How Do I Know If Someone Is a Good Friend?
Good company, trust, character — and the freedom to be yourself while growing into a better person.
Good company, trust, character — and the freedom to be yourself while growing into a better person.
Nejc had been at his new school for barely a week when Tim invited him to join his friends. It meant more to Nejc than he would have admitted. He no longer had to stand alone by the sports court, pretending to look for something on his phone. Tim could make the whole group laugh. He lent Nejc his notes and stood up for him when someone mocked a bad pass he made. Sometimes they got so caught up in talking after school that Nejc missed his bus.
Then something happened that made him uneasy. During a break, a video began circulating in the group chat. It showed a classmate stumbling over his words during a presentation. Tim made a remark, the others laughed, and Nejc laughed with them. He laughed before he stopped to think. Later, it did not seem funny at all.
There was also Leon, another boy in Nejc's class. Leon was easy enough to talk to and usually kept his word. But he was not as entertaining as Tim, and Nejc did not yet feel quite at home with him. Leon had also recently made an unkind remark about another boy, although he later apologized.
So whom should Nejc get to know better? Can Tim still be a good friend if he has behaved badly? And is Leon necessarily a better choice just because he is quieter?
The short answer: you cannot recognize a good friend by popularity, by the number of messages they send, or by a single kind or unkind act. What matters is how you get along, whether you genuinely want the best for each other, whether you can rely on their word, and what happens when you disagree. You do not need to find a perfect person. But it is worth choosing people you never need to hurt others to fit in with.
Who Is Fun to Be Around — and Who Can You Count On?
Sometimes what makes a friend special is simply how good it feels to spend time together. You can laugh about silly things, talk about music, train together, or sit quietly without feeling awkward. If every conversation becomes a test of character, friendship loses something lovely: the simple pleasure of being together.
Still, enjoying someone's company and trusting them deeply are not quite the same thing. You might love playing basketball with someone but never talk to them about problems at home. Another person may be less funny, yet know how to listen when you do not feel like laughing. Both kinds of connection matter. Not every friend is a confidant, and an acquaintance that never grows into a close friendship is not a failure.
Aristotle drew attention to a similar distinction in the Nicomachean Ethics. He described friendships built around usefulness, others built around shared enjoyment, and a deeper bond in which you wish someone well for that person's own sake. For this deeper kind, he particularly emphasized time and getting to know one another. [1]
Of course, the ancient philosopher never encountered a school group chat, and we need not turn his distinctions into a ranking of “real” and “fake” friends. But think about the difference. If you and a friend rehearse for a performance, help one another, and have a good time doing it, the fact that you both benefit does not spoil your friendship. But if she only gets in touch when she needs your notes and disappears whenever you need help, you may be giving far more to the friendship than you receive.
An even more interesting question is what remains when you are no longer the funniest, most successful, or most useful person in the group. Is your friend pleased for you when something goes well, even if they wanted the same opportunity? Can they celebrate with you without making everything about themselves? Can they stand by you when you have nothing special to offer?
This does not mean keeping score. Two friends do not always have the same amount of time, money, or energy. Someone who helps care for a younger sibling at home may not be able to invite you out very often. A friend going through a difficult time may need more support for a while than they can give back. Mutual care does not mean balancing the books every Friday. It means that, over time, the other person finds ways to show that you matter too.
Can You Really Be Yourself Around Them?
Perhaps you have wondered, “Do my friends actually like me?” It is worth adding another question: “What do I become like when I am with them?”
Can you talk to your friends about something that is not popular? Can you say you did not find a joke funny without immediately being pushed out? Are you allowed to be quiet when you are having a bad day? Or do you have to invent an even wilder story each time just to get their attention?
This does not mean a good friend always agrees with you. Quite the opposite: if you have treated someone unfairly, a person who can tell you, “That wasn't right,” may be a particularly valuable friend. There is a difference between someone who tells you a difficult truth because they care, and someone who belittles you to feel superior.
Even a friendship in which you feel accepted will not always be easy. You may have different personalities. One of you likes planning ahead; the other is spontaneous. One talks a great deal; the other needs some peace and quiet. If you can make room for these differences, the friendship is no less genuine. And you can respect a good person without having enough in common to become best friends.
Research on adolescent relationships has found links between friendship quality and various aspects of well-being. That does not give us a magic number of friends, and it certainly does not mean that adding more contacts will automatically make you happier. A review of 43 studies describes associations, not a simple cause-and-effect rule for every individual. [2] So you do not need to measure yourself by how many people tag you in a photo. One dependable relationship may be worth more than a crowd of superficial contacts — although having a larger circle of pleasant companions can have a place in your life too.
What Happens When Something Goes Wrong?
Nejc spends the day wondering whether Tim is a good friend at all after what happened with the video. That evening, though, he remembers a detail he would rather overlook: he laughed too.
The next day he could pretend nothing happened. That would be easiest. Or he could angrily declare Tim a bad person and cut off all contact. Neither choice would help him face what actually happened.
He can start by making amends for his own part. If he received the video, he does not forward it. At an appropriate and safe moment, he can tell the classmate, “I laughed yesterday. That wasn't right. I'm sorry.” The apology may not be accepted immediately. Nejc cannot decide that for the other person. But he can show through changed behavior that he means what he says. If the humiliation continues or the video spreads, he should ask a trustworthy adult for help rather than try to handle a potentially dangerous confrontation on his own. Research on bullying bystanders also shows that their responses are linked to the wider school environment. Speaking up matters, but one sentence cannot be counted on to end the bullying. [3]
Nejc can speak to Tim privately: “I like spending time with you, and I appreciate that you've helped me. But that video wasn't okay. I laughed too, and I regret it. I don't want to be part of spreading it any further.”
Several things might happen. Tim may brush it off at first but then admit he went too far. He might apologize and help stop the video being shared. Perhaps he will need time to think. Or he may mock Nejc for speaking up and keep doing the same thing again and again.
These responses are not all alike. One mistake does not define a person. How they respond afterward — whether they admit it and try to put things right — can tell you a great deal. If Tim changes his behavior, Nejc has a good reason not to throw the friendship away. If Tim makes laughing at other people's expense a condition of belonging to the group, Nejc has a good reason to step back from that company. When there are threats, violence, or blackmail, the answer is to seek help, not patiently test how much more you can endure.
And Leon? He too made an unkind remark once, but later acknowledged it and apologized. That is encouraging, but it is no guarantee that he will be a perfect friend. Nejc can get to know him better while working on a project, after training, or during an ordinary conversation. He does not have to choose between two people as though deciding who has won a competition.
Why Did Older Generations Talk So Much About Keeping Your Word?
You may have heard the saying, “A friend in need is a friend indeed.” It sounds simple, but it points to an experience: kindness can come easily when everything is going well; when helping takes time, effort, or sacrifice, you may discover how much you mean to someone. That is a lesson drawn from experience, not a reason to invent hardships just to test your friends.
Family memories can also teach us something. Older relatives sometimes talk about a neighbor who brought food when someone was ill, a friend who kept a promise even when it was inconvenient, or someone who made the first move after an argument. Such stories are valuable when they tell you what someone actually did, rather than merely saying the person came from “a good family” or was “the right sort of person.” We should not invent the origins of these family practices or present them as universal customs.
In ancient Rome, Cicero made a more demanding point in his work On Friendship: we should neither ask a friend to do something dishonorable nor do it ourselves just because a friend asks us to. [4] His wider social views belong to his own time, but this warning is easy to understand today: you do a friend no favor by helping them commit a wrong.
A fictional conversation. Nejc tells his grandfather what happened, then adds, “But Tim isn't a bad person. He's helped me loads of times.” His grandfather does not answer straightaway. Then he says, “I believe you. That's why it's worth talking to him, rather than just talking about him.”
“But what if he laughs at me?”
“Then you'll learn something you don't know yet. Just speak calmly, without an audience. And don't forget you have something to put right yourself.”
That advice is not an order about whom Nejc must spend time with. It is an invitation to think about what he has already experienced, what he still does not know, and what he can do fairly. If your parents, grandparents, or another experienced adult warn you about a friend, it is worth asking what particular behavior worries them. They may have noticed something important. But a person's background, religion, appearance, or family is not, by itself, a fair basis for judging their character.
Trust Cannot Be Demanded. It Has to Be Earned.
Suppose you have known someone for only a few days when they say, “If we're really friends, tell me who you have a crush on. You can trust me, can't you?” They might mean no harm; perhaps they just expect closeness too soon. Even so, you do not owe them information you are not ready to share.
Trust usually grows through small experiences. You arrange to meet, and both show up. You share something personal, and the other person does not turn it into a joke in front of everyone. You disagree, and they remain respectful. At other times you listen when they need you. Eventually you realize that you feel more relaxed with them. A study that followed young people over time found a two-way connection: stronger friendships were followed by greater personal openness, and greater openness was followed by improvements in friendship quality. That is not an instruction to share secrets before you are ready; closeness can grow at a pace that feels safe for both people. [5]
You do not have to hand over a password, send a private photo, or give up other friends to prove your trust. Nor do you build it by inventing secret tests to see who will pass. Ordinary opportunities to be dependable, talk, and respect boundaries are enough.
You may be able to count on a friend for a school project without yet trusting them with your most personal concerns. That is not an insult. Closeness has its own timing, pace, and boundaries. And even when you are close, you do not have to tell each other everything. Becoming friends does not take away your right to privacy.
There is one important exception. If a friend tells you they are being threatened or blackmailed, or that they are thinking about harming themselves, do not promise to keep the danger a secret. Tell them you care and seek help from a trusted adult or qualified professional together. You are not betraying their trust; you are looking after their safety.
Sometimes You Simply Don't Know Enough to Judge
Another fictional scene. Sara sends Ema a message about meeting on Saturday. Ema does not reply, although Sara later sees that she has been active online. Sara feels hurt. She is already composing the message, “Obviously I don't matter to you.”
But Sara does not know that. Ema may have forgotten, be dealing with problems at home, or simply not feel like talking that day. Or perhaps the meeting really is not important to her. Instead of accusing her, Sara could write, “Hey, are we still meeting tomorrow? Please let me know so I can plan my day.” That tells Ema what Sara needs without pretending to know what she is thinking.
If Ema apologizes and they make clearer plans next time, there is no reason to turn one unanswered message into a verdict on their friendship. But if arrangements repeatedly fall apart and Sara cannot talk about it, it makes sense for her to adjust her expectations. You cannot expect a friend to be available every minute. But you should not have to keep waiting for promises that are rarely kept, either.
The same applies to differences in belief. Someone may follow another religion, come from a different culture, or disagree with your taste in music and still be a respectful and loyal friend. A close friendship does not require total sameness. It becomes harder when someone regularly mocks your beliefs or demands that you abandon them in exchange for belonging. The problem there is not difference itself but behavior. Articles N33 and N34 examine broader questions of beliefs and cultures.
What If You Haven't Found Your People Yet?
When you see groups laughing about shared memories, it can seem as though everyone else has already found their place. Yet friendships often begin slowly, through ordinary repeated encounters: seeing the same people at sports practice, work, volunteering, music sessions, a shared project, or on the way home.
If starting conversations is hard for you, you do not have to force yourself to become the loudest person in the room. You can begin with an ordinary question, offer help, suggest a walk, or get in touch again the following week. If someone does not invite you along, that does not decide your worth. Some acquaintances never become close; with others, friendship develops as you get to know each other.
It also matters that you do not simply wait for someone who has every quality on your checklist. Sometimes you have to be the first to show interest, follow through on a plan, speak up respectfully, or apologize when you have got something wrong. Friendship is not a reward for perfection but a relationship built by two imperfect people.
If loneliness is causing you serious pain over a long period, or if someone is intimidating, threatening, or hurting you, seek out someone you trust rather than dealing with it alone. In Slovenia, the free TOM helpline for children and young people is available on 116 111, every day from 12 noon to 8 p.m. In an immediate emergency involving life or health, call 112; for urgent police assistance, call 113. [6][7] These numbers and hours refer to Slovenia; readers elsewhere should use appropriate local services. If the first adult does not take you seriously, reach out to another one.
So What Would I Tell Nejc?
I would not tell Nejc to end his friendship with Tim overnight. Tim has shown him genuine kindness too. But I would not advise him to stay in Tim's group at any cost, either. First, Nejc should make amends for his own part, talk calmly to Tim, and then watch what Tim does — not just what he promises. If Tim is willing to listen, this could be an opportunity for a better friendship. If the humiliating behavior continues and Tim expects Nejc to join in, Nejc should choose different company and seek help if necessary.
He should take his time getting to know Leon. Maybe they will become good friends; maybe they will simply be pleasant acquaintances. Nejc is allowed to have different kinds of friends. He does not have to hand over all his secrets or choose just one group to prove his loyalty.
And what would I tell you? Enjoy the friends who brighten your days. Value the ones who keep their word, can hear an uncomfortable truth, and genuinely wish you well. Allow people to make mistakes, but notice whether they know how to put them right. When someone helps you, be grateful; when they act unfairly, do not excuse it just because they are “one of yours.” Listen to the experience of older people, but judge particular actions. And do your part too: do not boast about loyalty if you are nowhere to be found when a friend needs an honest word or a helping hand.
A good friend will sometimes disappoint you. It is someone with whom you can share joy, talk even when you disagree, and discover over time that you are both worthy of one another's trust. Perhaps the best part is that you do not have to pretend to be someone else to belong. With a friend like that, you can grow into the person you want to be.
Sources and Further Reading
Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics, Book VIII, especially chapters 2–3. Primary philosophical and historical source: friendships based on utility, pleasure, and virtuous character; the need for time and mutual acquaintance. Text at Perseus.
Alsarrani, A., Hunter, R. F., Dunne, L., and Garcia, L. (2022), Association between friendship quality and subjective wellbeing among adolescents: a systematic review, BMC Public Health, 22, 2420. DOI and original publication. Includes 43 studies, mostly observational; does not justify claims about individual causation or a recommended number of friends.
Waasdorp, T. E., Fu, R., Clary, L. K., and Bradshaw, C. P. (2022), School Climate and Bullying Bystander Responses in Middle and High School, Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology, 80, 101412. Study. Reports links between bystander behavior and the school environment, not a guarantee that any single intervention will work.
Cicero, Laelius de amicitia (On Friendship), especially §§40 and 44. Historical argument against dishonorable requests between friends, not a complete modern theory of friendship. Original and English translation.
Costello, M. A., et al. (2024), Adolescent social learning within supportive friendships: Self-disclosure and relationship quality from adolescence to adulthood, Journal of Research on Adolescence, 34(3), 805–817. DOI. Longitudinal sample N = 184; association between friendship quality and self-disclosure is not advice to reveal private information quickly.
TOM helpline, official contact page: free number 116 111, every day 12:00–20:00; recorded as checked in the Slovene source on 26 October 2026.
Government of the Republic of Slovenia, emergency calls: 112 for emergency services and 113 for urgent police assistance; recorded as checked in the Slovene source on 26 October 2026.