habits Not Enough?
Sometimes the words “bad habit” conceal circumstances that call for more than a change of routine. If you're worried that you're losing control of your drinking or use of other substances, or if self-harm, dangerous restriction of food, compulsive behaviours, or severe emotional distress are involved, seek help from a trusted adult, a doctor, or another appropriate professional. If someone is physically dependent on alcohol, suddenly stopping drinking can be dangerous, so medical advice is needed, not a solo test of willpower. [6]
Nor is someone facing violence or threats responsible for making a better plan to manage the perpetrator's behaviour. Safety, protection, and help come first; you don't have to confront someone who threatens you on your own. If you are in immediate danger in Slovenia, call 112 or seek urgent assistance from the appropriate services.
If persistence is harder because of illness, differences in attention or development, lack of sleep, overload, or difficult conditions at home, that fact alone says nothing about your character. You may need a different way of working, a fairer division of responsibilities, or a professional assessment. Good advice doesn't expect exactly the same from everyone; it takes real circumstances into account without overlooking people's needs.
Cooperation can help with an ordinary change, too: a friend invites you for a walk, a parent agrees on a household task with you, or your grandmother practises alongside you. But support isn't the same as interrogating someone, checking their private messages, or shaming them in front of others. If an arrangement isn't working, you should be able to talk about it and revise it. Adults who acknowledge their own slip-ups can do more good here than those who only demand perfection.
What Would Be Wise to Do Tomorrow?
Don't choose ten new rules. Choose one repeated behaviour you have a sound reason to change. Notice when it starts and what it gives you at that moment. Then prepare one practical adjustment: make the distraction less accessible, find a better way to rest, set a clear starting point for practice, or make an arrangement with someone who can help. When the usual situation arises, try the new approach.
If it doesn't work, don't pretend nothing happened — and don't punish yourself with an impossible plan. Look honestly at what went wrong. Sometimes you need to persevere; at other times you need to scale back the goal, learn how to do the task better, or admit that you need help. What's valuable here isn't an unbroken streak of perfect days, but being honest about why you began and being willing to do something about it.
My advice is to support your willpower with the right conditions, rather than sending it into the same battle every day. If you're making progress on something important, keep going. If you get stuck, adjust your approach. And if a habit is harming you so seriously that you can't manage it safely on your own, ask for help. Character isn't built by keeping a flawless record. It also grows through the way you respond when good intentions meet real life.
Sources and Further Reading
Wood, W., and Rünger, D. (2016). Psychology of Habit. Annual Review of Psychology, 67, 289–314. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26361052/
National Institutes of Health (2012). Breaking Bad Habits: Why It's So Hard to Change. https://newsinhealth.nih.gov/2012/01/breaking-bad-habits
Lally, P., van Jaarsveld, C. H. M., Potts, H. W. W., and Wardle, J. (2010). How are habits formed: Modelling habit formation in the real world. European Journal of Social Psychology, 40, 998–1009. https://doi.org/10.1002/ejsp.674 ; an explanation of the limitations of the 66-day figure (University of Surrey): https://www.surrey.ac.uk/news/does-it-really-take-66-days-form-habit-we-asked-expert-dr-pippa-lally
Sheeran, P., Listrom, O., and Gollwitzer, P. M. (2024, published online; 2025 journal volume). The when and how of planning: Meta-analysis of the scope and components of implementation intentions in 642 tests. European Review of Social Psychology, 36(1), 162–194. https://doi.org/10.1080/10463283.2024.2334563
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Sleep and Health. https://www.cdc.gov/healthy-schools/sleep/index.html ; recommended sleep for ages 13–18: 8–10 hours per 24 hours.
NHS (2026). Alcohol-use disorder. https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/alcohol-use-disorder/
Centre for Clinical Interventions, Perfectionism: self-help resources — https://www.cci.health.wa.gov.au/Resources/Looking-After-Yourself/Perfectionism.